^yea! a convert!
Simultude is one of my favourite episodes too. I'm always amazed that the kid they got to play Trip at about 12 looks/sounds so much like CT
My favorite Tripism from the kid is in sickbay when he asks Archer can we go play with the spaceship again and he raises his eyebrows...
Trinneer has said "Similitude" is his favorite episode. It's right up there for me, too, with "Observer Effect," "The Forgotten," a couple others.
I couldn't take my eyes off it when I first saw it. The scene between Sim and T'Pol in her quarters..."You're all I think about..." The music... (The music won an Emmy.)
There's a lot of subtext to the dialogue, a lot of nuance to the performances. A compelling plot that puts the characters under pressure and reveals all sorts of things about them. The subtlety of Trinneer's turn as Sim, making him Trip, but not Trip. The way Archer seemed to age about twenty years over the course of a week, because of the burden of creating Sim. That scene between Sim and Archer in Trip's quarters-- "I need Trip! Trip!" I thought Bakula was wonderful, too.
I think this was one of Connor's best performances ever. And the scenes in T'Pol's quarters and with Archer in Trip's quarters were brilliant.
That scene between Sim and Archer in Trip's quarters-- "I need Trip! Trip!" I thought Bakula was wonderful, too.
Now that is the scene I've always felt was wrong and not Archer-like, though Bakula and Trinneer played it well.
I must say I'm perplexed about Similitude: acting job is great, yet the whole episode doesn't convince me somehow. I've an impression as if the writers didn't know what exactly should be the ethical problem they wanted to discuss.
OMG, I think that scene in Trip's quarters was dead-on. Right from the start, Archer keeps his emotional distance. Even with Kid-Sim, he isn't the father figure -- compare that with Trip's relationship with the boy in Marauders -- he's just working his way up to telling Sim the truth about himself. He cares, but he's struggling not to care too much.
So when Sim says he can "replace" Trip, Archer loses it. He knows that Sim could replace Trip as chief engineer, but he can't replace Trip as his friend. When he says "I need Trip!" what he's really saying is "I
want Trip!" Which is very Archer-like. He can be a real jerk sometimes, but he has enough clarity to know that Trip is irreplaceable.