• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Divorce should be easy, getting Married should be hard...

Professor Zoom

Admiral
Admiral
So, my brother is going through a divorce right now...well...he has been, since April of LAST YEAR. They've had to go to mediation, they've had court dates, nothing ever seems to get decided--the only thing they've worked out is custody of the kids, everything else is up in the air. It's been a SLOW frustrating process.

In September my brother asked for an emergency court hearing to resolve and issue, and it was granted and held, in DECEMBER.

To add a little salt to the wound: my brother and his soon (?) to be ex-wife have been living in the same house the entire time.

I feel so bad for the kids.

Anyway...it just made me think: Divorce should be easier, but getting married, let's make that MUCH harder, people who REALLY want to get together can do it.

We place so much emphasis on people getting married, but so little emphasis on giving people the tools to stay married. (And yes, my brother and his wife tried counseling, she didn't want to go.) So, at a certain point let people end it and just walk away.

In the state my brother lives in, they HAD to go to mediation first, and then the court dates have been so few and far in between...it's just taking forever.

I'm mostly venting, as I know it's been a tactic on my soon to be ex-wife's side to drag the process out--which I think will blow up in her face...

...and there's a lot of emotion on both sides, but I know my brother just wants to be done and done with the whole thing and move on.

And then, of course, are the kids, who only recently found out about the divorce. Yeah, my brother and his soon to be ex JUST told them...my family has been telling him to tell them for a LONG time now...

Anyway...

Should getting married be harder and divorce easier? (Not that I know to make that happen...)
 
Oh yeah, lets make marriage as easy to get out of as slippers... :rolleyes:

Kids! Now that's something people should have to take exhaustive tests for... do you have any idea how many kids are being raised by people that have NO reason or business raising kids... A whole generation of kids dumber than cattle... Being raised be parents only half as smart as cattle... :wtf:
 
I know what you mean about the divorce issues and timelines.... I was living with my father while in College a few years back when my parents went through their divorce.

My father for the most part had no issue with my mother taking just about anything she needed/wanted, and figured it'd be much easier if they both worked it out between themselves on who gets what rather then going through lawyers, because Lawyers will drag the whole process out as long as they can and when it's all said and done, the Lawyers get a good chunk of money which both parties end up paying.

But I also saw my mothers side of the situation where sure they could try and talk it about between themselves, but if there was a fight over one or two things, then it wouldn't get resolved without having to go back to the courts/lawyers anyways or be at each other's throats worse then what they'd be dealing through lawyers.

But it was dirty, nasty and a pile of stress for everybody, and 90% of all of that came from the Lawyers, through not sending in paper work, delaying forms, not communicating to the other lawyer, changing plans halfway through, blaming the other lawyer, etc. etc.

I don't think it has to be harder for people to get married, and I agree divorces should be easier.

In regards to making it harder to get married, speaking as someone who just got married a couple of months ago, I'd hate for it to be any harder then is currently is. What is needed are people to start to actually think about why they want to marry this person, how old are they, are there any issues that need to be worked out before you get married in case they don't get worked out afterwards, etc..... too many people it seems get married for all the wrong reasons or just out of plain ignorance due to emotions masking other important factors in the relationship.

But if this will help make it easier for your brother, After the divorce your brother, his ex and their children will be a hell of a lot better off. My father has since been remarried and my mother is in a new relationship, both are doing their own things and are both a lot happier then what I ever remember growing up. Living together during the divorce process I can only imagine is really stressful..... but neither will be left high and dry with no means to support themselves.

I remember my father freaking out that my mom and her lawyer were seeking the maximum amount they could get from my dad (lawyer's idea so that she didn't end up shorting herself out of what she's entitled to) and my dad thought he'd lose his house, have no way of living decently and his life would be completely ruined.

I told him at the time that she'd never get everything she's seeking, because #1 - as explained above, it was the lawyer's idea to make sure she didn't short herself and #2 - The courts will never allow him to be stripped of everything he has and make him destitute.... they will determine what is "Fair" for both parties.... and unfortunatly, this takes time.

