• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Bob Orci's Comment: The Film Stood on its Own Without...[Spoilers]

He fled and had no idea what had become of the 72 torpedoes. He interferes in the fight between Kirk's people and the Klingons, presumably, because of what Kirk said about advanced torpedoes in the "surrender" message he transmitted earlier. And Khan surrenders when Kirk answers the question "how many torpedoes?"
 
Maybe you should see the movie before objecting to how he is shown. His motivation is made very clear and understandable. He's ruthless, but he does care about his people and doesn't want them hurt. His plan involves getting revenge and saving his people.

Actually, at the point where we first see him in the film, he thinks all his people were killed by Marcus.
I thought he said something about being the one who put them in the torpedoes and shielding them. Marcus just knew and wanted to use them to kill him and start a war with the Klingons.

He fled and had no idea what had become of the 72 torpedoes. He interferes in the fight between Kirk's people and the Klingons, presumably, because of what Kirk said about advanced torpedoes in the "surrender" message he transmitted earlier. And Khan surrenders when Kirk answers the question "how many torpedoes?"

Exactly.

Up to this point he still thought them all dead, otherwise he wouldn't have acted as he did when he openly attacked Admiral Marcus' meeting.
 
I don't understand the logic of this. If they decided to go with Khan to bring in a crowd, why not plaster his name all over every poster and trailer they made? That would've told the non-Trek fans to expect the best villain we can give you, the Joker to our Batman, because Khan is back!

Maybe it's less about bringing a crowd in and more about bringing in repeat viewers?
 
I should get two, because Gaila is dead.

But you know what, I'll just take Spock and you can have Kirk and McCoy both :)

(send postcards)

Honey, there won't be time to send postcards.
e5023670.gif
 
I think the movie tried too hard to have its cake and eat it too.

It's trying to reinvent the franchise with its own vision, but it's also leaning on fan memory of the old movies to establish its themes.

Take Khan. Pretend the original series didn't exist, this is just a new movie in a new franchise. So you have no idea how dangerous Khan was from the original series. Based only on this movie, how scared are you of Khan? He seems like a pretty bad guy, and an unfeeling sociopath. But on his own, separated from his resources do you really feel like he's the greatest threat the galaxy has ever known?

The movie did not work very hard to establish Khan as a threat, it leaned on the fans' memory of Wrath of Khan, and the fans' memory of the scenes it directly reproduced from Wrath Of Khan. Which is something you don't get to do if you're completely changing the series.
 
I think the movie tried too hard to have its cake and eat it too.

It's trying to reinvent the franchise with its own vision, but it's also leaning on fan memory of the old movies to establish its themes.

Take Khan. Pretend the original series didn't exist, this is just a new movie in a new franchise. So you have no idea how dangerous Khan was from the original series. Based only on this movie, how scared are you of Khan? He seems like a pretty bad guy, and an unfeeling sociopath. But on his own, separated from his resources do you really feel like he's the greatest threat the galaxy has ever known?

The movie did not work very hard to establish Khan as a threat, it leaned on the fans' memory of Wrath of Khan, and the fans' memory of the scenes it directly reproduced from Wrath Of Khan. Which is something you don't get to do if you're completely changing the series.

If he's a man with apparent superhuman skills, and the charisma to match, as he's shown to be? Absolutely.
To be honest, Montalban's Khan never struck me as highly intelligent, or particularly superhuman. I feel that Cumberbatch's Khan exceeds Montalban in almost every way, and is superior.
 
They were holding his people hostage, he mentions it in dialogue.

Well, I haven't seen the movie yet. But still, would an aggressive tyrant who ruled half of Asia submit to "his people" being held "hostage"? I'd think he would have ripped some heads off at the beginning, and it'd be a done deal. After all, he took over an entire starship in 'Space Seed'.

KHAN SMASH!!!!! would not have saved his people. He did plan to get his people back. So what if it took a year before his plan was ready to execute? He's superior, not omnipotent.
 
The movie did not work very hard to establish Khan as a threat, it leaned on the fans' memory of Wrath of Khan, and the fans' memory of the scenes it directly reproduced from Wrath Of Khan. Which is something you don't get to do if you're completely changing the series.

He blew up a Starfleet Archive (which turned out to actually be a Section 31 operation base), he attacked and killed Starfleet Admirals, Captains and other officers including killing Pike. And got away to Kronos. I think that was a good threat
 
But still, would an aggressive tyrant who ruled half of Asia submit to "his people" being held "hostage"? I'd think he would have ripped some heads off at the beginning, and it'd be a done deal. After all, he took over an entire starship in 'Space Seed'.

When that attempt to take over the Enterprise in Space Seed was finally thwarted, he submitted to being exiled to Ceti Alpha V rather than try again from a less advantageous position and risk the lives of his (now incapacitated by knockout gas) people. He no longer had the element of surprise on his side, numbers, or an insider he could manipulate fully (McGivers had saved Kirk), so he knew the game was lost. That's the same position he was in at the start of Into Darkness. His people were incapacitated and in potential danger, he was alone under Marcus' watchful eye, and he was a known threat. He needed to gain an advantage again, manipulate insiders to do his bidding, and get his people to safety before he could strike.

They're supermen, not Superman. They're not invulnerable. Powerful though he is, Khan can't take on all of Starfleet alone and with his people held hostage. He needs "allies" he can manipulate to gain an advantage, like the desperate father in the beginning and Kirk later on.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top