• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Has Enterprise ever messed up the continuity?

The in-universe explanation for the change in Klingons is not because there was more money and better effects available because out-of-universe does not exist. In 1996 Worf explained that it was because "We don't like to talk about it" but in 2004 it was because of an augment plague that turned the Kingon's into Human hybrids.

We don't know why Borg technology suddenly looked cooler after 1996, or why the flash back to the best of Both world had cool Borg tech and not funcky 80s Borg tech, but there should be an in-universe explanation forthcoming in the next thousand years or so.

The in-universe explanation is the Temporal Cold War is happening right this minute, and because of hyperfractures in the chronosphere, only we fans are aware of it. Once everything is straightened out, we won't remember that any of this ever happened. As long as things are resolved correctly.
 
Fair enough. It makes for sense for the Vulcan's to be the ones to make first contact with the Klingons. The Vulcans in ENT were far more accustomed to Klingon practices, rituals (regarding death) and their reaction to a Klingon dying on Earth provoking a war with Earth. The Vulcan's were the intermediaries on behalf of Earth, regarding Klaang. Also Archer and co deployed the tactic of observing a culture in secret several times in season 1 and 2.

So there is no continuity snaffu, like you said. Thanks hombre.

I don't think so. I just re watched "First Contact" and Picard noted that there was quite a bit of disagreement regarding the policy when it was first adopted (Picard made it sound like the vote to approve it was something along the lines of 9 to 8), which doesn't sound like the a Vulcans were the first to make contact with the Klingons on a solo basis.
Let's go to the tape
First Contact said:
PICARD: Centuries ago, a disastrous contact with the Klingon Empire led to decades of war. It was decided then we would do surveillance before making contact. It was a controversial decision. I believe it prevented more problems than it created.
It's ambiguous enough that Picard could be talking about the Vulcans or any other Federation race. It could also refer to a string of disasters encounter between humans and Klingons, starting with Broken Bow, where Klingon customs were deliberately ignored and continuing through Archer's various dealings with them. ( none of which were particularly positive) Klingons are know to hold a grudge and would transfer their enmity to the Federation. An organization they viewed as a "humans only club", with Vulcans being used as their "intellectual puppets". Once can see how this string of events might lead to a policy of observation before contact. Though Enterprise does establish that the Vulcan's did use observation and evaluation prior to contact ( Carbon Creek). So it coming from Vulcan works.

Oh and the guy who wrote the line is fine with the Enterprise take.
 
However, by 2079 all "United Earth nonsense" had been abolished, as Q reminded Data in "Encounter At Farpoint"
The statement came from Q, and is therefor suspect as far as being completely true.

However Data never tried to refute it, nor did any other member of the away team. And Picard's line about "Kill All The Lawyers" very well backs up Q's claim about the court being from that era.

It's unlikely given the death toll of the war that the third world war was in fact world wide, nor do I think the "post atomic horror" was either. The PAH existed in some areas only, and any growth/participation in United Earth in those areas would have had to wait until those peoples got their act together.

600 hundred million dead? That's quite a large number, plus I would also suggest that the War lead to the destruction of a lot of records from before 2053, so Riker's number may've even been off by a a few billion. Not to mention but the majority of the world's major cities and governments had been wiped out by WWIII. Let's see: Ottawa Canada currently has about 1 million people, Toronto about 2.5 million, Washington D.c. Is around 12 million, Delhi India is close to 25 million (and by 2030 their population is expected to bloom to close to 36 million), Tokyo Japan is currently around 36 million, Sydney Australia is around 4.5 million, London UK is about 8 million...need I go on? So if the major cities were destroyed, you could easily see the 600 million dead. Plus as Spock noted in "Space Seed", when he was looking up information about Khan, very few records from about the 1990's through to the mid-21st century survive.
which was apparently the beginnings of what would become the United Earth government in 2150 ...
Beverly used 2150 to refer to the formation of a "world government," she never refer to United Earth in connection to that date. That the body that was formed in 2150 was in fact "United Earth" is both possible and debateably not the case.

In 2150 the mentioned world government and United Earth could have been (at the time) two entirely separate organizations.

That doesn't even make sense. As Picard noted the Hegemony was a very loose affiliation between European states. It had no real power, just like the UN of today has no real power.

We're only told that the European Hegemony was formed in the early 22nd century, but were not given an exact year of the formation. 2123 refers to the beginning of the use of the distress beacon.

2123 is "early-22nd century". And the distress beacon was a common EH distress beacon.
The Mariposa was launched in November 2123.
United Earth existed in some form
a functioning world government
It wasn't my intent to suggest that United Earth was a world government in 2067, only that it already exist in some form.

It is highly doubtful that any sort of world government or UN organization had been setup by 2067, considering that WWIII had ended in 2053, and in 2063 the US still looked like Europe had in the late-1940's.
 
Last edited:
Where does Colonel Green fit on the timeline?

Extracting millions of genetically damaged humans from the genepool after the war.

(It was TNG who moved the war.)

After the war, but before first contact?

Yes.

A Global leader before, during and after the war.

The consideration of infrastructure to enable a modern mass extermination is obvious.
 
Colonel Green was involved in WW III itself (he led an ultra violent radical faction of eco-terrorists who caused 37 million deaths) and also genocidal killing of radiation victims after the war was over.

ENT was going to do an episode about Green, but after Brent Spiner expressed interest in appearing, the arc was re-written and turned into the Arik Soong Borderland/Cold Station/Augments arc.
 
And you have to remember that WWIII officially started in 2026 and officially ended in 2053, while the "seeds" for the war were planted back in the 1990's with the Eugenics Wars. So the timeline for WWIII is a lot longer than the timelines for WWI & WWII combined.

Plus Colonel a Green was responsible for 37 million deaths.
 
Nuclear wars do not last years.

They last minutes.

Memory Beta says that posturing started as early as 2026, but the war itself didn't kick off till the 2050s.
 
If ENT is supposed to be chronologically the "first" set of adventures, we could say all series and films produced before it messed up continuity.
 
Alpha vs. Beta.

The few facts we have, can be interpreted in a different ways.

DS9 says that there was a "planetary" baseball league in 2026.

(Plenty of planets in the solar system.)

That would have made the sport quite difficult if the players had to train to compete in different gravities depending on where the game is played.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top