He and my step mother at one point had three homes, rather then just one, sold one, and plan on selling the second to move into the third, so he's certainly not hurting as much as he originally thought.

Now to me, it seems you and your brother are a bit weary over marriages due to everything going on in the divorce and that you think it'd be much better for people to go through more trials and tests to make sure those people will last in a marriage...... maybe both your bother and his wife (soon to be ex) are hating each other's guts and regret the whole relationship for the most part........ but if it wasn't for the way things are today, they wouldn't have the children whom are now a part of your extended family and you may have ended up missing out on knowing them.

Try not to think of the whole situation as a mistake or a waste of time and life, but rather, another learning curve in life.... like I said.... my parents are doing a hell of a lot better now then they ever did while married, and I'd say that them being together through all the good and bad has helped them figure out more about what they want to do with their lives.

It's a hard way of learning, but it's a learning process non the less.
 
Oh yeah, lets make marriage as easy to get out of as slippers... :rolleyes:

Ah, but I would make getting into the slippers VERY hard...so you really want it.

Kids! Now that's something people should have to take exhaustive tests for...

Agreed.

In regards to making it harder to get married, speaking as someone who just got married a couple of months ago, I'd hate for it to be any harder then is currently is.

How is it hard? When I got married, we got the license, had to wait like 3 days and then went to City Hall. Easiest thing to do.
What is needed are people to start to actually think about why they want to marry this person, how old are they, are there any issues that need to be worked out before you get married in case they don't get worked out afterwards, etc..... too many people it seems get married for all the wrong reasons or just out of plain ignorance due to emotions masking other important factors in the relationship.

EXACTLY. That's why I feel like it's harder, it takes more time then people will actually have to sit and think about these things, maybe even answer them.

But if this will help make it easier for your brother, After the divorce your brother, his ex and their children will be a hell of a lot better off.

Agreed. Though, the first year is going to be hard on the kids I think.

Now to me, it seems you and your brother are a bit weary over marriages

Me? No. I'm very happily married and happy to be married. I'm not sure about my brother, the only thing I've heard him say is "pre-nup."

due to everything going on in the divorce and that you think it'd be much better for people to go through more trials and tests to make sure those people will last in a marriage......

My now wife and I did talk, quite a bit. In part one of the reasons we went over and over was she was immigrating and we didn't want people to think we got married so she could stay.

After awhile, we realized that was sorta bunk, who cares what people think, but, it did make us really examine why we would want to be married and what we would miss if we didn't.

To me, my (older) brother was young when he got married (25), at 25 I was just figuring out who I was. I got married at 31, and very happy I sorta knew who I was alone, and now I can figure out who I am with my wife.
 
Well, the people involved can make it easy or hard; and lawyers don't help.

What we really need is a culture that doesn't make marriage an expectation.
 
I sort of think my best friend got married because of familial and possibly friend expectations...to make it worse she considered converting to Roman Catholicism because her husband had been married previously and she didn't want to be considered not his "real" wife because of the religion issue.

Having grown up with two strikes against me versus mainstream culture (Jewish and Gay) I felt compelled to ask her why she was so invested in what other people thought of her.

So far their marriage seems to be going well (under 6 months old), but I admit I have some reservations and when I first met him my inside voice said, "Him?" But to be fair I've only met him twice so far, so I'm hardly qualified to have an opinion.
 
Well, the people involved can make it easy or hard; and lawyers don't help.

What we really need is a culture that doesn't make marriage an expectation.

I agree with everything except the "lawyers don't help" part. Yes, there are scumbag lawyers out there, but most are okay. And they only come into play if the couple can't agree or if the couple is rich and needs help dividing the assets tied up in complex funds and such.
 
I read an article within the last two days (wish I'd snagged the link) where people who were required to attend pre-marital counseling discovered, "Ooops, we are NOT meant to be together and it won't work" and ended up canceling the wedding.

This should be a requirement in all 50 States.
 
