If they are not going to trust a TV auteur like Fuller, and they plan to do it by committee (big surprise), then they need to bring in ALL of the old guard, not just Meyer and Menosky. Otherwise it's gonna be an ever more watered down version than the JJverse.
It's true that Trek is not defined by its creators (ironically), but the problem is today's market is not ideal for Trek. Without a creative force like Fuller it will be Berman/Braga all over again with more explosions.
No.
Constantly recycling the same creative folks over and over, combined with oversaturation is what doomed Trek to begin with. They need new people in the driver's seat. I have no real issue with Fuller stepping aside for people new to Trek.