• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Countdown to Darkness - Review and Discussion

Rate the comics

  • Excellent

    Votes: 5 14.7%
  • Above Average

    Votes: 13 38.2%
  • Average

    Votes: 10 29.4%
  • Below Average

    Votes: 2 5.9%
  • Poor

    Votes: 4 11.8%

  • Total voters
    34
^My bad. I could have sworn they were in 2233. It would be cool if Garber was Kor. He did a great job in that deleted scene :klingon:
 
I hope they re-use some of the 'established' villains more than once.

I prefer longer stories but the Redshirts Tale was by far the strongest single shot story. A really good read.

I was disappointed in the conclusion to Countdown to Darkness. It was an interesting build up and then a tease but they may resolve it properly after the movie which would be fun.

Is a movie adaptation planned? There will be a conspicuous gap in the narrative if not.
 
Is Abramsverse-Kor supposed to be the Klingon played by Victor Garber in the ST XI deleted scene? The one where he interrogates Nero?

Those scenes were in 2233, so if it was Kor, that would make him a hell of a lot older in the jjverse than in the prime U.

Actually when we first meet Kor, we have absolutely no idea how old he is. I'm not aware of any mention of his age anywhere in an episode.
 
Actually when we first meet Kor, we have absolutely no idea how old he is. I'm not aware of any mention of his age anywhere in an episode.

In "Blood Oath," Odo says that Kor "must be a hundred years old" and Koloth is "probably a hundred and fifty years old," but those are rough at best, seeing as how the episode is 103 years after "Errand of Mercy."
 
Every time I saw April he reminded me of someone. I assumed the artists might have used an actor as a photo reference. I racked my brain and then it struck me, April looks like Bruce Boxleitner. Then I had second thoughts and decided he looked like Roscoe Born.
 
Pretty meager lead-in to the new film. Nowhere near as fun as Countdown was.
 
I hope there is at least a reference to April in the film, even if he doesn't appear (which he probably won't; otherwise we would have heard about it).
 
I just finished CtD. I enjoyed it. If the story and action had been punched up a bit more I would've been happy if this plot had been the movie. I pictured Jon Voight as April.

That being said I didn't enjoy it as much as I did Countdown. There were so many little geek out moments in Countdown and there were only a handful here. Countdown was much less constrained because it could do whatever it wanted in the 24th century for the most part.

It was good seeing Captain April and I'm guessing this Admiral Marcus character is Carol Marcus's dad. Wasn't expecting to see a Mudd or that she would be Bajoran (?). It was also cool seeing the Klingons, though I wish they would ditch the leather helmets and I don't like that new Klingon ship design.
 
Overall, I have to rate it as average. Issues 3 & 4 pumped me up for the movie a bit more (I'm already excited for it regardless of tie-in comics), but still the whole shebang wasn't nearly as entertaining as the Ongoing series or Countdown.
 
I found CTD to be entertaining on its own merits. But it did nothing to excite me for Into Darkness. The last page felt so tacked on, like, "oh crap, we better throw a mention into Cumberbatch's character!"
 
I liked issue #3, right up until the point where April explained how he was able to commandeer the Enterprise. I could not believe that Starfleet copied April's failsafe program from the previous Enterprise into the new Enterprise's computer. My reaction was, "What? How does that even make any foxtroting sense?"

I feel like I've read this particular story before, but I'm having a difficult time placing exactly where.

I felt exactly the same. This is the laziest piece of writing in this series yet. I hate deus ex machina solutions like that. I can not believe that starfleet engineers would be that lazy when setting up the computer systems on the top of the line ships. It's just not believeable at all.
Why would they "copy" it anyways? It's a completely new ship. Just because of the name Enterprise? Ridiculous.

After seeing the movie
This contrivance doesn't seem so far-fetched or out of the blue. From the new movie, we see that Admiral Marcus must have had this back door system installed into every ship: that's how he must have cut the Enterprise's engines on the Klingon border. I always thought it odd that April's secret password was "Caroline" instead of, say "Sara." Now I see that the Caroline password is actually Marcus' selection, probably being his daughter's full first name.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top