Poll How positive are you about Discovery now?

[Relayer1]

You also shouldn't support something you dislike just on the very, very unlikely chance it might lead to something you do like. It almost never happens.

True, but I don't find it that unlikely that if Trek series is a hit they'd make more (and different) Trek shows. It's happened in the past.

Well, we don't know yet if we will like Discovery. I'm gonna watch, and if I don't like, I'll quit

Oh, I won't.

I must have started watching thirty or more 'genre' shows in the last decade or two and I've bailed on all of them except Galactica before the end, but I'll ALWAYS watch (and purchase) a Trek series. I even did with Voyager...

 

[Guy Gardener]

I plugged along on The Good Wife for no reason... Half way through season 3, I realized that this was my favourite show.

 

[Ensign Ogahd Ahmganadai]

Oh, I won't.

I must have started watching thirty or more 'genre' shows in the last decade or two and I've bailed on all of them except Galactica before the end, but I'll ALWAYS watch (and purchase) a Trek series. I even did with Voyager...

I don't mean I'll watch the pilot and if I'm not thoroughly impressed saying "okay, I'm out". I'll basically do this season by season. I'll judge whether to watch the next season by whether or not I think there's potential in the season just past.

I did that for Voyager and made it all the way to Season 5. I did it for Enterprise and stopped midway through Season 2, but did end up watching re-runs and then came back for the third and fourth seasons.

 

[Jarvisimo]

Its interesting this debate in america; in the rest of the world, Discovery's position on Netflix makes it immediately available to millions of viewers, many of whom will watch it because of the medium putting it front and centre (which begun this week with the ads on homepage), the old fans and those people who liked the Abrams movies. It's a shame it isn't on Netflix there, but it makes this anger to CBS Access seem very silly - a service very little different from many paid for services.

Do you want CBS to evolve, to survive, to continue making television after TV itself stops being lucrative enough to support big budget TV without a subscription service? It is annoying to be sure but the strange resentment to the medium is bizarre, as though streaming isn't now the method most incredible TV is broadcast through in the us.

 

[kirk55555]

True, but I don't find it that unlikely that if Trek series is a hit they'd make more (and different) Trek shows. It's happened in the past.

If Discovery is a hit, they'll just make more crappy, dark & gritty, completely non-Trek shows and slap the Trek name on them. Supporting crap just leads to more crap. At least if it failed they'd try something new, even if it took awhile (unlike what some "the sky is falling" people might say, Trek is too big a franchise to just disappear, even if it takes years Trek would have a new show again even if Discovery fails, and if STD fails a new show would probably be done completely differently, which would almost certainly be a good thing). I'd rather have no Trek then terrible, franchise insulting junk if the Trek label slapped on.

 

[Ensign Ogahd Ahmganadai]

I have sort of switched to "wait and see" mode. I'm tamping down my excitement, extinguishing my expectations and preparing myself to be utterly wrong about everything I've ever said about it, good or bad. We have less than a week to go. At this point I'm finished speculating, I'm finished defending, as right around the corner is the opportunity for the show to speak for itself.

 

[Bry_Sinclair]

I've been a Trek fan since I was a bairn. The announcement of a new show airing in less than a week should excite and captivate me, but it's just not. When it was first announced I was very excited and part of me wants to get back that level of enthusiasm and anticipation, but I just can't. A little disappointed in myself for becoming so jaded by my mid-30s.

 

[Relayer1]

I've been a Trek fan since I was a bairn. The announcement of a new show airing in less than a week should excite and captivate me, but it's just not. When it was first announced I was very excited and part of me wants to get back that level of enthusiasm and anticipation, but I just can't. A little disappointed in myself for becoming so jaded by my mid-30s.

I'm mid 50's but I get where you're coming from. I may be excited about Discovery, but Star Wars 8 is another matter...

 

[Starfury]

I've been a Trek fan since I was a bairn. The announcement of a new show airing in less than a week should excite and captivate me, but it's just not. When it was first announced I was very excited and part of me wants to get back that level of enthusiasm and anticipation, but I just can't. A little disappointed in myself for becoming so jaded by my mid-30s.

My excitement stopped the moment Bryan Fuller sat in front of an eager crowd and all he could think of was to ask them which captain they liked most. That moment I knew there was no vision behind Discovery.

 

[Ridcully]

Well he is not on anymore!

 

[tomalak301]

I'm still cautiously optimistic about the show but we're like a work week away from when it starts and I should feel a lot more excited than I am. Maybe it's dreading another show being added to my already growing list, or the tone of the show kind of feels depressing, or it will be weird watching on a streaming site, which I've already purchased. I'm still going to watch with eager anticipation but this should be a huge special occasion and I don't really feel "special" about it yet.

 

[Ridcully]

As long as they are better than Enterprise...I am good!
They have made very nice sets(wherever you like them or not, and good looking ships and such)....
So they are clearly doing all out(again in spite of the old grumpy "fanbase").

 

[BillJ]

I have sort of switched to "wait and see" mode. I'm tamping down my excitement, extinguishing my expectations and preparing myself to be utterly wrong about everything I've ever said about it, good or bad.

Why? Part of the fun of life is speculating about the unknown. Whether it be God, aliens or a TV show you haven't seen yet.

Just don't expect everyone to agree with your speculations.

 

[BillJ]

They have made very nice sets...

They've made very expensive sets. Nice is in the eye of the beholder.

 

[Ensign Ogahd Ahmganadai]

Why? Part of the fun of life is speculating about the unknown. Whether it be God, aliens or a TV show you haven't seen yet.

Just don't expect everyone to agree with your speculations.

This again. I'm still struggling to figure out why what I said makes people think I demand agreement from everyone. I haven't said anything other users like Mage or Mr. Awe haven't said.

 

[BillJ]

This again. I'm still struggling to figure out why what I said makes people think I demand agreement from everyone. I haven't said anything other users like Mage or Mr. Awe haven't said.

You just come off as a bit troubled that people aren't as excited about the show as you are.

 

[Ensign Ogahd Ahmganadai]

You just come off as a bit troubled that people aren't as excited about the show as you are.

And some (not you) seem angry that others are looking forward to it.

 

[Ridcully]

Can't make me unhappy....

 

[Tuskin38]

And some (not you) seem angry that others are looking forward to it.

I'm not getting that at all.

 

[Ensign Ogahd Ahmganadai]

I'm not getting that at all.

I think I just need to take a step back from the whole ordeal. I'm clearly not objective, and soon we'll find out if anything any of us are feeling is warranted.

I'll say this; Monday, I fully predict about half the posts to be "Damn, that was awesome!" and about a third to be "sorry, it's at least as bad as I thought, maybe worse".