When I first saw AOTC, I was of the opinion that it was a quantum leap over TPM in terms of quality. Time has not improved my opinion. I now think that, in spite of it's flaws, TPM is the one movie in the Prequel Trilogy that most "feels" like a Star Wars film. But I still (for all their many, many faults) love the PT. I think AOTC is the weakest, but the arena battle is one of my favorite things out of all six of the original movies.