• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Favorite unintentional series finales

"Haunted Highway," an episode of the short-lived The Highwayma series, wound up being its onscreen finale in '88. I have a soft spot for it. How could I not for a show that had "Whacko Jacko" as a main character? (The show was set, as it eventually turned out, in the post-apocalpytic future of... 1992. :lol:)
 
^I don't see how something can be your favorite if you hate it. Unless it's your favorite thing to hate. Are we defining the word "favorite" differently? I understand it to mean the thing you like more than everything else.






Kor wrote:

Does anyone remember the UPN show "Nowhere Man" from the 90s? I think the ending fits in with this discussion

Christopher wrote:

Except this is supposed to be about good finales...

The OP Wrote:

Favorite unintentional series finales (emphasis mine)


HIjol writes:

Not "good" finales, "unintentional" finales

That is where my confusion came from, and why I listed "Deadwood".

According to Milch in commentary in the episode, "Tell Him Something Pretty" , they did not know it was over. Then, there was talk of a shortened 4th season, and again, 2 movies to replace the 4th season. Recent talks with HBO and Milch in 2015 renew fuckin' hope, is all. (Deadwood-ese fuckin' mine)

source: DVD Commentary and: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadwood_(TV_series)
 
Can we count Blake's 7 in this one...

I was expecting someone would. But can it really be considered an unintentional finale, given how, well, final it was?

Well they could have been stunned, and we never did see Avon get shot only a fade to black and the sound of shots being fired. Either ways is a memorable final scene.

Dark Angel, although most of the rest of the season was crummy.

Dead Like Me.


At least we did get a final of sorts with the TV movie Life after Death, though you could see the ending coming a mile off well okay half a mile off.
 
Does anyone remember the UPN show "Nowhere Man" from the 90s? I think the ending fits in with this discussion.

Except this is supposed to be about good finales. Nowhere Man was a mess overall -- its attempt to tell a Prisoner-style paranoia show in a Fugitive-style wandering format couldn't really work, because it pretty much required most of the population of the United States to be cooperating in the "secret" conspiracy against this one guy -- but its finale was a much greater mess. They basically revealed that nothing we'd seen for the previous season was what it seemed, but in a way that made no sense whatsoever and gave the impression that they were just making stuff up as they went and had never really had any idea what the secret behind the conspiracy was. It was the kind of finale that made everything before it seem worse and more pointless.

Maybe it's because I was thirteen when this show was on the air, but I always thought the whole thing was absolutely brilliant! :p

Kor

I was a teenager too, and thought it was great. I felt like UPN totally missed the X-Files wave that soon followed.

The show also opened my eyes to the brilliant acting of Bruce Greenwood.

Too bad they never re-aired it. i'd like to see if Christopher was accurate in his analysis or overly harsh.
 
I may well be overly harsh toward Nowhere Man, but I found it frustratingly contrived. What I hated -- on top of the absurdity of an "everyone's out to get you" premise set out in the wild all over the country instead of in a finite, controlled environment, and the general sense that they had no consistent idea what the conspiracy was actually about -- was that the lead character's paranoia always failed him exactly at the moments when he needed it most. For most of an episode, we'd see him acting with caution and suspicion toward people, aware that They were out to get him and that anyone could be Their agents -- but then, at exactly the moment when it was most obvious to me that he was being led into a trap, he would suddenly become utterly trusting and gullible and allow himself to be trapped.

Of course, that relates to why I don't like paranoia-based stories in general, because they're so damn predictable. It's always self-evident that nothing is what it seems, anyone who looks friendly is going to betray the hero, everything is always going to turn out in the worst possible way, etc. There's no suspense because you can see the twists coming a mile away.

