• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

General Trek Questions and Observations

Or vice versa. A Borg Cube or 10 may have done a good sweep of the Alpha Quadrant races in circa 1500 AD to see if any races of good technology existed. Grabbed a few Vulcans, maybe a Ferengi or two, then took one look at Earth and said "Eh, bunch of primitives. Maybe in a thousand years..."

Aside form what matthunter said, I think the numbers of Vulcans and Humans are too close to each other for that.

The Ferengi are Species 180. The Vulcans are Species 3259 and Humans are 5618

Though one could argue that even the Vulcans and Humans have numbers that seem too low, if the Borg have been doing their thing since the 1500s, it seems they should have encountered a lot more species.
 
Aside form what matthunter said, I think the numbers of Vulcans and Humans are too close to each other for that.

The Ferengi are Species 180. The Vulcans are Species 3259 and Humans are 5618

Though one could argue that even the Vulcans and Humans have numbers that seem too low, if the Borg have been doing their thing since the 1500s, it seems they should have encountered a lot more species.

That depends on how long it took them to assimilate highly advanced technologies and a large enough drone population to absorb any losses. They wouldn't have always been as efficient and unstoppable as we know them.
 
This is probably something that most fans here already know but the actor Christopher McDonald who played Lt. Castillo was born in Romulus
 
Except the Borg were only really starting out back in the 14-1500s, as per VOY Dragon's Teeth.

Which still leaves an intriguing mystery. Why had they been developing like that for 'thousands of centuries', as Guinan tells us in the original Borg episode, Q Who, to only go for an aggressive course of expansion not much earlier (and possibly even later) than our 15th century? Or did they suffer some catastrophic setback sometime before the Vaadwaur went into stasis? Or could perhaps either Guinan or the Vaadwaur simply have been misinformed?
 
I think Guinan was wrong. Thousands of centuries would make them older than much more advanced races like the Iconians.
 
^I'm conflicted about whom to believe. Out of universe, I'd definitely go with Q Who, given that it's the episode that invented the Borg, and given the tendency of VOY to be not too scrupulous about things like in-universe consistency as long as it sounds nice within the episode, but in universe I'd agree that the Vaadwaur would probably be in a far better position to know than Guinan, who admits herself that she knows only 'bits and pieces'.

Then again, as I said, there are still scenarios in which both are telling the truth.
 
So that means that Federation ship was assimilated in 2362, FIVE years before Wolf 359, two years before the Enterprise D officially had first contact with the Borg and still one year before that Borg incursion along the neutral zone where they scooped up those Romulan (and Federation?) outposts.

Starfleet loses ships regular as clockwork - Defiant, Bozeman, Pegasus, Hera, Equinox, Voyager, Olympia etc. - so they probably just didn't even notice.
 
"Discovery" should have been "Enterprise"....and "Picard."

Okay, let me clarify. What I mean is that--in my opinion--about half of what makes up "Star Trek: Discovery" should have been the prequel series that aired right after "Voyager" ended. And other elements should have been used for the post-"Voyager" era of Starfleet.

THE PREQUEL:

First off, the name. "Discovery" would've been the most fitting name for the ship of that first prequel series. It was always implied that Kirk's was the first Enterprise, and Discovery is a perfect name for Earth's first exploration ship.

The Klingons as main antagonists would've made much more sense for that prequel series than some made-up villains never mentioned in the rest of the franchise. The cameos of young Spock, Captain Pike, and Pike's "Number One," would've also been far more welcome than cameos from the Ferengi, the Borg, and holodeck tech that shoudn't exist yet.

The diversity of the main cast: nothing revolutionary now, but would have been exactly what "Star Trek" needed in 2001. A captain and first officer that were both female and non-white (something I specifically wanted to see, at that time). Openly gay characters. An intersex/NB character. 2001 would've been the time to do that! That would have made it echo the social daring of the Original Series.

THE POST-VOYAGER STUFF

...all of that said, the visuals of "Discovery" are totally off for any pre-Kirk era, but would have been perfect for a post-Voyager Starfleet. That crazy-awesome ship, with it's crazy-awesome magic-mushroom drive; those shinny, intricate gold and silver uniforms; and those cool looking alien antagonists, that had no reason to be called "Klingons."

It's a sad irony that the first two seasons felt the need to be a prequel, when "Discovery's" third season and "Star Trek: Picard" demonstrate that yes, the "Trek" writers can absolutely continue the saga of Starfleet post-Voyager, and awesomely.

And the 32nd Century Uniforms? Those look surprisingly dull, compared to all of the incredible tech of that era. Those simplistic, but nice, uniforms, those should have been what the pre-Kirk Starfleet should've had.

SO BASICALY... I love new-Trek as I love a Tarantino movie. It's a great story, but the order feels all ****ed up.
 
And the 32nd Century Uniforms? Those look surprisingly dull, compared to all of the incredible tech of that era. Those simplistic, but nice, uniforms, those should have been what the pre-Kirk Starfleet should've had.

I agree that there were definitely some misfires when it came to the uniforms - though I love the Mad Max-ish aesthetic of the Klingons, for example, something tells me they should be a little more raggedy and a little less polished and matchy-matchy. They're Klingons, for Pete's sake, not the Jackson 5 !

Oh, and the inexplicable suede bomber jacket they put on Picard starting in S5 of TNG ?

It was hard to reconcile such an already clearly-defined character in a costume piece that said "Hey, anyone want to go for gelato ?!"
 
I think Guinan was wrong. Thousands of centuries would make them older than much more advanced races like the Iconians.

