• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

how did burlinghoff rassmussen know about the enterprise d?

This fake Rasmussen did say it had taken him "weeks" to learn the ropes of the timepod, to the degree that he did, that is. Perhaps the original plan, by the real Rasmussen, had been to visit this planet in the middle of crisis and chaos where nobody would have the attention to spare for spotting him? The delay (which the autopilot took in absolute terms, also arriving "weeks" late) meant that the pod ran into the starship instead... And our thief turned the threat into an opportunity.

Timo Saloniemi
 
That makes a great deal of sense. The credentials thing baffled me, so if Picard didn't mean it literally, it's much easier to wrap my head around. I also completely agree that Rasmussen was just BSing.
But little question, when you say "just story convenience", do you think the time machine went there completely randomly? I think the scientist who owned the time machine programmed it to that time and date deliberately because the Enterprise was there, and maybe it was an easy place to observe the Enterprise for some reason. Or maybe there was something about that place that was relevant to the scientist's research project, but the Enterprise being there was relevant.

Ont he timepod encountering the Enterprise I mean it happened because it needed to happen for there to be a story. I don't think there was any reason at all for any time traveler to want to see this particular mission of the Enterprise, especially to the extent of making themselves known to be there to do this. The roll of dice when the pod shows up the Enterprise just happened to be nearby. Rasmussen set the pod to travel, it popped out where it did and he probably planned on going off to find something to do, it just happened the Enterprise was somewhat nearby so he went for them.
 
Should we assume that the universe is so full of time travelers that sooner or later, one would necessarily appear just 300 km off the heroes' starboard bow? Or that the universe is so full of starships that the unique time travel event would necessarily take place close to one of those?

We know the latter ain't true at least: there are way too few starships around for Starfleet to be able to accomplish its mission. Which is a story convenience that works without any inconvenient assumptions, as it automatically facilitates the stories where the heroes' is the only ship around.

The former is a bit unlikely to be true, too. I mean, yes, there's enough oomph in the universe for everybody to travel to the past at least twice - at least time travelers will never run out of time. But it's an observed fact that timepods don't pop up every week. Why's that? Are most of them competent at hiding their presence, and only the ones hijacked by amateurs actually ever get spotted?

In order for there to be this story, we need to have the timepod emerge where and when it does. And coincidence isn't the only explanation available to us. Personally, I'd steer away from coincidence, both because it's unrealistic, but also and primarily because it's so dull...

Timo Saloniemi
 
I mean any of it is possible, but just the feel of things makes me think there's deliberate intent for someone to have wanted to show up there with the time pod, more likely the original owner, who most likely wouldn't intend to be as obvious as the fraud was
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top