• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Down the Rabbit... er Wormhole: My Rewatching Journey

I agree, mostly. Move Along Home is not one of my favorite episodes. The endings I hate go like this, "and then I woke up" or "nobody remembers because of a temporal paradox" or "just kidding". This is one of those episodes. And these aliens just have tattoos. Lots of people have tattoos. You mean to tell me that all the way over in the Gamma Quadrant are aliens but they just look like tattooed guys? When I get to this episode, I don't feel a need to rewatch it, but I do say the phrase "move along, move along home" at dumb drivers sometimes.
 
Oh dear, I've let four episodes go by without a review... I can attribute this to Pre-Finals insomnia... So I'll start:

The Nagus

"With the sudden death of Grand Nagus Zek, Quark becomes the new leader of the Ferengi Alliance, but he also becomes a target for murder."

I like Quark. But I don't like Quark episodes, I suppose. Or perhaps this was just a bad example. I like Quark when he's playing off characters to help them see parts of their own character or something to that effect. His scenes with Odo are fantastic as are his scenes with Major Kira, as infrequent as they are. However, at this point I don't think he's strong enough to carry his own episode.

I saw this episode yesterday and I really can't remember anything about it, which is a bad sign. There are some episodes I've seen only once that I can retell the whole plot in full detail. The Inner Light is an example of that. So, I guess I have to end my review here.

Favorite Character Moment: Quark making Odo kiss his staff (Quark and Odo moments seem to make up all of my favorite character moments...)

Annoying Character of the Episode: Every Ferengi that isn't Quark. Quark is the only character the rest are caricatures.

Final Score: 4/10. Not really offending like Code of Honor or Shades of Grey, but very unmemorable.

***

Vortex

"A fugitive attempts to trade evidence about Odo's people for freedom."

Can I just say, best episode of the season so far? I can't even list all of my favorite moments in a brief review. Let's see... The Holosuite scene was badass, Quark showed that he actually does care for Odo when he blew up at Rom who got excited when he reasoned that Odo would die before giving up his prisoner. Odo showing true compassion for Croden at the end.

This episode just worked for me on all levels. While the first half was a little slow, it had some brilliant scenes with Odo and Croden. I really did feel for Odo by the end not knowing where his home is. This is the plot thread I'm most interested in and I would say that Odo is my favorite character at this time.

Favorite Character Moment: Odo's last lines, asking where home is. I truely felt for him.

Annoying Character of the Episode: The Miradorn, I could see where he was coming from, but at the same time he ended up being more of a lame comic book villain than anything else. Kind of like The Vulture or someone like that...

Final Score: 9/10. Almost perfect.
 
I guess the first time I ever noticed Wallace Shawn was in Princess Bride. He had some of the best lines like "Ever heard of Plato, Aristotle? Idiots!" and "Never bet with a Sicilian when death is on the line." I must have seen that movie at least four times in the theatre, then repeatedly at home after the VHS was released. So, when he showed up on DS9 as Zek, I immediately took note. "These tube grubs are chilled to perfection." I was upset that they killed him immediately because I wanted him to become a regular. No question that Shimmerman was doing the best Ferengi by that point, but he had been a Ferengi on TNG already. Wallace Shawn just nailed the part. So, when it turned out he wasn't dead, and later they kept bringing him back, I was as happy about it as when Whoopi joined TNG.

But in rewatching this episode, I was struck by how the writers had not decided what to do with Rom yet. I don't want to spoil it for you, but there is an episode coming up in Season 3 that really sets Rom going in his eventual direction, and it has Wallace Shawn, again. For now, just think of Rom as not being fully individuated. He is at this point merely a foil for Quark, and not a very good one at that. I think they originally planned for Quark to be less Ferenginarian and Rom to be a more typical Ferengi in contrast, but they eventually realized that Quark was a model Ferengi, so therefore Rom could become the un-Ferengi. And that did work, in my opinion.

By the way, I like Ferengi episodes. They are some of the finest social criticism of laissez-faire capitalism ever televised in the 20th century. I don't think there will ever be a Fan Collective - Ferengi DVD Set, but if there were, this episode would be essential. Dang, that's almost a threadworthy topic...
 
Keep watching. :)
I'm very curious. How did you like "Duet" and "In The Hands Of..."? IMO these episodes are highlights of Season 1. "Duet" is also one of the best ST-episodes ever.

I know many people who don't like season 1. They say it's crap and argue that DS9 did not really start until season 4. I don't hold this view. Compared to season 1 of TNG and VOY DS9's first episodes are outstanding. When you watch some episodes of season 1, it is striking that the writers were eager to create something new, to create a new identity...
 
Snakespeare: I do agree with you on Zek. Wallace Shawn happens to be my best friend's third cousin twice removed or something like that, so it's pretty cool to see him in things, especially Star Trek. I'm not anti-Ferengi episode either, but as of now, Quark has been a more compelling character when he's somewhat of a guest and helps the other characters figure out things.

Dukat: I agree with you. I've seen a lot of Trek and none of these episodes have really compared to some of the worst has to offer. Even The Passenger, my least favorite episode thus far doesn't stack up to things like Code of Honor, Hide and Q, Homesoil, Heroes and Demons, and Time and Again. Also, the weak episodes (Save The Passenger) say something interesting about humans, Bajorans or something to that effect. If people say the show gets better, then I'm pumped.

