• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Did you have to learn piano as a kid? Are you glad?

I learned to play the guitar, violin, and clarinet.

I never wanted to learn any of those, I wanted singing lessons. And I hate that my mother forced me into it.

I do still play the guitar however.
 
My parents had me take piano lessons as a kid and while I'm certainly not resentful about it I'm not really glad about it either. At the time though, I was frequently not very thrilled about it especially as I grew older. I did terrible, terrible things to our electric metronome when no one was looking.

When it comes to my musical expression, I've always preferred vocal over instrumental. I think that's really what it comes down to for me. I got pretty involved in that in high school (by which time I had already dropped piano lessons) so in retrospect I don't feel that I got anything out of the piano that I wouldn't have gotten from singing. So I certainly don't fault my parents for it or anything like that, but I do think that that time could have been better served elsewhere.

It also didn't help that my younger sister was (and still is) better at it then I was :p
 
I had to force my parents into letting me take music lessons. When I was 5 I apparently (though I don't remember) told my mother I wanted to learn either the cello or the oboe. A mild case of childhood asthma nixed the oboe idea for me, so cello it was. My dad didn't like the idea of spending money for me to learn an instrument, so I had to be creative. When I was 8 I managed to convince the principal of my school to let me join the orchestra, which was a free program but only for 5th and 6th grade students. Since I couldn't afford a cello of my own to practice on at home, I went to school an hour and a half early every day to practice on the school cello -- it was actually the nicest one the school had because it was the only half size: the other students were big enough to start on 3/4 or full sized instruments, so the half size was rarely used.

My mother recognized my devotion and started taking house-cleaning jobs behind my dad's back to save money. By the time I was big enough for a full size cello my parents had divorced and my mom had saved enough to buy me one.

When I was in 7th grade I started skipping school. By the last trimester I had stopped going entirely, except for orchestra. I walked 3 miles to school carrying a cello that was bigger than me to go to orchestra, and then walked home. I skipped 8th grade and moved to a new school district for high school, there they had a better orchestra, and I also joined the West Seattle Community Orchestra. I played in the Seattle Youth Symphony, and made it to principal cellist, and I used my knowledge of music to teach myself the violin, mandolin, and currently, guitar.

My cello is in my closet now, and I've played it only a handful of times in the past ten years. I was so passionate about it in my youth, but I've filled my life with other things these days. I'm happy that I learned it, and it's the only thing I own that I cling to purely out of nostalgia. Maybe someday I'll return to it.
As with many of your personal recounts, this is seven kinds of awesome.
 
I took piano lessons for ten years. I'm not sure whether it was originally my parents' idea or my own, but I loved it and played long into adulthood.
 
I had to force my parents into letting me take music lessons. When I was 5 I apparently (though I don't remember) told my mother I wanted to learn either the cello or the oboe. A mild case of childhood asthma nixed the oboe idea for me, so cello it was. My dad didn't like the idea of spending money for me to learn an instrument, so I had to be creative. When I was 8 I managed to convince the principal of my school to let me join the orchestra, which was a free program but only for 5th and 6th grade students. Since I couldn't afford a cello of my own to practice on at home, I went to school an hour and a half early every day to practice on the school cello -- it was actually the nicest one the school had because it was the only half size: the other students were big enough to start on 3/4 or full sized instruments, so the half size was rarely used.

My mother recognized my devotion and started taking house-cleaning jobs behind my dad's back to save money. By the time I was big enough for a full size cello my parents had divorced and my mom had saved enough to buy me one.

When I was in 7th grade I started skipping school. By the last trimester I had stopped going entirely, except for orchestra. I walked 3 miles to school carrying a cello that was bigger than me to go to orchestra, and then walked home. I skipped 8th grade and moved to a new school district for high school, there they had a better orchestra, and I also joined the West Seattle Community Orchestra. I played in the Seattle Youth Symphony, and made it to principal cellist, and I used my knowledge of music to teach myself the violin, mandolin, and currently, guitar.

My cello is in my closet now, and I've played it only a handful of times in the past ten years. I was so passionate about it in my youth, but I've filled my life with other things these days. I'm happy that I learned it, and it's the only thing I own that I cling to purely out of nostalgia. Maybe someday I'll return to it.
As with many of your personal recounts, this is seven kinds of awesome.
Only seven? I was going for nine. :(


;)

Someday perhaps, when everyone who might be implicated is dead, I will write the story of my life!
 
At five you knew what cellos and oboes were? :eek:
Doesn't everyone?

My friend I can show you example after example of full grown and supposedly educated adults who don't know what those instruments are.
I don't doubt you could, but there's no reason at all why someone shouldn't be able to recognize most of the orchestral instruments at age five, either visually or audibly (and yes, tsq, the part of the duck in Peter and the Wolf was indeed played by the oboe.)
 
My grandmother was the music teacher to many professional Christian artists (many of whom were on The Gaither Homecoming shows), so music lessons were a must for all her grandchildren. She bought the instruments she wanted us to play... and no duplicates were allowed. Each of us took a year of piano, then we could choose our instrument. My choice was taken so I had to settle for electric guitar. I felt more comfortable playing left-handed (everything else is done RH), although my teacher agreed with me, Grandmother overruled me. Eventually, I just stopped trying.

If I tried, I am sure I could still read music... at least the basics. I always wish I had kept our old piano and learned to play better.
 
Never said that a five yar old shouldn't know. Only that I was surprised to see that one did. I sure didn't when I was five, and I'm the barometer of all human intelligence. Go figure
 
My family could never buy a piano, but even when they tried to make me learn in school I didn't really enjoy it. The music teacher had some crazy system of turning papers in that required you to show the paper to the teacher, check your name off, put it in the box, tell the teacher you'd put it in the box, spin around three times and click your heels... all for an instrument that I thought was pretty boring anyway. All I learned was that I had a really interesting wart on the back of my hand.

While not knowing how to read sheet music is definitely hindering my renewed interest in playing music, it's not really something I'm sad about. The two instruments I play (guitar and transverse 12-hole ocarina) both have alternative forms of notation.
 
Noone forced me to take any lessons. At some point I was asked if I wanted to learn some musical instrument and I chose keyboards (not piano). I am very glad I did. I don't play regularly anymore but I do enjoy playing my keyboards whenever I do.
 
Only seven? I was going for nine. :(

;)
What can I say, I'm a traditionalist. For particularly fantastic events, I can rise it to seven times seven kinds of awesome. But you have to work really hard for that. :p

Someday perhaps, when everyone who might be implicated is dead, I will write the story of my life!
Change the names and some details, and do it! Do it now!
 
Last edited:
Did you have to learn piano as a kid?
Actually, I did.


Are you glad?
Sure, why not, music's pretty cool.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top