I read an article within the last two days (wish I'd snagged the link) where people who were required to attend pre-marital counseling discovered, "Ooops, we are NOT meant to be together and it won't work" and ended up canceling the wedding.

This should be a requirement in all 50 States.

That should be a requirement, but most states have a delay period because they assumed that people would be smart enough to do this themselves. So much for individual liberty.

How about people taking responsibility for making their own mess. Their is nothing wrong with marriage. What is wrong is people period.
 
Well, the people involved can make it easy or hard; and lawyers don't help.

What we really need is a culture that doesn't make marriage an expectation.

I agree with everything except the "lawyers don't help" part. Yes, there are scumbag lawyers out there, but most are okay. And they only come into play if the couple can't agree or if the couple is rich and needs help dividing the assets tied up in complex funds and such.
Yes, this is true.
 
I vote for divorce being easier. I've been seperated from my ex husband for over 2 years and I'm still legally married. This is down to him not pulling his finger out with his lawyer. Due to unemployment he was entitled to apply for legal aid, and I gave my consent for the divorce to go ahead etc. Heard nothing since. I keep asking my ex if he has contacted his lawyer and all I get is "Not yet, I'll do it this week" and he never does grrrr! :klingon:
 
I vote for divorce being easier. I've been seperated from my ex husband for over 2 years and I'm still legally married. This is down to him not pulling his finger out with his lawyer. Due to unemployment he was entitled to apply for legal aid, and I gave my consent for the divorce to go ahead etc. Heard nothing since. I keep asking my ex if he has contacted his lawyer and all I get is "Not yet, I'll do it this week" and he never does grrrr! :klingon:

Do you have a lawyer? If not, you're allowed to contact his lawyer directly since you're representing yourself. (Also, if he's being this much of an ass already, you might want to look into getting a lawyer yourself.)
 
I'm glad my divorce was relatively easy. Well, aside from the emotional impact. We used the same lawyer, didn't fight over anything, and everything worked out. That was almost five years ago. Time sure flies.
 
Kids! Now that's something people should have to take exhaustive tests for...

Agreed.

The problem with that is what happens if you fail those tests? Do they take your ovaries and testicles away from you?

What if they don't, you failed and you get pregnant or your loved one becomes pregnant?

Are they going to force you to give it up for adoption or have an abortion?

How much are they going to charge you to take this test and to process it? (You know they'll find an excuse to charge you up the wa-zoo)

How is it hard? When I got married, we got the license, had to wait like 3 days and then went to City Hall. Easiest thing to do.

While that was what we were going to do, based on our situation it wasn't practical or respectful for our families, since we were just thinking of doing that and then telling everybody after the fact. But since my wife's family is halfway around the world, and I'd be the first in my generation to get married, and my wife was her family's only daughter.... we sorta had to make it a bit more then just a court.

Personally speaking, I feel people who want to make getting married harder or to put people through tests for basic things in our lives like having children, etc. are basing their views on an emotional response to something that occured in their personal lives.

I don't mean to be offensive, but just because your brother and my parents (and others in similar situations) made some "bad decisions" in their lives to make them wind up being divorced, why should everybody else have to suffer or be dragged through more complicated tests and bureaucracies due to their own personal issues?

It's not everybody else's fault, or the system's fault that your brother married who he married..... it's his own. And while my parents were pretty well forced into marriage in the 70's by their parents via a pregnancy (and being the thing to do back then) it still all boiled down to their actions, their decisions and their responsibility.

I don't see why everybody else has to go through rings of fire to get married just because your brother and a few others in the world made bad decisions and don't like the position they're currently in. If other people make bad decisions as well and end up being divorced, then those are the consequences..... and they're the exact same consequences I accept for my own actions of getting married.

I certainly do not expect to get divorced (i imagine most who get married don't) but if it does happen, I have nobody else to blame but myself.... certainly not my family or her family, not my friend, and certainly not the system that allowed us to get married.

EXACTLY. That's why I feel like it's harder, it takes more time then people will actually have to sit and think about these things, maybe even answer them.

