• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Foundation Adaptation Series Officially Ordered by Apple

Also, Dune has been filmed twice already...not very well, but filmed none-the-less.

And yeah, the problems with Foundation aren't technical (it could be done with 'Forbidden Planet' level VFX) it's purely about how dry, expansive and devoid of character and personality it is. Trying to tackle it anything close to word-for-word would be like making "Literally All of Human History From Hunter Gatherers To The Industrial Revolution in detail: The Movie"
 
Last edited:
Skipper said:
The problems with The Lord of the Ring were purely technical (how many films to make,
Click to expand...
You're way oversimplifying it. Over 1100 pages of prose needed to be distilled to its core essentials while retaining complex characterisations and world-building. Peter Jackson's achievement is nothing short of monumental. Not to mention, as faithful to the source material as can be, without regurgitating Tolkien's writing.

I'd also note Game of Thrones. An almost superb adaptation of what so many book fans considered unadaptable... Until it wasn't any more.

Reverend said:
Also, Dune has been filmed twice already...not very well, but filmed none-the-less.
Click to expand...
David Lynch movie is dogshit. Miniseries is... Better written, but produced dismally.
 
Last edited:
It had its own feel..it’s own worldbuilding. It is what Jupiter Ascending and VALERIAN couldn’t capture, but Chronicles of Riddick did…a sweeping expanse…a feel. I even liked the force shield look…dense…tougher than trek fields in a way.

Where Lynch’s effort was Lawrence of Arabia…the TV series…and this latest effort are more matter of fact…like Restrapo?
Religion mixed with a vital resource fought over by foreign powers trying to get in good with Bedouins?

That was Gulf Wars I and II
No thank you. I’ll take Lynch’s magic…where you hardly even see the damn spice.
 
I've seen some trailers, also read Isaac Asimov's first 2 books.
I'm curious about the series....
So Jared Harris will play Hari Seldon.... sounds interesting.
I like him, seen him in the Chernobyl miniseries, first season from The Terror and in The Expanse.
Hopefully they will keep shooting the series and something great will come out.

I also started to watch at some point Raised by Wolves, cool sci-fi, it started well, but the end of the first season was a bit disappointing. Kinda turned from sci-fi into fantasy :thumbdown:
Ridley Scott was one of the executive producers.
 
nedski said:
So Jared Harris will play Hari Seldon.... sounds interesting.
I like him, seen him in the Chernobyl miniseries, first season from The Terror and in The Expanse.
Click to expand...

Yeah, Jared Harris is a great actor, and son of Richard Harris. He's shown to have a great acting range and I think he's a great choice to play Hari Seldon. I think his first big break was with Mad Men.

Agree with Raised by Wolves. I loved its visual design echoing back to golden-age of sci-fi, but the story was everywhere. Didn't really know what it wanted to be, and I'm likely not coming back to it if a second season is produced.
 
I'm looking forward to this series but I haven't really been following the news. Did I read correctly that the first two episodes will be available on Friday? While I haven't read the books, I'm really hoping this show is like the Expanse. I need more 90s era quality sci fi Shows in my life and the reason I gravitated to the Expanse was it had the feeling of shows like Babylon 5 or DS9. Hopefully Foundation gives me that same craving.
 
It's Foundation Week! At last. Another great "unfilmable" classic sci-fi book comes to visual media.
 
I have a question.

In the original trilogy there is nothing to suggest the Emperor is a series of clones - in fact way it is presented it seems like just a regular dynastic family, with various other noble houses vying for control on occasion. Cloning tech isn't even mentioned.

I haven't read the the prequels since I was 13 or so. Is he a clone in them, or was that added purely by this adaptation?
 
wayoung said:
I haven't read the the prequels since I was 13 or so. Is he a clone in them, or was that added purely by this adaptation?
Click to expand...
To my recollection, it was added purely by this adaptation. That said, it lets them keep an actor across the hundreds of years the story spans, so it seems a reasonable addition.
 
ATimson said:
To my recollection, it was added purely by this adaptation. That said, it lets them keep an actor across the hundreds of years the story spans, so it seems a reasonable addition.
Click to expand...

I'm not rejecting it, I was just curious.

Although it does fuck with the Mule. His inability to found a dynasty is the reason why is empire was destined to be ephemeral. But if he can clone himself :shrug:
 
wayoung said:
I have a question.

In the original trilogy there is nothing to suggest the Emperor is a series of clones - in fact way it is presented it seems like just a regular dynastic family, with various other noble houses vying for control on occasion. Cloning tech isn't even mentioned.

I haven't read the the prequels since I was 13 or so. Is he a clone in them, or was that added purely by this adaptation?
Click to expand...
In the original books medical science was at 1940's level ... I mean, Seldon was on a wheelchair! And they made clear that the human life span was comparable to today one.
 
ATimson said:
To my recollection, it was added purely by this adaptation. That said, it lets them keep an actor across the hundreds of years the story spans, so it seems a reasonable addition.
Click to expand...


Which is something I don't really get seeing as what people were seeing was a hologram of Seldon activated at certain times via his predictions. They could use the hologram idea and still keep using the same actor. That's what confuses me. The only reason I could think of for going that way would be if they plan on doing two-way interaction with him.
 
tomalak301 said:
I'm looking forward to this series but I haven't really been following the news. Did I read correctly that the first two episodes will be available on Friday? While I haven't read the books, I'm really hoping this show is like the Expanse. I need more 90s era quality sci fi Shows in my life and the reason I gravitated to the Expanse was it had the feeling of shows like Babylon 5 or DS9. Hopefully Foundation gives me that same craving.
Click to expand...

Yes, it's the first 3 2 episodes that air/release this week, followed by one a week every Friday for a total of 10 episodes.
Source

Also of interest around here:
But the most interesting person who’ll be yelling “CUT!” for Foundation — and twice no less — is Roxann Dawson, who has directed episodes of Penny Dreadful: City of Angels, House of Cards, and Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., but is best known to fans of epic sci-fi space operas as B’Elanna Torres from Star Trek: Voyager…a show she directed twice before doing the same for 10 episodes of Star Trek: Enterprise.
Click to expand...
Source
 
wayoung said:
I have a question.

In the original trilogy there is nothing to suggest the Emperor is a series of clones - in fact way it is presented it seems like just a regular dynastic family, with various other noble houses vying for control on occasion. Cloning tech isn't even mentioned.

I haven't read the the prequels since I was 13 or so. Is he a clone in them, or was that added purely by this adaptation?
Click to expand...

True, cloning is not even mentioned once in the old trilogy or in the prequels or the sequels
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Shaka Zulu
Arthur C. Clarke's 'Venus Prime' to become a TV miniseries, directed by Jonathan Frakes
Replies
9
Views
955
Australis
Australis
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top