• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Ashes to Ashes Series 3 (may contain Spoilers)

I don't remember the US version all that much, but I thought the ending was fairly definitive wasn't it? I guess they could spin it off from that event, but then again, they probably weren't planning any kind of spinoff by the time Ashes to Ashes aired.
 
I don't remember the US version all that much, but I thought the ending was fairly definitive wasn't it?

Read my spoilercode. I mentioned details which suggest, to me, that the ending was NOT definitive - i.e. it was just another one of Sam's coma dreams.
 
Yeah, I did. Then again, I just wonder how long they had until they had to throw together the ending that they eventually used. I can't imagine that's how they wanted the show to go out if they had more time to run with it anyway.
 
Utterly fantastic. Definitely cemented LoM\A2A as one of my favourite shows of all time. The end was heartbreaking for Alex, but the final scene was the perfect note to end on.

Oh, and can we have a moment of silence for the Quattro? :(
 
So sad that Alex died and Hunt does not get to go to heaven.:(

Hunt could've gone but he chose not to. He chose to be something better than that. He chose to be a guardian to all the coppers who die unfairly before their time and to keep Keats at bay forever.

What I want to know is, did Alex actually wake up in the real world at the end of season 2? And if she did, then how did she fall back into a coma and die at the start of season 3?
 
If they really planned the series before hand, the 9:04 (9:06?) reference would have been there at the end of season 2, in which case she never woke up.

Then again, if Sam did wake up at the end of LoM to meet up with his mother and give his psych report before committing suicide, there's no reason why Alex didn't either.
 
She didn't wake up at the end of series 2, they confirmed that in the documentary on the s2 DVDs. "Coma in a coma." is how they described it.
 
I absolutely loved the ending. I felt cheated at the end of Life on Mars but this brought closure to both series. It's funny that the end of LoM made it look like Gene and the others where all in Sam's head where the end to this series firmly states that they're all real.

Charlie
 
LoM was a great ending but so was this though it never answered the question it of course never could...Why or how did Gene's death create this world.

Very nice wrap up and what a line...

I am arresting you for murdering my car you Dyke digging tosspot :lol:
 
What a fantastic ending! So sad about the Quattro.

LoM was a great ending but so was this though it never answered the question it of course never could...Why or how did Gene's death create this world.

My interpretation is that Gene had went with Keats (the devil) when he died, who created the world Gene wanted, and is now trapped there, forever.
 
I didn't even think of that as a possibility but it's a great one. I kind of viewed it as a more Peter Pan sort of thing. Gene and his lost coppers, they'll eventually wanna move on but Gene never can.
 
No idea how Gene created the world that he did, but he can't leave. He keeps himself there by obligation. His mind created the world and I assume that should he ever leave it, it would cease to be.

I thought that it was a marvellous hour of television. I must admit, my instant reaction afterwards was a little underwhelming, largely because I'd been spoiled earlier in the day. However, once over that, and the obvious disappointment of no John Simm/Sam, I think it's a superb finale.

The videotape viewings came sooner than I thought, as did the reveal about Gene, I thought that it was going to be a frantic race to Lancashire between Drake and Gene throughout most of the episode.

The final moments were glorious. Admittedly I wasn't mad keen on Keeley Hawes to begin with, but over the last two years she's absolutely nailed the role of Drake. Her ultimate fate was gut-wrenching, but utterly the right way to go. The kind of series that LoM and A2A have been, it had to end bittersweet. To finish in any other way would have been wrong IMO.

Reading an interview with Matt Graham earlier, apparently they did consider bringing John Simm back, and he'd have been there at the RA at the end, doing what Nelson eventually did, welcoming them. They went against that because they thought that it would steel Keeley Hawes' thunder somewhat. Shame really as I think it would have worked quite well if it had been he that revealed that Alex was dead.

I'm just very relieved that the final episode lived up to the series that had gone before it. Seen it more than a few times where a great series has had a poor finale. Thankfully, this was the perfect send-off for the Gene Genie.

So long Guv, you'll be misssed.
 
I didn't want to see Sam again so I'm glad they didn't use him. He's happy in the afterlife and that's good enough for me.
 
I didn't want to see Sam again so I'm glad they didn't use him. He's happy in the afterlife and that's good enough for me.

In terms of the story you're right.

Given that this really tied up both series, Sam appearing would have been a nice touch. Unnecessary as you say, but as a viewer I'd have liked that.

At the end of the day though, his absence didn't make a great deal of difference, it just turned a 10/10 into a 9.9/10. :)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top