Yes but forcing people to take tests and have some second party determine if you and your partner should be married isn't the right answer. Way too many problems can arise from such a system..... and can you imagine such a system back in the early 80's or even earlier? You could have ended up having people reject your marriage request because you're gay, your partner is of a different race, and so on.

In my view, it has to start with the parents teaching their children how to approach this in the right way and when their children get older and closer to the point where they can marry or wish to, they should be obligated to understand these things and understand what consequences may occur.

It seems to me that you just want to move the pain in the arse situation of a divorce to the begining of the relationship to when one get's married, which I imagine would greatly reduce the amount of people getting married to one another, but for all the wrong reasons.

I think the easiest solution for everybody is that during the wedding, it is pointed out along with the better/worse speech, that divorces are a real factor in a marriage if they go the wrong way and you'll both go through a living hell unless you are certain this is the right decision.

Other then that, I would say anything else would be way too intrusive to one's personal rights as an individual, as an adult who should be capable of making their own decisions.

Agreed. Though, the first year is going to be hard on the kids I think.

It certainly will be.... afterwards it did get a bit easier, mainly because everybody involved kinda gets used to the routine and the shouting and fighting/stress does reduce..... the begining of a divorce is pretty much a shoke to everyone, including those who made the decision. Making the decision of getting a divorce may not be the easiest thing to do in life, but actually going through one is even worse then the decision itself.

But they will be fine and they will go on with their lives, and after the divorce is all said and done, things usually get a lot better for everybody involved.

The last couple in my family to get a divorce was my aunt and uncle who have one child, of course my cousin. He was younger then I when they went through one, and the reasons for the divorce were a lot more different, where that ex-aunt of mine (whom I never liked for as long as I can remember) cheated on my uncle with some "black guy from Jamaica who she fled off to Toronto with" whom my damn Uncle bent over backwards for that skank more then he should have over the years.

But I think him seeing what my father went through in his divorce had allowed him to deal with the situation very well in my opinion.... I mean if I was him and my wife ditched me and my son for some guy she met in another country while all of us were on vacation, with just a letter telling us what the hell happened..... I dunno...... I'd be pretty pissed to say the least.

I've been cheated on before in the past, so I know how it feels to be that person taken advantage of..... but being married and something like that happening? Whole different ball game.

Me? No. I'm very happily married and happy to be married. I'm not sure about my brother, the only thing I've heard him say is "pre-nup."

Fair enough, it was just a loose observation.

My now wife and I did talk, quite a bit. In part one of the reasons we went over and over was she was immigrating and we didn't want people to think we got married so she could stay.

I know that situation, as my wife's from another country.... but since we're eventually going to move to her home country and while I may have many more job opportunities there then here, I feel some may feel this was our intention as well, which it certainly wasn't.

After awhile, we realized that was sorta bunk, who cares what people think, but, it did make us really examine why we would want to be married and what we would miss if we didn't.

Agreed. It shouldn't matter what other's think about your relationship, but if what you suspect they are thinking seems to be in your mind a lot, perhaps it's more about what you're thinking about the relationship then what they're thinking. Are those reasons true, etc.?

But at the same time, I believe friend/family's views on your relationship do hold a bit of validity. Afterall, it was my friends and most of my family who kept telling me my first serious relationship was wrong and that "I could do so much better" ~ I didn't listen to them being a young whipper snapper, thinking they don't understand the whole situation or her as I do...... only to find out that they did, as she eventually cheated on me at lest once that I am aware of and continually used me/took advantage of me on a number of occasions. But I was young & ignorant at the time and felt this was how relationships worked (before being cheated on of course) because my parent's relationship wasn't the best either.

To me, my (older) brother was young when he got married (25), at 25 I was just figuring out who I was. I got married at 31, and very happy I sorta knew who I was alone, and now I can figure out who I am with my wife.

Sounds familiar to a degree.... I'm 29 and my wife is 30.... I'm the youngest in my immediate family, where my brother is 31 and my sister, who has triplets, 33 are not married and I feel they took a lot out of our parent's and other family member's relationships to not just rush in because it's the popular thing to do.

