^Thank you.
Christopher has pretty much made a mountain out of a mole hill in his replies.
Wow. Christopher doesn't need anyone to defend him, but I'm going to anyway. I read his responses as clearly saying (well before he outright said it) that he felt unable to comment on the editorial situation. How the heck is that making a mountain out of a molehill? A straight answer would have violated his integrity (either through a lie, or through giving away information that he was not authorized to give). So he did the next best thing - didn't give any answer, and made it clear he couldn't. So Allyn pushed Christopher. And round and round we go.
If you think that Christopher built any mountains, you may want to re-read this thread, and check your assumptions.
What would have been your answer to "Is Tom Selleck the editor of your book?"![]()
He just got replaced by Harrison Ford?
Whether this counts as "winning" or "losing" is left as an exercise for the reader.The editors are selected by lottery on a day to day basis.
The Journalist and Trek fan in me is saying that we have a "right" to know who is editing the Trek line,
The Journalist and Trek fan in me is saying that we have a "right" to know who is editing the Trek line,
No you don't. It's a private company making TV show tie-in novels; it's not a government agency or public office. Who is or is not editing Star Trek books is none of our business if Pocket doesn't want it to be our business.
That isn't a necessity. Off the top of my head, "Primary Colors" and the "Castle" novels were published anonymously, which is obviously much more palatable than if, say, the Mayor of New York was anonymous, something more within the purview of the people's right to know.
So... who wants cake?
Ooh, I want cake!
The Journalist and Trek fan in me is saying that we have a "right" to know who is editing the Trek line,
No you don't. It's a private company making TV show tie-in novels; it's not a government agency or public office. Who is or is not editing Star Trek books is none of our business if Pocket doesn't want it to be our business.
Oh lol. I guess we should also send "Thank You" notes to Pocket because they kindly let us know who wrote the book.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.