Supernatural is on the CW, right? At its best, Supernatural has a very dark tone and can be quite graphic at times. The CW also doesn't shy away from homosexual relationships, questioning religion, or morally ambiguous protagonists. Maybe it is a good fit?
I'll have to take your word for it. I never was able to get into
Supernatural. It seems like fun from what I hear about it, and I've caught a very few of the more comedic episodes (including two of the Felicia Day ones), but I've never found the lead actors or the premise at all interesting.
And yeah, between Captain Singh on
The Flash and Nyssa and Sarah on
Arrow, I'd say The CW is pretty LGB-friendly. And didn't the lead character on
The 100 turn out to be bisexual? I'd stopped watching by that point, but I read something about it.