Both my wife and I spent half a year talking to one another over the internet before she came here and we agreed that when she did come here, there wouldn't be any expectations of a relationship and we'd just start off as friends/room mates in case we seem different in person then online. We pretty much hit it off the first day she arrived, lived with each other for almost two years before we married and have had no fights yet...... there were a few debates over a few things, but nothing I would call a fight, there were never any insults tossed, nobody came at each other with blunt objects, haven't shouted at one another.... so far so good.

I mean my relationship with my first serious girlfriend lasted just over 3 years, and unfortunatly lived with her for almost an additional year due to an apartment lease and either of us having very little money.

My second serious relationship lasted a little over four years.

This relationship wasn't very long in growth before we decided to get married compared to the others, mainly because I see a dating/long term relationship as a trial basis of trying to work out all the issues that may arise in a relationship and until those issues are resolved, there will never be any suggestion of marriage. I changed a lot for those other girls in the past relationships, while they changed very little and pretty well took advantage of me (i'm just too much of a nice guy, what can I say?)

And after two-three years of no change on their part, obviously they never would, so why offer them a marriage in the hopes they'd change afterwards?

I learned a lot of "What not to do" in those relationships, and when my wife and I entered this one, we both had a decent level of experience in what we're looking for and both have gone through a lot of crap in past relationship to know not to beat around the bush anymore. When we started dating, we both found that there was very little we had to work on, we didn't fight, I wasn't pushing her to change and neither was she on I, thus after a little over a year, on christmas day, I proposed and the rest is history.

Upon reflection when typing all of this, I think perhaps the logical solution would be to change the minimum age for marriage of 18 (I think that's the minimum) to something like 30 years of age.

Why?

Because like how your teen years and before are all about learning and gaining experience, your 20's are more of the same where you're learning and gaining experience of real life, gaining your independance, learning who you are, what you like and don't like, what career you wish to follow, what you're looking for in a relationship, etc.....

Jumping right into a marriage in say your early 20's or late teens and starting a family before you even had time to figure out who you are and where you fit in the world only complicates things and imo could add regret to such a relationship when you hit your 30's or older...... afterall, you just spent your 20's maintaining a family, you missed out on dating other people, figuring out more of what you like in the world, what your interests are, and if the relationship goes down hill just a little bit at some point, resentment for the other person could be a big factor and you could end up blaming them for wasting your youth, etc..... when you had an equal role in the situation.

If people got married much later in life, like you and I did (ie: towards your 30's not early 20's) we'd probably see a lot less divorces and more happy families..... but we all know some religious people wouldn't agree to this limitation.
 
What we really need is a culture that doesn't make marriage an expectation.

Bingo. People have a heart attack when I say I'd rather not get married.

Since my parents divorced, my dad did re-marry, and while my mother is in another relationship now for a good number of years, her boyfriend also came out from a nasty divorce as well and neither plan on marrying and are quite happy with how their relationship is now.

Besides after living with your bf/gf for like 2 years, you're Common Law anyways, which is pretty well like being married..... minus all the red tape you'd face if you break up.
 
I agree with everything except the "lawyers don't help" part. Yes, there are scumbag lawyers out there, but most are okay. And they only come into play if the couple can't agree or if the couple is rich and needs help dividing the assets tied up in complex funds and such.

My parents certainly wern't what I would consider "Rich" (mind you, we wern't poor either) and even low income families will get lawyers involved mainly due to so little being available to split in the first place, that they'd probably fight even harder then those who got plenty of money.
 
I read an article within the last two days (wish I'd snagged the link) where people who were required to attend pre-marital counseling discovered, "Ooops, we are NOT meant to be together and it won't work" and ended up canceling the wedding.

This should be a requirement in all 50 States.

I've heard of this in Roman Catholic relationships where the Priest will want them to sit in on a little pow wow on their relationship before they ok it.... not sure how often this is done though.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top