• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Enterprise D should not be the flagship

Others include: Lt Nara (unnamed alien, engineer, Eye of the Beholder), Lt Daniel Kawn (half-Napean, engineer, Eye of the Beholder), Ensign/Lt Ro Laren (Bajoran, pilot, various episodes), Ensign Sito Jaxa (Bajoran, tactical officer, Lower Decks), Ensign Taurik (Vulcan, engineer, Lower Decks) and depending on whether civilian personnel count there's also Guinan, Mot and one of the Ten Forward waiters (both Bolian).
Also Simon Tarses, the Romulan/Vulcan medical tech from The Drumhead
I am on season three of TNG, from what I can remember the Enterprise D is the flagship of the fleet, apart from real life, restricted TV budget reasons, this so called flagship representing a multispecies Federation has a crew complement of around 1000 personnel and yet apart from Worf, Selar and Troi every other crew person is entirely human.
Data is an alien, from an alien world, not human.
 
Maybe Earth is the capital because it wasn’t special. Vulcan has been around forever and was very powerful. The militaristic Andorians hated them, and the Tellarites rub everyone the wrong way. Meanwhile Earth’s a newbie of no threat to anyone and willing to make peace and alliances with everyone. Centuries later, it’s the powerhouse.
By that thinking, once Earth did become a "powerhouse" shouldn't the Federation Council have moved to a different Federation Member world?

One with no measure of specialness?
 
His goal is to be more human
What's great about him is that despite a goal of trying to be like humans, he never denies that he isn't. He fully acknowledges what he is. No matter how much changes about him. That will never change. He's actually said so himself... I think it was in Hero Worship.
 
Data was created by a human from Earth who moved to a human colony, and was built to look human, so he's a fake human.
 
By that thinking, once Earth did become a "powerhouse" shouldn't the Federation Council have moved to a different Federation Member world?

One with no measure of specialness?
If they felt the need to at that point, sure. Initially it was a matter of trust. No one trusted anyone so they gave it to the easily conquerable, or dismissible, humans. By the 24th century, the humans and the union overall is trusted and stable so changing capitals isn’t a priority? Though in my head canon, there is no one capital world and different branches of government or departments of Starfleet are spread on multiple ...one nova bomb shouldn’t be enough to decapitate a civilization.
 
Data was created by a human from Earth who moved to a human colony, and was built to look human, so he's a fake human.
But he's also his own type of life form. He is endowed with life. That makes him something real. He may in fact be an artificial human, but in creating that, a new living thing was created also, a not human thing
 
No one trusted anyone
According to Journey to Babel, in the 23rd century the members still didn't.
By the 24th century, the humans and the union overall is trusted and stable so changing capitals isn’t a priority?
What was said on screen to make you think the various federation members now felt trust and stability toward each other, I mean what had really changed?

I never got the impression that the members even liked each other.

Starfleet didn't even typically have completely mixed crews. The Defiant was the odd one out, the feature characters on TNG were humans, half humans, an artificial human, and one klingon.

Perhaps the federation was more a inconvenience that served a purpose.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps the federation was more a inconvenience that served a purpose.
Or maybe we're about to begin a frequent conversation on the effects of makeup budget on crew diversity? Look at the greater mix on DSC.
 
At minimum, all it takes to depict a alien on Star Trek is to indicate that a character is non-Human.

Full Betazed involved only dark contact lenses, many aliens didn't even require that much.
 
Those who say that Enterprise-D shouldn't have been the flagship must have been happy after what happened in 'Generations'?
 
Though in my head canon, there is no one capital world and different branches of government or departments of Starfleet are spread on multiple ...one nova bomb shouldn’t be enough to decapitate a civilization.

ITA, makes sense

By the 23rd century the whole of San Francisco should be operated by Starfleet Academy, how one small human city, (46.89 sq miles) can train the whole of Starfleet that defends a trillion member UFP does not make sense.
 
Hmmm..I thought Klingons, Romulans, and Federation members could pass through the Neutral Zones, but their armed ships couldn’t. Or is that just in the Cardassian “Demilitarized Zone”?
 
I thought Klingons, Romulans, and Federation members could pass through the Neutral Zones, but their armed ships couldn’t.
Maybe that was the case.

My interpretation was both the Federation and Romulans sides of the NZ were hard borders to each other, no traffic at all was legally allowed (just smugglers and spies?). Nor could either send any ships into the neutral zone between the borders. Now any civilizations located inside the neutral zone itself probably could enter the Federation, with a degree of suspicion that they could be Romulan agents. I wouldn't think the Romulans would want anything coming in.

The TNG episode Face of the Enemy made it sound like going from the Romulan side to the Federations side was difficult.

The Klingons might be different, the border between the Federation and the Empire wasn't establish by a treaty following a war and could be more open civilian traffic. The Klingons don't seem to be the most officious of people.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top