• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Do you think Star Trek needed a reboot?

I want my Star Trek to be the way it always was.

Did JJ also sneak into your house and break all your DVDs? Unless he did that, then your Star Trek is beautifully preserved and you can watch it over and over and over and over and over and over again and it will be exactly the same as it always was. Every last bit of digitally encoded information can be burned right into your screen for all eternity.

You're just not going to get any new stuff based on it.

It failed to be profitable. It failed to be marketable. It failed to grow it's audience at the time when some of it's earliest fans started to literally die off (it's been 46 and a half years for God's sakes).

It failed to evolve and keep with the narrative style that is popular today. It looked cheesy just as Brosnan's Bond looked cheesy next to Craig's Bond or Clooney's Batman next to Bale's.

You had more than enough chances to invite enough friends to keep prime-Trek going strong. Hell, UPN even gave you a freebie season because they didn't have anything else to air. Apparently, for someone as demanding as you, you seem to lack the clout to gather millions of friends around for just one hour a week to keep what you love so much from going on.

What sort of madness would it take for a company to keep producing the same product for an ever shrinking size of the population?
 
Trek XI: A Romulan miner blows up a planet after he somehow finds himself in the past after his home planet is destroyed via natural causes in the future after the person who did everything he could to save his planet fails to save the planet.

Er, yeah. He's pissed at Spock because Spock didn't save Romulus from destruction, and now he's trapped 200 years in the past because of Spock, and he wants to make Spock suffer by doing the same thing to his planet that happened to Romulus. So Nero's anger doesn't make sense to you, why?

Oh, and he also wants to blow up Earth for some reason.
Nero made it quite clear why he wants to blow up Earth. He told his reasoning to Pike when he abducted him. Were you in the movie theater bathroom during that scene?
 
This is an entire cast and any emotional dynamic is built on our memories of other people, whereas they devoted the first entire two Bond movies making us care about Bond and M.

Maybe you arrived in the cinema ten minutes late, because the masterful opening sequence of ST (2009) even made us care about Robau, George Kirk and wife, Winona. Powerful stuff!

The Spock/Uhura material was also both fresh and an emotional ride.
 
It seems to me JJ's only concern with his new movies is to get more cash and he doesn't seem too shy about letting you know that. His loyalty is not to the fans, it is to his wallet.

That's not in any way an accurate description of anything Abrams has said, so it's rather peculiar how that could "seem to you" to be the case.

People keep remembering this Roddenberry...

genesaint.jpg


But this is the Roddenberry that created and ran Trek...

genemoney.jpg


My awesome photoshop skills at work! :lol:

This is has given me the courage to post up something that I made a few months ago:
roddenbirdylarge_zpsd34b378d-1_zps00818f32.jpg
 
This is has given me the courage to post up something that I made a few months ago:
roddenbirdylarge_zpsd34b378d-1_zps00818f32.jpg

With the divine rays of light only pointing toward the ground and the fuzzy rocks around his feet, it looks like a bunch of tribbles are trying to lasso Roddenjesus (or do we prefer Jesusberry?). Oddly appropriate. :lol:
 
This is has given me the courage to post up something that I made a few months ago:
roddenbirdylarge_zpsd34b378d-1_zps00818f32.jpg

Replace the sheep with sehlat and rocks with tribbles and you've got a winner. :techman:

Oh, and the little girl he's touching needs a bigger rack. Gene likes his women curvy!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top