2-17 Playing God
I didn't care much for either of the plots in Playing God. First there's the proto-universe story, which doesn't makes much sense and is loaded with heinous amounts of technobabble. Since that story took a backseat to the Dax one you could never really get invested in it, or frankly to understand why they didn't go along with Kira's suggestion right from the start and wipe it out. Those lofty high Trek morals sound good on paper, but what are they worth if you and perhaps your entire universe are obliterated in the process. The resolution was as simple as inexplicable. Exactly why would it work to get it back to the Gamma quadrant? Presumably it could expand and grow from there too, and eventually consume the rest of our universe anyway.
Then there is the Dax plot that I also didn't like that much. While it is interesting to get glimpses into Trill society, I couldn't sympathize with either Jadzia Dax, who was much too rude, or the initiate Arjin, who obviously never should've gotten into the symbiont program in the first place. Why Dax didn't flunk him then and there is a mystery. It's not like he wouldn't have any career left. He was a good pilot for starters. But I did enjoy the view of Jadzia in a towel and with her hair hanging loosely. She'll get her ice cream tonight!
The only part I can say I liked were the Cardassian voles. I hope we get to see more of those critters.
Playing God receives a grade of 3+ from me.
2-18 Profit and Loss
Profit and Loss was a somewhat interesting episode, but I found it hard to believe in Quark trying to fill Humphrey Bogart's shoes (yes, this episode is clearly influenced by Casablanca). It did rob him of a of his usual Ferengi traits to have him be this much in love with Natima, a dissident Cardassian woman. Her makeup looked great, by the way, and you just had to wonder how far down those scales went. And for a Cardie, she looked very good. But I had a hard time believing in the love affair, there was little chemistry and call me a bigot, but it felt a bit disgusting conjuring up images of the two of them doing the… well, you know!
Garak is what saves this episode. Once you think you may know him, he surprises you. You really can't tell what side he is on. But I found it implausible that he'd just vaporize that Gul with no repercussions, either from station security of the Cardassian homeworld.
Speaking of implausibilities, I also found it odd that Odo could take it upon himself to just release the Cardassian dissidents (or whatever they were, it was never made clear). He - and Sisko - serves at the behest of the Bajoran government, and one would think they'd be very pissed off at this blatant refusal to follow orders and in the process probably stop the release of Bajoran nationals.
Still, in the end I give Profit and Loss an average grade of 5+.
I didn't care much for either of the plots in Playing God. First there's the proto-universe story, which doesn't makes much sense and is loaded with heinous amounts of technobabble. Since that story took a backseat to the Dax one you could never really get invested in it, or frankly to understand why they didn't go along with Kira's suggestion right from the start and wipe it out. Those lofty high Trek morals sound good on paper, but what are they worth if you and perhaps your entire universe are obliterated in the process. The resolution was as simple as inexplicable. Exactly why would it work to get it back to the Gamma quadrant? Presumably it could expand and grow from there too, and eventually consume the rest of our universe anyway.
Then there is the Dax plot that I also didn't like that much. While it is interesting to get glimpses into Trill society, I couldn't sympathize with either Jadzia Dax, who was much too rude, or the initiate Arjin, who obviously never should've gotten into the symbiont program in the first place. Why Dax didn't flunk him then and there is a mystery. It's not like he wouldn't have any career left. He was a good pilot for starters. But I did enjoy the view of Jadzia in a towel and with her hair hanging loosely. She'll get her ice cream tonight!
The only part I can say I liked were the Cardassian voles. I hope we get to see more of those critters.
Playing God receives a grade of 3+ from me.
2-18 Profit and Loss
Profit and Loss was a somewhat interesting episode, but I found it hard to believe in Quark trying to fill Humphrey Bogart's shoes (yes, this episode is clearly influenced by Casablanca). It did rob him of a of his usual Ferengi traits to have him be this much in love with Natima, a dissident Cardassian woman. Her makeup looked great, by the way, and you just had to wonder how far down those scales went. And for a Cardie, she looked very good. But I had a hard time believing in the love affair, there was little chemistry and call me a bigot, but it felt a bit disgusting conjuring up images of the two of them doing the… well, you know!
Garak is what saves this episode. Once you think you may know him, he surprises you. You really can't tell what side he is on. But I found it implausible that he'd just vaporize that Gul with no repercussions, either from station security of the Cardassian homeworld.
Speaking of implausibilities, I also found it odd that Odo could take it upon himself to just release the Cardassian dissidents (or whatever they were, it was never made clear). He - and Sisko - serves at the behest of the Bajoran government, and one would think they'd be very pissed off at this blatant refusal to follow orders and in the process probably stop the release of Bajoran nationals.
Still, in the end I give Profit and Loss an average grade of 5+.