***

Battle Lines:

"
A runabout carrying Kai Opaka crashes on a planet of eternal war, where it is impossible for the combatants to die"

A pretty classic heavy handed Trek-Message episode in same same vein of Let This Be Your Last Battlefield. Regardless, I really enjoyed this one. It's upsetting that the Kai is gone now, I was starting to enjoy her character, but I guess she needs to make way for Winn somehow.



While, I did like this episode, it highlights one of my problems with the show. Sisko seems like he's more of a role than a character. Not since Emissary has he gotten an episode devoted to him and most of what he's done so far is arbitrate disputes, run the station, and be a parent to Jake. Even in ensamble episodes like this one, he almost plays second fiddle to the other characters, in this one it's Kira who gets major character moments while Sisko tries to arbitrate between the people.


Favorite Character moment: Any scene with Opaka and Kira. Kira is starting to become a very compelling character and this is the first season where all characters are usually cardboard cutouts.



Annoying Character Moment: Both leaders of the tribes were comic book villain-esque and played in archetypes rather than characters, something Trek usually avoids when it comes to specific characters (not so much races)

Final Score: 7.5/10. Really solid, but the message felt extra-heavy handed this ep.


***


The Storyteller


"Chief O'Brien is appointed spiritual leader of a Bajoran village. Meanwhile, Nog and Jake try to help their new friend settle a struggle between two Bajoran villages."


I'm going to admit it, I liked this episode. The O'Brien plot was wonderful in its sheer ridiculousness and I loved his interactions with Bashir. Yes, I said I liked something that had to do with Bashir.

However, the plot that I found to be the most enjoyable was the plot between Jake, Nog and Varis Sul. I hated Wesley and while cute, Naomi Wildman somewhat annoyed me, so needless to say children on Trek aren't my favorite. However, Jake and Nog are exceptions, because they're, dare I say it, real people. And in this episode, I really believed their friendship with Varis Sul and I even recognized a little of myself, awkwardly trying to impress a girl, who is no one more than someone who just walked passed you.


I hope Varis Sul makes appearences later on, but I know she won't. I know DS9 is good with reoccuring characters (so far we have Rom, Nog, I know Garak and Dukat becomes one, and of course Morn), but I doubt they are this good. No, she played her role and now she's gone. Oh well, she was cool while she lasted.


Favorite character moment: Jake, Nog and Sul dangling their feet over the Prominade acting like kids, albiet kids with issues. Such a new ground for Trek.


Annoying character moment: Every Bajoran in the village. Star Trek has done a very good job at not making the Bajorans religious whack jobs... they failed here.



7/10: Very enjoyable despite bad reputation.
 
I have finished the season!! I loved the last two episodes quite a bit, now I just have to get to reviewing... well, let's start:

Progress

"An old farmer refuses to leave the moon where he lives, even though it is about to be made uninhabitable by toxic gases. Meanwhile, Jake and Nog set out to turn an inordinate amount of seemingly worthless condiments into profit."

I think I was supposed to like Mullibok, but I just didn't. I felt like he was simply manipulating Kira and the writers didn't do a good job of making it clear why this moon is special to him. I'm usually very sympathetic when it comes to eminent domain cases, but this time it has nothing to do with making a profit at someone's expense. This will help thousands of Bajorans who were hurt by the war. I really can't side with him on this one.

The Jake and Nog story was interesting to me, but at the same time it felt like it was really awkward to place it with the story that it was placed with.

Favorite character moment: Kira and Sisko's conversation on the moon. I've really enjoyed the growth of their relationship.

Final Score: 5.5/10: Interesting story, but it's hurt because I have trouble sympathizing with Mullibok and the two stories don't compliment each other.

***

If Wishes Were Horses

"Station residents suddenly find their imaginations are manifested in physical form; a spatial rift threatens to destroy the Bajoran system."

I think I've seen this episode before, but I'm not sure. I was very happy to see an episode with only one plot going on, but it's unfortunate that this one was it. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great either. With just a few minor changes, you can make this a TNG episode very easily. Doesn't deal with Bajor or the Wormhole or even use the station in a unique way with settings of recurring characters. What's the point then? TNG is still running, why do we need TNG episodes on DS9?

DS9 is such an interesting new direction and I don't feel like this episode showed that, which made it really weak. I did like Odo chasing an ostrich down the Prominade though.

5/10: Average and hurt because it's a clear example of a TNG episode in DS9.

Favorite Character Moment: Sisko discussing humanity with Buck at the end. Pretty sure that's the famous Sisko baseball too...
 
Yep, the one thing If Wishes Were Horses did for the series was give Sisko his baseball.

I can see where you're coming from on Progress. I seem to be the only one on this board who doesn't think Progress is a second Duet. It was too boring and I agree with you completely about not siding with Mullibok.

'The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few' anyone?
 
I think I was supposed to like Mullibok, but I just didn't. I felt like he was simply manipulating Kira and the writers didn't do a good job of making it clear why this moon is special to him. I'm usually very sympathetic when it comes to eminent domain cases

...

Interesting story, but it's hurt because I have trouble sympathizing with Mullibok and the two stories don't compliment each other.

It was too boring and I agree with you completely about not siding with Mullibok.

In the Deep Space Nine Companion Peter Allan Fields said Mullibok was supposed to be unlikeable and he thought that Brian Keith played him as a more sympathetic character than he was going for in the script. If you didn't like Mullibok, that was the writer's intent.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top