• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Communicating With Aliens

^^ no use if they use decimal computers or character based systems..

It doesn't matter what their character system is. If they have computers they understand 1s and 0s. If I was communicating with a person who only spoke Cantonese, and that person understood computers, they'd still understand what number I was trying to represent in binary.

Even if they have computers that don't function in binary bits, they'd still have had to evolve through that to get there and still have an understanding of binary math.

But isn't the whole "maths is a universal language" thing a myth?

Yes, because it's not a language. It's just universal. The same mathematical things that are true for us are true for them. The constant you have to multiply by to calculate the circumference of a circle is the same for everyone.

That's why I say, the way you show the aliens you are trying to communicate and establish a baseline for the method of communication, you start with recognizable mathematical constants, in a manner that any species that can build a computer can recognize. The purpose of that is to give a hint that not only you are trying to communicate with them, but how you are planning to do it. Once that baseline is established, you use it to start establishing a vocabulary.

It doesn't matter if they approach math a little differently. They could use different words, different notation, whatever, it doesn't matter. All roads lead to the same end. They could represent that 2 + 3 = 5 by ASDFADSF /// asdfasdfh *** 999008. It wouldn't stop them from understanding what we meant if we sent them: oo + ooo = ooooo. They wouldn't know what + and = meant, but because they understand the math they would glean the meanings of those symbols from the context.
 
Last edited:
Even if they have computers that don't function in binary bits, they'd still have had to evolve through that to get there and still have an understanding of binary math.

That is one hell of a leap to make. It works under the assumption their brains are going to work like our brains do. Computers could have evolved in a completely different manner based on how they evolved and what their capabilities are.
 
Using mathematical constants is a good way just to let the aliens know our current level of advancement. But of course you'd need to establish context before you can really communicate meaning.

Message 1: 11 111 11111 1111111 11111111111
The first five primes, to give the aliens a hint for the next message.

Message 2: 10 11 101 111 1011
The same five primes in binary since they have the hint from the first message we're talking about primes, now they know we are using binary numbers to communicate.

Message 3:
11 001001000011111101101010100010001000010110100011000010001101001100010011000110011000101000101110000000110111000001110011010001
Pi in binary. They already understand the hint that we use a binary counting system, so they calculate what those numbers might mean, and recognize it as Pi.

Message 4:
(Picture of animal) 0001. (Picture of human) 0001 11. (Picture of building) 110110. (And so on)
They already understand we're using binary numbers to express things. Now they have a hint we're using them as language and sharing them the basic vocabulary.

And so on. A process of first establishing context by showing them something simple they already recognize, then building on what you taught them.

Good idea, but how do you know that you didn't just insult the Slug Queen's Mother on Sluggonia XVIII?


https://www.slashgear.com/strange-radio-transmissions-are-emanating-from-proxima-centauri-19651887/

Strange radio transmissions are emanating from Proxima Centauri

Something strange is going on at the closest star to the sun. A mysterious radio signal is coming from Proxima Centauri, which is too dim to be seen from Earth with the naked eye. Despite being too dim for us to see from Earth, it’s a cosmic stone throw away at only 4.2 light-years away. A mysterious signal is emanating from the star, which was discovered in archived data gathered last year.

[The signal](https://www.scientificamerican.com/...over-mysterious-signal-from-proxima-centauri/) was discovered this fall and appears to come from the direction of Proxima Centauri. As of now, researchers have been unable to dismiss the signal as interference from Earth. While detecting a strange signal coming from a nearby star certainly has tantalizing possibilities, scientists on the project caution, there is still lots of work to be done.

Researcher Andrew Siemion from the University of California, Berkeley has said that the signal has properties that have caused it to pass many checks so far, and it can’t be explained. One of the most curious aspects of the signal is that it occupies an extremely narrow radio spectrum of 982 megahertz. That is a spectral range that is typically empty of any transmissions from human-made satellites and spacecraft.


One of the most curious aspects of the signal is that it occupies an extremely narrow radio spectrum of 982 megahertz. That is a spectral range that is typically empty of any transmissions from human-made satellites and spacecraft.

Space Weather Phenomena

https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/phenomena

In the article there are numerous topics relating to space weather phenomena, but none are below the 1,000 megahertz range.

The anomaly definitely isn't a solar flare from Proxima Centauri's sun.

Solar flares occur in a power-law spectrum of magnitudes; an energy release of typically 1020 joules of energy suffices to produce a clearly observable event, while a major event can emit up to 1025 joules.

The researcher says that there is no known natural way to compress electromagnetic energy into a single band frequency. Siemion does say that there could be some unknown exotic work of plasma physics that could account for the signal. However, he admits that for now, the only source that is known for such a signal is technological.

If the signal however does prove to be a natural effect of plasma physics compressing EM energy into a single band frequency, then let the good times roll.
 
The main reason that I believe that Earth hasn't received a return signal from a sentient life form is as simple as the binary language that we communicate into the stars with. Our binary language is often times encoded with mathematical formulas and representations of an alphabet and numbering system.

An alien race would discount such a simple and flat base of communication as being cold and having no life, like a machine. A machine that simply spits out letters and numbers and mathematical formula. If an alien race did encounter our signal it would perceive our location as being a very machine ran world without sentient life, possibly a world ran by machines, highly intelligent machines that killed off the human population in an attempt to protect its own existence, if you will. After rendering all threats of life on Earth non-threats through eradication, the machine returned to its original programming of serving the human race even though the human race no longer existed. Thus an alien civilization might never contact Earth for fear of the machines returning to their defense program, developing ships to locate and eradicate the human based lifeform. Thus a 'cold signal' would never attract an alien species.

A sentient life would expect depth to a signal sent by another sentient species that would include the sentient species in the center of a circle denoting that this circle representation plus its heartbeat signal is dominant over all other species. The pyramid below the central circle would then contain various images of animals and their heartbeat patterns in descending order of dominance below humans. A three pointed triangle does convey more depth, both 2D and 3D that would also inform the alien species that humans were able to thick in at least three dimensions, the forth dimension being able to communicate in depth across the void as a living planet full of life instead of a cold heart beat that is the machine.

The first triangle of the first two alien species would match up along the sides, their circles of dominance and sentience overlapping each other to form a new chain, that as the triangles are formed, perfectly amongst sentient species, then a new symbol of a new empire would be formed.

When probing the heavens for the beast, one does not use frozen water to lure the beast in, for the beast can drink of water by ravaging the snow bank around a long forgotten and rotting tree. The beast can drink water at any time for the water is soothing and calms the beast into sleep.

Buy when the primal and warm sound of man beckons through the snow covered woods, the water quickly turns to a frozen and distasteful reminder of laziness and less fortune within the gut of the beast.

The beast desires a hunt and only the call of warm blood through the frozen and chilled night will remedy the scourge in the beast. Tracking the warm call to the heart of the warrior. Warm blood that melts the frigid edges of loneliness of the beast.

Warm blood that as it drips from the beasts pelt being held up by the warrior, the other beasts watching with cold and hollow eyes from the darkness will remember that humans may take warm fuzzy creatures as pets, but our call into the night is but the tip our blade, our spear that will let them know they have been cut long before they even arrive on Earth. For each call into the night of space is but a powerful thrust of the sword to bleed the beast to attract the next errant fool who thinks that humans are warm and fuzzy rabbits in the frozen forrest of the Universe.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top