Anyway, Nowhere Man's creator Lawrence Hertzog really seemed to like The Fugitive knockoffs. Five years earlier, he made a failed pilot called Project: Tinman that was shown in one of those "showcase" nights that networks used to have where they'd burn off a couple of rejected pilots in their movie-of-the-week slot, and I happened to record it on my VCR. I still have a copy, and last year I rewatched it and reviewed it for my blog. I remembered liking it because it was similar to Roddenberry's The Questor Tapes, but on revisiting it, I found that it wasn't very good at all, more like the watered-down, network-mandated retool of Questor that Roddenberry self-cancelled the series rather than agreeing to make.
 
Never Fade Away

Though I would of prefered the Angel finale to be called Fight the Good Fight, playing off Doyle's words to Angel at the start of the show

I seem to recall the writers knew that would be the final episode when they wrote it. If that's the case, I'm not certain how it would qualify as an unintentional finale.

I think it was semi-unintentional, in that they found out they were being canceled mid-season, but I could be wrong about that; it's obviously been awhile.

My recollection is that Whedon asked for a decision to be made regarding the show's future before they had completed work on the season. WB decided to cancel the show, thereby making the fifth season its last, and the finale was written thusly.

Maybe it was an unintentional end of the season, but then most shows live on the bubble this way (sometimes ending on cliffhangers purposely to help garner interest and publicity to aid the chances of a renewal) so I'm not sure it would really count.
 
The story I was always told is that Whedon always planned for a 6th season and he had wrote virtually all of the 5th season already so some aspects of the finale changed but alot of it was always going to be there.
 
I would not count "Not Fade Away" as an unintentional finale. Yes, it wasn't announced until very late in Season 5's production that it would be the last season, but they still clearly knew going in that "Not Fade Away" would be the last episode.

When I met James Marsters at Phoenix ComicCon 5 years ago, he talked about how Joss Whedon practically forced the WB to cancel the show by demanding an early answer as to whether the show would be renewed or not. Had he left things more open, the WB might have decided at the last minute to keep the show on for another year, especially since their proposed Dark Shadows revival never made it past the pilot stage.

Red Dwarf Series VIII "Only the Good..." If only for the final scene when Rimmer kicks Death in the balls! :guffaw:

I hate that ending. It's clunky and abrupt, most of the cast is absent, and it makes no damn sense. I recently binge-rewatched Red Dwarf and tracked down the unaired alternate ending to "Only the Good...," and it works so much better. It isn't this weird, rushed, finale that's just Rimmer and a vending machine and a random Grim Reaper -- it's got the whole cast, it resolves the plot, and it has a cool final scene that provides a solid bookend to the seasonal arc. Also, the status quo in the revival seasons makes far more sense if you assume they follow from the alternate ending.

Red Dwarf is saved, but the crew has evacuated and Rimmer leaves them behind, so it's back to just the core group alone aboard the Dwarf, as we see in "Back to Earth" and Series X. The only part that doesn't follow is Rimmer being a hologram again, but he could've suffered a fatal accident in the interim between "Only the Good" and "Back to Earth."

I really don't know why they didn't use the alternate ending. At the very least, they should've completed the effects and done an alternate edit of the finale on the DVD version.

The alternate ending was lame. Yes, it involves the rest of the cast and fits in better with "Back to Earth" & Series X but it's still lame. There's just no punch to it. It's not funny. It's not interesting. If they were going to do a different ending, I would have liked to see the one that they never shot where the human Rimmer from Series VIII gets rescued by the hologram Ace Rimmer that left in Series VII.

I will say that "Only the Good..." is a deeply flawed episode. It focuses too much on Rimmer and not enough on Lister. There are a lot of scenes that feel more like skits than like anything that would fit with the episode as a whole; like the bit where Rimmer & Lister get drunk or the stuff with Cat. But I do love that ridiculous ending!

Well... Something might be our personal favorite because of pure sentimental value, or a "so bad it's good" camp quality, while recognizing that it's not considered "good" according to other viewers' standards of quality.

Agreed. I always think of the Super Mario Bros. movie in this category. MST3K & Rifftrax has made a career out of movies that are fun but not necessarily good.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top