• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Ethan Peck cast as DSC's Spock

Weird that some fans need post-Nimoy Spocks to look just like him... 12 years after Nimoy emphatically gave Quinto his blessing.

(What Nimoy didn't seem to want: the character to die with him. Strangely, not all of his fans seem to agree.)
Don't actually care.
 
kirk-ethan-spock-tvguide.jpg
 
I'm just going to leave this here...

The first J.J. Abrams Star Trek movie establishes that this would be okay: old Spock (Leonard Nimoy) recognizes young Spock (Zachary Quinto) as himself. Same with old Spock laying eyes on Kirk (Chris Pine) and Scotty (Simon Pegg) and “seeing” the Scotty and Kirk he knew in the past. It’s one of those things that requires the audiences to give the reboot movies a break, but it does seem to the intent. Two actors: same character.

To put it another way, nobody thinks Saavik in Star Trek III is from a different universe than Saavik from Star Trek II even though one was played by Robin Curtis and one was played by Kirstie Alley. Similarly, no one who is a fan of the Marvel movies would claim that the first Iron Man is in a different universe than the other movies even though Roadie is played by Terrence Howard intially, and then later, by Don Cheadle.
Source

Different actors but same character? How very Star Trek.
 
Well, I gotta admit: I’m liking Peck’s Spock - having initially been skeptical that his character should appear in Discovery.

In fact - I’m keen to see more of Peck’s Spock, either further in the series or as part of a Pike / Enterprise spin-off (if such a show were to eventuate).
 
Well, I gotta admit: I’m liking Peck’s Spock - having initially been skeptical that his character should appear in Discovery.

In fact - I’m keen to see more of Peck’s Spock, either further in the series or as part of a Pike / Enterprise spin-off (if such a show were to eventuate).
Yeah, I agree. Although he's developing his own take on the character, he's channeling Nimory much more than Quinto did. He has the emotional yet logical disdain for things that older Spock (post TMP) later redeveloped as he shed his devotion to logic.
 
So far, Peck's Spock has been everything I wanted. Which may not be what everyone else wants. So much angst, get that boy a Kylo Ren helmet.

His barbs with Michael (and his utter disdain for father-of-the-millennium Sarek) were amazing.
 
I thought Peck did a pretty good job as Spock on the last episode. But it looks like Spock is going to mature very quickly between DSC and TOS. Peck never plays him as truly dispassionate. There's always this underlying level of snark underneath how he behaves. Nimoy did that too, just not constantly.
 
I thought Peck did a pretty good job as Spock on the last episode. But it looks like Spock is going to mature very quickly between DSC and TOS. Peck never plays him as truly dispassionate. There's always this underlying level of snark underneath how he behaves. Nimoy did that too, just not constantly.
The character has about a decade to evolve. And in Where No Man..., his snark is of a kind comparable, albeit somewhat tempered, to what Peck has performed thus far.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top