It's my second favorite, too (though my first is TWoK). STiD is a splendid success in virtually every particular, and a pure joy to watch. It makes me sad that fandom's Internet groupthink cynically chose to dogpile it and declare it the worst thing ever, when they should have been alternately dancing in the streets and prostrating themselves in gratitude.It is my second favorite Star Trek movie behind TMP. There was a lot to build a sequel off of, and Paramount got cold feet over a hundred fans voting it the worst Trek movie. Per usual, Paramount is its own worst enemy when it comes to Star Trek.