• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Andor - Season 2

Was rewatching some DS9 and I think Gilroy maybe stumbled just a tiny bit at the end by letting Perrin live. Damar's wife and kid were executed by the Dominion immediately after he defected. If Emperor Palpatine of all people comes across as nicer than the Founders of the Dominion, then someone's writing him wrong.
I am not at all shocked the Empire didn't see the point in killing a divorced woman's ex-husband. As for the daughter, hasn't it been speculated the family she married into has enough influence to protect her? For that matter, given Perrin is getting cozy with Leida's mother-in-law, it's not that much of a stretch their influence also protected him. So no, by sparing Mon Mothma's family, Palpatine isn't being nicer than the Dominion, just being more politically conscious.
 
Palpatine needed the bureaucracy and the Senate to help keep member worlds of the Empire from exploding in revolt against Imperial repression and didn't get rid of either until just after the events of Andor and Rogue One. Palpatine was Machiavellian and practical, so he - at least on the surface - tolerated less-agreeable Senators for 19 years while he readied the Death Star for final operational status and could then tell the old bureaucrats and the now-rubber stamp legislature to get lost.
 
The only issue never resolved was who Cassian's sister is/was. The too-obvious choice would be Kleya, and I also read somewhere in this thread the suggestion that it was Dedra. Hey, maybe it's Jyn Erso, which would keep alive the Star Wars tradition of retconned sibling makeouts....
It kind of was resolved, in their last conversation his mother told him that she was dead and he should stop trying find it.
It couldn't be Jyn since I believe we "saw" her mother give birth to her in Catalyst. I know they have been contradicting some books and comics, but they seem to be more or less canon until they'rer contradicted, and I can't really see any reason a future production to contradict that since the whole Erso family's story is done at this point.
 
I am not at all shocked the Empire didn't see the point in killing a divorced woman's ex-husband. As for the daughter, hasn't it been speculated the family she married into has enough influence to protect her? For that matter, given Perrin is getting cozy with Leida's mother-in-law, it's not that much of a stretch their influence also protected him. So no, by sparing Mon Mothma's family, Palpatine isn't being nicer than the Dominion, just being more politically conscious.
I'd go so far as to say they would be kept alive and "free" so that they could be watched *very closely* in case Mon ever attempts to make contact. Leida especially, since the ISB are well aware that there's little love lost between husband and wife. They're much more valuable as bait than as examples as to the perils of disloyalty. They're still going to basically be hostages though. A gilded cage is still a cage.

All that said, Mon mentions in 'Rebels' how Chandrilla is suffering comparably to Lothal, so it seems there were indeed severe ramifications for the whole planet, if not for her immediate family. Indeed, that may be part of the plan too; drive a wedge between Mon and her own people by making them suffer while her family is left in peace.
 
I'm guessing Gilroy wasn't even aware of this line and LFL may have forgotten about it entirely. Leida's and Perrin's fate should've been brought in line with this Rebels dialogue
Why would it matter if Gilroy was made aware of it or not? The show never went back to Chandrilla after the wedding, so what happened there between the last two arcs wasn't massively relevant. As for Lucasfilm "forgetting" about a significant continuity detail on a Filloni show; yeaaaah no. Pablo was the main canon advisor for Gilroy when writing Andor, and he was very much involved in both 'Rebels' and 'Rogue One', so he'd be acutely aware and would have brought it up if it was important. The only time when they might have been the case was the point where they thought about having Mon go back there before fleeing for a final conversation with her daughter. But that never ended up happening, so it's neither here not there.
 
Last edited:
I just don't see Palpatine letting Leida and Perrin off easy. If anything by ROTJ he'd have "leaked" that Leida was being held at Death Star 2 so that if Mon wants to blow up another Death Star, she'd have to kill her own daughter to do it.
 
I'm guessing Gilroy wasn't even aware of this line and LFL may have forgotten about it entirely. Leida's and Perrin's fate should've been brought in line with this Rebels dialogue
We certainly know that the show was aware of Rebels generally, given the somewhat awkward ending of s2e9...
 
503268189-1650906168957795-6873697714139378775-n.jpg
 
I just don't see Palpatine letting Leida and Perrin off easy. If anything by ROTJ he'd have "leaked" that Leida was being held at Death Star 2 so that if Mon wants to blow up another Death Star, she'd have to kill her own daughter to do it.
Like I said, they're most likely not being "let off". They're bait on a hook. And who knows, maybe after the Battle of Yavin, they were both dragged out into the street and incinerated for all to see. We have no idea what their ultimate fates are yet.
Honestly, I think it'd be weird for Saw to have a holocomm with anyone that didn't deteriorate into an argument inside of 3 seconds. This is the kind of guy that would argue with trees if he thought they were judging him.
 
Last edited:
Just repeating myself, but I can still see an option whereby Palpatine uses Perrin as a propaganda weapon, trotting him out to bad mouth Mon on TV.
Yeah that might backfire because the galaxy will probably burst into laughter the moment Perrin starts regurgitating the speech the ISB gives him to read. Honestly Palpatine would get better traction trotting out recovering spice addicts and Hutt cartel victims and denouncing Mon as a hypocrite for working with spice smuggler Han Solo.
 
Yeah that might backfire because the galaxy will probably burst into laughter the moment Perrin starts regurgitating the speech the ISB gives him to read. Honestly Palpatine would get better traction trotting out recovering spice addicts and Hutt cartel victims and denouncing Mon as a hypocrite for working with spice smuggler Han Solo.
Palps doesn't care about that stuff. The galaxy can laugh until the moment the Death Star enters orbit.
 
The Emperor just let Tarkin run roughshod over Lord Vader and push around a Sith Lord so that the Death Star would be operational at the right moment. Palpatine allowed underlings to be a pain in the ass so long as the greater goal was being serviced and the Emperor's hold on absolute power was preserved.
 
Tony Gilroy mentioned a sequence that didn't make it into episode 9 in which Perin reveals that he knew what Mon was up to all the time and that he had been regularly taken in for questioning and that he had been covering for her all along.
 
Palpatine needed the bureaucracy and the Senate to help keep member worlds of the Empire from exploding in revolt against Imperial repression and didn't get rid of either until just after the events of Andor and Rogue One. Palpatine was Machiavellian and practical, so he - at least on the surface - tolerated less-agreeable Senators for 19 years while he readied the Death Star for final operational status and could then tell the old bureaucrats and the now-rubber stamp legislature to get lost.

Also we see how obviously cult like the vocal supporters of the Galactic Empire are on the floor of the Galactic Senate (and it carries over into the problems of the Sequel era and explains why the First Order felt very much like a military cult, plus the stadium full of robed Sith cultists in the 3rd movie).
 
When most of the chamber is filled with Senators who lap up everything you tell the galaxy then why dissolve a bureaucracy that helps you run things more smoothly, at least not until the last possible minute? The Emperor needed to maintain the illusion of a representative legislature, anyways, so that there'd be fewer catcalls that the system was basically a one-man tyranny.
 
When most of the chamber is filled with Senators who lap up everything you tell the galaxy then why dissolve a bureaucracy that helps you run things more smoothly, at least not until the last possible minute? The Emperor needed to maintain the illusion of a representative legislature, anyways, so that there'd be fewer catcalls that the system was basically a one-man tyranny.
:shifty:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top