• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Search results for query: * (refine your search)

  1. Watersluis

    The Dominion versus the Borg

    The power levels of neither have been portrayed consistently, nor has that of the Defiant. Such is typically the case with such matters, such as the ancient quæstion whether Superman would beat Gokuu in a fight or not.
  2. Watersluis

    Did the Prophets intend for the Bajoran Occupation to occur?

    I do not. I don't care about providing ad hoc definitions for “vague words”. I simply do not utilize them to make my arguments. A word is only useful in it's usage if I can with confidence assume the person with whom I speak has the same conception of it as I. Such as, in this case, I simply...
  3. Watersluis

    Did the Prophets intend for the Bajoran Occupation to occur?

    The prrophets were never said by their religion to be omnipotent. The word “god” clearly prædates it's usage to describe the supposedly omnipotent Abrahamic god and has been used for the gods of many religions which were never said to be omnipotent. Ascribing omnipotence to gods is mostly...
  4. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    Apparently in this case means that it was something that was mentioned at one point but did not make a particular impact. I can't say it made as much of an impact on me as it did on others amidst the sea of other “North American English accents” on characters that should not be having them...
  5. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    Yes, that is the impression I gained but I wasn't too sure. It being for a U.S.A. audiences these references are of course more subtle than what a European can easily determine. Certainly the first artificial satellite and human in space are monumentous achievements in space exploration worthy...
  6. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    Ah, now I see why they didn't do it. Apparently some people are offended at the display of Soviet achievements. Notwithstanding the many issues with humans experimenting on nonhuman animals for their own gain, let us be honest that is not an issue bound to only one side of the iron curtain, and...
  7. Watersluis

    Worf and Kira and Captain Sisko's executive officer

    Looking it up, Starship Down was indeed further back than I remember it, but also already included Worf. I'm no sure what set up Worf and J. Dax to a similar extend as that episode did the latter with Bashir.
  8. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    I'm sure they could could have cut the arbitrary submarine for something as momentous as the first man in space. Perhaps he was conceived as such, but he was apparently from the U.S.A., not that I could tell the difference, of course, for as with Uhura, and Kirk their ethnicity could not really...
  9. Watersluis

    Worf and Kira and Captain Sisko's executive officer

    Well yes, because both of these couples were forced and out of nowhere. Kira had known of Odo's feelings for a long time, but suddenly now awakens to a mutual love after a poor date and that very strange argument? Dax was also clearly set up to be with Bashir and did not seem like Worf's type...
  10. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    You and I both know the number is two, both having about three times the population of the U.S.A., neither having a single cast member in T.O.S..
  11. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    In this case, time is a particularly poor excuse. The post you quoted pointed out that T.O.S. was actually one of the least offenders and all that came after it was even more America-centric, much of which produced after Pacific Rim. I do not particularly swallow this when quite a bit of...
  12. Watersluis

    Should Sisko had stepped in clash between Winn & Keiko

    The same can be said of the interpretions of diplomats in contact with any foreign nation who relay what they've seen at home.
  13. Watersluis

    Is Scotty's accent actually bad?

    Yes, there are many countries more populous than the U.S.A. Consider how something such as Pacific Rim did it, for a far better effect. Of course, it wasn't simply the issue that too many of the characters were nominally from the U.S.A., but that even those that weren't spoke with...
  14. Watersluis

    Should Sisko had stepped in clash between Winn & Keiko

    The topic of the prophets shows well how people react to arbitrarily calling something a “religion”, and how easily they are influenced by a different choice of words for the same thing. Unlike most religions, these “gods” are an accepted existence and simply an alien form of life, but the...
  15. Watersluis

    Was Dukat really evil?

    Ahh, yes, the man who fought long and hard to keep his slaves and fashioned his own false teeth from teeth pulled from them. I say hi back to him. George Washington was in no way a man who rose for the plight of the little man. He was a wealthy slave owner who sent men to their death to fight a...
  16. Watersluis

    Was Dukat really evil?

    I disagree. Even outside of such times, why did almost all revolutionaries eventually become dictators? Lenin, Castro, Robespierre, even Gandhi all started with what originally seemed noble intentions but soon revealed their autocratic and dogmatic nature. For a man to pick up the sword against...
  17. Watersluis

    What are some of the best cutdowns of DS9?

    I actually dislike that they later revealed that Odo was not as high and mighty as he claimed. I rather liked his original character as being self-righteous, dogmatic, and holding his own personal subjective views on his so-called “justice” as fact and believing it innate to his species, but...
  18. Watersluis

    Eddington's vitriolic assessment of The Federation

    I said so at the start that I found it unlikely that a man would pack up from Copenhagen to live in the middle of the Sahara, yes. The examples you gave are very much not comparable to that. — I believe it unlikely, because it simply does not happen. While it is true that in the case of the...
  19. Watersluis

    Eddington's vitriolic assessment of The Federation

    Which still does not compare to people going somewhere where not even a grocery story exists, to build one themselves.
  20. Watersluis

    Q, the Borg, and DS9

    The Borg would surely be even more inconsistently portrayed. We have always been assimilating organic life.
Back
Top