• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Batman: The Animated Series / MillenniuM

^^No, the "Fire From Olympus" segment of the overture sounds exactly like what was in the episode to me. Why would they have recorded a separate overture version for that episode, particularly one nearly four minutes long?

Meanwhile, I was wrong about the Joker cue from the overture being from "Joker's Favor." It's actually from "The Last Laugh," I believe the "Joker Loots Gotham" cue.
 
Interesting... the score for "Two-Face Part 2" includes the 30-second cue that was routinely used for the recap segments in B:TAS two-parters, even though that cue is actually an excerpt from the score to "The Forgotten." I guess they included it there because it's the only 2-parter in the album.

Overall, I think the "Two-Face" score was, if not the best B:TAS score Walker ever did, certainly very close to the top. It's the best one in this collection, to be sure. She was really firing on all cylinders here. Of course, it's a very poignant story that gave her a lot to work with. Meanwhile, I sometimes forget just how good the score in the last act of "Pretty Poison" is.

The "Music of the Bat 101" segment was described in liner notes as an interview, but it's just Walker talking and playing a piano, and from the acoustics and her delivery, it sounds like maybe she was giving a lecture or demonstration in an auditorium. I wonder what the source of this is. Anyway, it's interesting to hear her dissect and explain her Batman theme, and to hear her perform it in bare-bones form on the piano.

All in all, this is a great collection to have. Of course I can pop in my DVDs and watch the episodes anytime, but it's great to be able to hear the music in the clear and pick up on details I never noticed before. For instance, I never realized the bass line in the Two-Face theme is on a bass clarinet, which has a really great, disturbing sound to it.

But I do have a few regrets. I wish the overture hadn't included so many segments that are also featured elsewhere on the CD; they could've devoted that time to longer cues from "Heart of Ice" and "Feat of Clay," and maybe a bit from some other episodes too. Also, I don't think we needed three Joker episodes on one disk. "Joker's Favor" is a classic, but I would've gladly lost either of the other two in favor of something different. (I guess the one I'd ditch is "Christmas With the Joker." Although the hip-hop drumbeat cue on "The Last Laugh" is off-putting to me, the episode's score is actually pretty good overall, I have to admit.)

Of course, I assume that some scores or overture cues were left out for legal/financial reasons, in that the producers were only willing or able to dish out royalties to so many composers. For instance, nothing of Harvey Cohen's is represented here, nor anything from other composers like Stu Balcomb. And maybe the brevity of the "Heart of Ice" segment on the overture is because Todd Hayen did most (?) of that score. It's a long shot, but I'm hoping this CD's sales were good enough that they do another, hopefully focusing strongly on Cohen's work (particularly "A Bullet for Bullock").
 
I know Cohen died, but so did Walker, and that didn't preclude them from using her music. Obviously the rights would rest with his estate.

And the onscreen credits to "Heart of Ice" name both Todd Hayen and Shirley Walker.
 
My copy is on its way...another week or so and it should get here right in time for Christmas! Christopher...since you've listened to it, does Christmas With the Joker have Mark Hamil signing the Batman jingle bell lyrics or just the music?
 
^^No vocals on "Xmas With the Joker." Just the instrumental accompaniment. In the parts where the Arkham inmates are singing, the instrumental is apparently meant to be source music, since it sounds like an electric organ or something.
 
IT CAME! OH MY GOSH...................IT CAME!!!!!!!!!!!


HELL FU***** YEAH!!!!!!!!


IT CAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Like the pictures from the series in the booklet, and Batman and Joker pictures on the two discs. This is so awesome!!

Nice honor/dedication to Shirley Walker.

Excellent release! Will listen to it soon! I hope they release another cd collection of music!
 
They said at a film score board that all orders are finally processed and being packed and will ship in a few days.

They are also asking for Volume 2 whether we want complete scores or just cues.

COMPLETE!!!!! The music is fantastic, just one cue here and there doesn't do it!!!
 
Complete would be nice, but there's something to be said for focusing on the high points of each score so as to fit more episodes in. The best thing might be something similar to this, complete episodes plus a medley of shorter excerpts, but increase the quantity and duration of the excerpts. And avoid the kind of repetition we had here, with the overture containing several cues also heard elsewhere on the set.
 
Many of the scores are solid efforts all in themselves, and have plenty of variations onf themes, other themes or motifs used once only, picking just one or two cues is like ripping one or two chapters of a good book and hoping that's enough. It's really not.


Plus, taking into consideration the studio didn't want to do the CDs years back, and the re-use fees were really high and we're lucky we even got this at all, La La Land Records should take full advantage of a fiiendly studio and current fanbase and get it while they can before the studio changes it's mind, or changes hands and the new owners don't give a rat's ass.
 
Many of the scores are solid efforts all in themselves, and have plenty of variations onf themes, other themes or motifs used once only, picking just one or two cues is like ripping one or two chapters of a good book and hoping that's enough. It's really not.

Of course not. In an ideal world, we could get the complete score of every episode. But with only a limited running time, there has to be a tradeoff -- either get some complete scores and miss out on a lot more, or get a broader selection of incomplete scores. And there are benefits and drawbacks to both tradeoffs, which of course is why they call them tradeoffs. And that's why I'm suggesting a mixed approach.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top