• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Butch & Sundance & westerns of 1969

J.T.B.

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Today, October 24, is the 40th anniversary of the general US release of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, written by William Goldman directed by George Roy Hill. A very '60s kind of western, its modern tone and musical interludes were too much for most critics, but it went on to become the most successful western movie of all time. The casual and good-humored interaction between Paul Newman and Robert Redford would provide the template for the "buddy picture" for years to come.

Though not as successful, two other landmark westerns were made in 1969: Sam Peckinpah's The Wild Bunch and True Grit, directed by Henry Hathaway from a popular novel by Charles Portis. The Wild Bunch, which gained immediate notoriety for upping the level of screen violence, is a strong ensemble piece with innovative, kinetic editing style and sound design. True Grit is a solid and nicely-detailed adaptation of an excellent revenge-tale with a unique female perspective, but is mostly known for the performance of western icon John Wayne. Sixty-one years old and down to one lung, Wayne plays against his normal active, upstanding type as a declining, drunken lawman who isn't above bending the law when it suits him.

What these quite different movies have in common is the theme of the end of the old west. All are set closer to 1900 than to the Civil War (The Wild Bunch is in the 19-teens), and the last frontiers of the country have been tamed and settled. The rough and violent men who thrived in the "wild west" are not needed or wanted in the newly-civilized territories. In True Grit and The Wild Bunch, the violent men are needed one last time for missions that civilized men can't undertake. In Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, the violent men say to hell with the new order; they turn their backs on it and leave to find a new un-civilized place where they can live as they have always done.

Like these movies, I was also made in 1969, so I never saw them in their theatrical runs, but have seen all three on the big screen. I grew up seeing "Butch and Sundance" on TV (I even remember watching it in a junior high school auditorium), and it was always a favorite of mine and my brother's. I saw True Grit on TV early on, but never thought much of it until I began to appreciate John Wayne in my twenties. I knew little about The Wild Bunch until its 1995 theatrical re-release. I saw it three times in the week it played in a local art-house and knew I had found one of my all-time favorite movies.

BTW, Jeff Corey has small but important roles in True Grit and Butch Cassidy, but good old Strother Martin managed to appear in all three!

It's for me hard to rank these films, I love them all. I'd like to see what others think of any or all of them. Thanks for reading this far!

Justin
 
I saw True Grit in the theater during its original run. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and The Wild Bunch are both classics, but I saw both of those on TV, years later. True Grit always ranks higher for me, just because it was something I could enjoy with my dad.
 
It's never really occurred to me before that three such classic and seminal westerns all were released in the same year (and at a time when the genre was in termical decline, too).

My favourite is easily Butch and Sundance, still one of the definitive 'buddy movies' and just a great fun piece of cinema. The chemistry between Newman (RIP) and Redford is just so perfect, it's almost unthinkable that Steve McQueen was first choice to play Sundance (he was too much like Newman for one thing).

I've never been a John Wayne fan but I do like True Grit, though its been years from I've seen it. As the OP said, Wayne's illness and vulnerability in the role make it interesting, though I much prefer his final picture, The Shootist.

As for the Wild Bunch, it's the only one I own on DVD, having bought it on the strength of its acclaim. I did find it somewhat over-rated, as I find much of Peckinpah to be over-rated but it's certainly a striking and unique movie.

The three movies do certainly represent three very different and memorable takes on the western. God knows, I wish we saw more westerns nowadays instead of torture porn, horror movies and rom-coms ...
 
I love westerns, and all three of these are big winners.

It's hard to rank them, but right now I would say

Wild Bunch
True Grit
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

The Wild Bunch is just such a well filmed story, and it has a roughness that a lot of older westerns lack. The final battle is one of the best shootouts ever. It's a good story.

True Grit Is a movie with flaws, but all is made up for by John Wayne's exellent performance. I've always found the entire first half to be a bit tedious and nothing special, but the second half is western perfection. At the climax, When Rooster flys forward of his horse, with two rifles blazing, might be the single most thrilling moment in any western.

I do agree That The Shootist is much better. It's underrated, one of Wayne's best movies.

I saw Butch and Sundance on the big screen just a few months back. It's a very fun "buddy" picture. It's the funniest western I've seen, and Newman and Redford play off eachother perfectly.

Speaking of other westerns, I've always thought the magnificent seven was overrated. I've always thought the direction was plain and unexciting, It also has a terrible romantic subplot.

I think my favorite Western Might be Shane, Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, or The Shootist.
 
^ But the Magnificent 7 has all sorts of great scenes, a superb cast, a great theme tune and all sorts of poignancy during the final shoot-out. Ah well, to each his own.

My own fave western is The Outlaw Josey Wales, FWIW.
 
Loved "Butch", thought "The Wild Bunch" was very innovative and could care less about "True Grit".

Loved "The Shootist", get a kick out of "Support Your Local..." and think the #2 Western of all time(after "Butch") is "Silverado". So sue me.
 
I really enjoy a good western, although I wasn't sure what to make of The Wild Bunch when I first saw it on DVD three or four years ago. I need to see it again.

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid is a fun movie, and I'm surprised that the critics so decisively panned it upon its original release. I can understand seeing it as a glossier, packaged version of Bonnie and Clyde when it was first released, but it doesn't appear to me in those terms 40 years later. As far as the two Newman/Redford pairings go, though, I think I enjoy The Sting much more.

I like True Grit, too. John Wayne created a one-note star personality, but this film allows him to show a little versatility. I'm curious to see how the Coen Bros. remake it, if they end up going through with that project.

My favorite western, though? A tough call. Leone's two masterpieces of the spaghetti western off-shoot, The Good, The Bad and the Ugly and Once Upon a Time in the West are great. And The Magnificent Seven is a really solid film. It's a remake that is actually as worthwhile as the film it remade.
 
the #2 Western of all time(after "Butch") is "Silverado". So sue me.

I haven't seen it, so can't agree or disagree. But a lot of people really like its director Lawrence Kasdan's subsequent teaming with Kevin Costner in Wyatt Earp (despite a critical panning at the time). Plus Silverado seems to have a great cast. Must look it out some time.
 
the #2 Western of all time(after "Butch") is "Silverado". So sue me.

I haven't seen it, so can't agree or disagree. But a lot of people really like its director Lawrence Kasdan's subsequent teaming with Kevin Costner in Wyatt Earp (despite a critical panning at the time). Plus Silverado seems to have a great cast. Must look it out some time.

Highly rec! Great cast! Costner, Glenn, Kline, Dennehy, Goldblum, Cleese, Glover-there are very few faces you won't recognize.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top