It's an interesting one, because her species is so long-lived. If the Borg only originated in the 14-15th century, her parents or grandparents would have likely been around to see them get started. Guinan herself was born some time in the 1800s. Even if they lost their recorded history, their oral history should go back hundreds of thousands of years given how long-lived they are as a species.

Maybe the Borg were around prior to the 14th/15th century but some sort of cataclysm had befallen the collective just before that time, that nearly wiped them out entirely. Losing a war, or some sort of internal 'filter' where v1 of the collective just stopped working for some reason. So they weren't really 'getting started', it just appeared that way to the Vaadwaur.

Would explain Seven's reference that "The Collective's memory from nine hundred years ago is fragmentary" - if they'd lost a large number of ships and drones, perhaps they lost a lot of records themselves.
 
Which still leaves an intriguing mystery. Why had they been developing like that for 'thousands of centuries', as Guinan tells us in the original Borg episode, Q Who, to only go for an aggressive course of expansion not much earlier (and possibly even later) than our 15th century? Or did they suffer some catastrophic setback sometime before the Vaadwaur went into stasis? Or could perhaps either Guinan or the Vaadwaur simply have been misinformed?

The Doomsday Machine builders, Slavers..Vegan Tyranny were active then.

When is "then"?

Didn't Guinan say the Borg were around for thousands of centuries, and thus for hundreds of thosuands ofyears?

Didn't the Vaadwaur or however they were spelled say the Borg only ruled a few systems a thousand years before Voyager?

There is a big rime difference berween those statements, hundreds of thousands of years. So I have to wonder exactly when was your "then" supposed to be.

We can suppose that maybe the Borg existed from hundreds of thousands of years, and then suffered some terrible disaster comparitively recently, and as they recovered began their carrer of assimilating people and technology..

There are only the vaguest hints about when the Doomsday Machine was built, and where it might have been built.

The Thrint or Slavers come from Larry Niven's Known Space series, where they ruled a large part of the galaxy at least a billion years ago. The only canonical mention of the Slavers in Star Trek is in the animated series episode "The Slaver Weapon".

SPOCK: These stasis boxes are the most remarkable thing the Slavers ever produced. Time stands still inside a stasis box. A billion years means nothing in there. What is it, Lieutenant?
UHURA: I've studied the history of the Slaver Empire, but it's sketchy. We know they were masters of all the intelligent beings in this galaxy a billion years ago, until one race revolted. Are the stasis boxes the only source of information we have?
SPOCK: The Slavers and all their subjects were exterminated in the war that followed. Intelligent life had to evolve all over again. The stasis boxes are the only remnant of those lost civilisations.

And:

SPOCK [OC]: Stasis boxes and their contents are the only remnant of a species which ruled most of this galaxy a billion years ago. Their effect on science has been incalculable. In one was found a flying belt which was the key to the artificial gravity field used by starships. Another box contained a disrupter bomb with the pin pulled. As a result, all stasis boxes are now under the jurisdiction of Starfleet, and only certain key specialists handle them. The boxes are rare, potentially dangerous, and we seem to have found a second one.

http://www.chakoteya.net/StarTrek/TAS011.htm

So in the Slavers lived "one billion" years ago, which was 1,000,000,000 years using the short scale or 1,000,000,000,000 years using the long scale.

A billion is a number with two distinct definitions:

  • 1,000,000,000, i.e. one thousand million, or 109 (ten to the ninth power), as defined on the short scale. This is now the meaning in all English dialects.[1][2]
  • 1,000,000,000,000, i.e. one million million, or 1012 (ten to the twelfth power), as defined on the long scale. This is one thousand times larger than the short scale billion, and this number is now normally referred to as one trillion. This is the historical meaning in English (with the exception of the United States), and was still in official use in British English until some time after World War II. It is still in use in many non-English-speaking countries where billion and trillion 1018 (ten to the eighteenth power) or equivalent words maintain their long scale definitions.
.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billion

The Vegan Tyranny is also from written science fiction, from James Blish's "Okie" stories, also known as Cities in Flight. James Blish mentioned the Vegans in one of his adaptations of TOS episodes. So the Vegans are not exactly, totally, or 100 percent, canon in Star Trek. There is no totally canon information about them in Star Trek.

What is know about the Vegan Confederation or Vegan Tyranny in Cities in Flight is that it was a large space empire ruling much of the galaxy and lastng for about 10,000 years before being overthrown by Earth humans. Earth Humans didn't consider the Vegans (from Vega II, a planet of the star Vega) to be human, but the non human civilzations did. And an unusual looking man could pass himself off as a Vegan.

Anway, there is an incredibly vast amount of time between the Slavers 1,000,000,000 years ago and the Vegan space realm founded about 8000 BC.

So it seems a little odd to me to read the Slavers and the Vegan Tyranny lumped together as existing together "then".
 
Last edited:
Maybe the Borg were around prior to the 14th/15th century but some sort of cataclysm had befallen the collective just before that time

Maybe a Borg attempt to produce another queen, like the queen tried to do with Picard much later. We know the queen is emotional, so I could see a Borg civil war with more than one queen at the helm.
 
they weren't really 'getting started', it just appeared that way to the Vaadwaur.
Wasn't it just that the Vaadwaur just said that the Borg were a small empire that wasn't really worthy of their attention?
Maybe before that time (or that cataclysm, to follow your idea) the Borg just didn't assimilate other species (or their technology) and were a more peaceful (or at least non-expansionist) species that just had upgraded themselves to be a collective of cyborgs.
Maybe whatever happened resulted in them changing to the modern Borg who aggressively devour everything/everyone they can get their hands on.
Maybe, if there were any members of the original Borg species that refused to be upgraded, it was caused by internal strive/civil war.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top