• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Differences Between "The Cage" and Discovery (Minor "Desperate Hours" Spoilers)

We already have to believe that Picard and Janeway believed in different dress codes for starship personnel. It wouldn't be difficult to further decide some third skipper could have been even more relaxed or uptight about it. We just missed out on many uniform variants in TOS and TNG because of budg.. because of random factors and statistics.

And subspace. Definitely subspace.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Thank you for relaying some of that information! While some folks will be satisfied with that, I find it kind of arbitrary and contrived. Only one class of starship in the fleet wears one kind of uniform, while the rest of the fleet wears something else altogether? Nah, not buying it.
Well, the DS9 crew still kept their original uniforms for a full Season after we saw the mew 'Movie" uniforms of ST:FC. And the ST:Voy crew kept their original uniforms EVEN WHEN they had made and started maintaining regular contact with Earth - and the scenes of Star Fleet members on Earth WERE wearing the new 'Movie Uniforms' from ST:FC - so there IS precident for something like this. ;)

This parallel uniforms thing would work better if they shared more design elements. TNG and DS9 uniforms obviously belong to the same uniform family, the Cage and DIS uniforms not so much.
Um yeah:
This:
FPWGA3VI5MZ3MBG.MEDIUM.jpg

Does look similar to this:
patrick_stewart_star_trek_insurrection_003.jpg

In the same way this:
pD0eM.jpg

Looks a lot like:
star-trek-discovery-crew-ew.jpg

;)
 
My thinking is that someone, somewhere along the line, didn't realize that "The Cage" is almost contemporary in the timeline to DSC. There may have been thinking that it was ENT, DSC, then "The Cage" into TOS.
 
in which it deals with the issues of the supposed continuity violations between "The Cage" and Star Trek: Discovery.

Ah, so they're supposed now.

Article seems like needless bandaid fixes. I think everybody understands that you can come up with a rationalization for EVERYTHING. But do we really NEED these fixes.

Trek has a great many of these continuity bandaids do we really need to be piling more one? Just make them look reasonable consistent from the beginning and we wouldn't need to fix anything.

[,,,] all while Captain Pike gets bossed around by Captain Georgiou.

Ugh. Eyeroll please. :rolleyes: They way the article states it makes it sound like revenge writing.

"Pike made all that statement about women, Now look, hyuk hyuk, he's getting bossed around by one."

BULLSHIT. Just let it be. Pike doesn't need some sort of comeuppance.

And lastly about the article, they're NOT TUTRLENECKS!

This is a turtleneck:
R761leadwhite__32459.1441126152.560.850.jpg


This is a turtleneck:
corbomitemanuever007.jpg


This is NOT an effing TURTLENECK:
thecage061.jpg


:mad::censored::mad:
 
The Cage happened in 2254, at least a year before Discovery. Uniform rollouts shouldn't take over a year, and that bears out with previous uniform changes in TNG and DS9/movies.
It took the US military years to roll out its new camo uniforms in the early 2000s.
 
In that article, something else in the book is not correct with talking about the uniforms, in fact from the same paragraph in the article linked in the OP: it says that Gant from Shenzhou notices the differences while on a landing party assignment with members of the Enterprise crew (noting the colored uniforms vs. the Shenzhou ones).

In "The Cage" timeframe, they would have been wearing the bluish-grey jackets from the Enterprise, wouldn't they?
 
Why did the division colors change from primary colors to metals and back again?

Why not? The primary colors also changed all the time, not just getting reshuffled but also getting changed altogether - the yellowish of TOS is not the yellowish of the TOS movies or TNG. And none of them would pass for a "primary" yellow in expert circles.

The DSC colors are as close a match to the "The Cage" as one really can get with all-new materials. Somebody put some thought to that one!

Timo Saloniemi
 
For the same reason that the uniforms went from primary colors to beiges, whites and grays in the 2270s and then red mountie suits in the 2280s, and eventually back to primary colors (but now assigned to different divisions) in the 24th century.

Kor
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top