Did I Miss Something???

[johnnybear]

It's only the accelerated cells that cause death if damaged! Maybe they settle down after a while or not all of them can lead to death! Rael trying to nick Kirk might be enough to kill but a bruise or what might be okay!
JB

 

[Gary7]

It's only the accelerated cells that cause death if damaged! Maybe they settle down after a while or not all of them can lead to death! Rael trying to nick Kirk might be enough to kill but a bruise or what might be okay!
JB

EKOR: "In your struggle with Compton, some of his cells were damaged. Those newly accelerated to our level are sensitive to cell damage. They age rapidly and die."


My interpretation of this content is that the danger of death from cell damage is only when you're "newly accelerated." This suggests that after some time, there is an equilibrium or stabilization, whereby you won't be at risk any longer. If that wasn't the case, you'd die from just flossing your teeth (drawing blood) or skinning a knee. Far too dangerous to live for very long.

I thought the premise of this episode was clever, but not well thought out. Think of the gas molecules in the air... you'd end up struggling to move around anywhere as you slowly push those molecules out of the way. And then, of course, what of oxygen intake? You'd suffocate, because the air won't move fast enough!

I felt that the acceleration was poorly depicted. You'd see people standing around, not moving at all for many minutes. Then later, in a different scene, the person moves a great distance. Like Scotty. It just didn't add up. I think it would've been better to show visually perceived slow movement, but it would've been technically very hard to do realistically given the special effects technology of the day.

 

[johnnybear]

Yep the Scotty lingering in the doorway scene stretched the imagination a little I agree!
JB

 

[ZapBrannigan]

I thought the premise of this episode was clever, but not well thought out. Think of the gas molecules in the air... you'd end up struggling to move around anywhere as you slowly push those molecules out of the way. And then, of course, what of oxygen intake? You'd suffocate, because the air won't move fast enough!

Agreed. TNG did an episode where the ship is about to explode in battle with the Romulans, but the whole tableau is frozen in time, and only a returning shuttle party can move around at normal speed.

In another TNG, Geordi and a female crewman were "phase shifted" such that everybody assumed they were dead, but they were walking around the ship like invisible ghosts, passing through walls and even passing through unshifted people just like air. But they never passed through the floors, even though gravity was holding them down (for some reason) just like the rest of us.

Star Trek will probably always play fast and loose with "fun situation" rules.

 

[Gary7]

Good points. With regards to the TNG episode with Geordi and Ro, I guess that suggests that there's ample air even in the "shifted phase" plane of existence. What they should have done with Timescape, is that the landing party should have been equipped with an oxygen supply. So they'd be breathing their own "time contained" air... and thus solve the problem of trying to breathe air that isn't moving.

 

[Spock's Barber]

Yep the Scotty lingering in the doorway scene stretched the imagination a little I agree!
JB

Poor James Doohan had to literally freeze like a statue for filming those scenes.

 

[johnnybear]

Poor James Doohan had to literally freeze like a statue for filming those scenes.

Really? But I thought he was like that because Kirk and Spock were trapped between one second and the next my Lord!
JB

 

[alensatemybuick1]

Reminds me of the end-credits from a couple of the old "Police Squad" episodes...

 

[Tenacity]

The radiation around the planet caused the Scalosians to become sterile in addition to the hyperacceleration.

Apparently only the males became sterile, not the women.

The radiation that accelerated the few surviving Scalosians, might have directly killed off the majority of the planet's original population.

 

[johnnybear]

And then there were five...
JB

 

[Qonundrum]

Sitting down damages some of your cells.

Yeah, but do people prefer discussing the joys of sitting down more than the joys of

Spoiler

(making coffee with that delicious sugar free peppermint chocolate flavoring loaded with high fructose corn syrup... :9 )

?

 

[Phaser Two]

Yep the Scotty lingering in the doorway scene stretched the imagination a little I agree!
JB

Interestingly he does move forward a bit between scenes, which I think is a nice touch. But I believe the real reason, out of universe, that he was there was to serve as a doorstop to keep the transporter room door open. Otherwise Kirk and Deela couldn't have just walked right in. (It's also handy to have Scotty there to show that Kirk has been decelerated by the antidote.) In universe, Spock ordering Scotty to the transporter room makes very little sense.

 

[Boomer359]

That's right. I remember now that they were going to use the Enterprise crew as breeding stock. But wouldn't it take decades for that large number of Scalosians to die off?

Why wouldn't acceleration sterilize the crew of the Enterprise, then, too?

 

[johnnybear]

Why wouldn't acceleration sterilize the crew of the Enterprise, then, too?

Eventually perhaps, maybe that's why the Scalosians were in such a hurry to repopulate their planet!
JB