Discovery 8/10 info dump thread...
- Thread starter Overgeeked
- Start date
Totally understandable. I didn't see your earlier post suggesting it.
Quick note about the ads. I imagine that CBS will offer a "premium" ad-free service for a few bucks more a month.
Overall, I'm very excited about the new series. And, TOS, to this day, is still my favorite ST series. I love everything about that show. So, having the ability to play those elements and characters sounds fantastic to me.
However, surprisingly, I have a few mixed feelings about this series as described. I'm very surprised that it's a prequel. While I know that good writers can fit exciting new stories within an existing timeline, it still creates some constraints as to what they can do. No matter what happens, at the end of the day, everything must reset so that TOS happens as we see it. That imposes some limitations.
Why not move forward in the timeline. Move far enough beyond Nemesis that it's essentially a new setting but with some familiar elements. They're then free to do pretty much whatever they want without having to reset it?
I'm mostly excited about what I've heard . . . just surprised about the prequel or midquel aspect to it.
Mr Awe
However, surprisingly, I have a few mixed feelings about this series as described. I'm very surprised that it's a prequel. While I know that good writers can fit exciting new stories within an existing timeline, it still creates some constraints as to what they can do. No matter what happens, at the end of the day, everything must reset so that TOS happens as we see it. That imposes some limitations.
Why not move forward in the timeline. Move far enough beyond Nemesis that it's essentially a new setting but with some familiar elements. They're then free to do pretty much whatever they want without having to reset it?
I'm mostly excited about what I've heard . . . just surprised about the prequel or midquel aspect to it.
Mr Awe
I'd like it to be set post-Nemesis, but not linked to Nemesis. It's more about seeing what lies ahead than revisiting Nemesis. I'm still excited about the series as described. It'll be great to have a new Trek series!
Mr Awe
Not if it's a decade before TOS. Kirk would have been in his 20s in the 2250s, as anyone who has seen the Abrams movies should know. Tarsus IV was during his childhood.
Wow, Dennis, you're getting ruder by the day. That was uncalled for. If you don't like Trek fans, why do you hang out with us?
Mr Awe
Except for the fact that it is a prequel, or midquel. They writer's can write great stories, but ultimately any cold war tension would be lessened by the fact that it all has to be reset so that TOS can play out as we've seen it. That's why I'd rather that something take place post-Nemesis. But, still very much looking forward to this series!
Mr Awe
Source?
I still feel like we know next to nothing about this show. There are some aspects I could find potentially interesting, but just "Oooooh, Star Trek! Prime Universe! Ten years before Kirk! Female of color lead! She's not a Captain! Lots of aliens! Ship based on McQuarrie!" It's all a lot of noise. But what's the meat and bones? Its really hard for me to get excited about this as it just seems to be all window dressing at this point.
Simply going on the basis of Fuller retweeting this image, I think the first season will have something to do with Klingons, perhaps illustrating the end of the Four Year War or the Battle of Axanar or whatever the hell it's called.
Meyer did say The Undiscovered Country was some kind of "touchstone" for DSC.
Meyer did say The Undiscovered Country was some kind of "touchstone" for DSC.
Kirk is what, 32 in the first season of TOS? 13, 14 years back makes him a teenager. Close enough. I wouldn't take the 10 years comment as stating it took exactly ten years prior to WNMHGB.
Window dressing, I mean lingerie, can be VERY exciting.
Window dressing, I mean lingerie, can be VERY exciting.
I typically find what's under the lingerie far more exciting.
Similar threads
