• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Del Toro OUT of Trek film

Trekmovie.com said:
It was just last Friday when JJ Abrams denied a report that Del Toro would be playing the role of Khan Noonien Singh, telling HitFix that report was "not true." With news that Del Toro is no longer in the running, Abrams denial could be read a different way. And in fact, Vulture is reporting from "a highly placed source" that Khan is indeed the villain in the Star Trek sequel. These reports have still not been confirmed and so should still be considered rumor.
My guess is that Khan will be the mentor of Kirk's Klingon rival, puppeting the Klingon Empire from the shadows, having been found and thawed by the Klingons a while after the Kelvin was destroyed.
 
A second remake of Khan is all they can come up with? That's it? If this movie is a Khan remake, it could come out in 2016 for all I care. I won't be seeing it.:barf:
 
it.
won't.
be.
khan!

I'll betting my two firstborns and their mother that Khan will not appear in this movie!
 
A second remake of Khan is all they can come up with? That's it? If this movie is a Khan remake, it could come out in 2016 for all I care. I won't be seeing it.:barf:

While I wouldn't go that far, I will say I will be very disappointed in the writers if it ends up being Khan, whether Space Seed or Wrath of, doesn't matter. Next we'll hear Trek 13 will feature Trelane, 14 will feature the Tribbles, and the rest of the films will feature Harry Mudd.

New villains, people - not rehashes.

Having said all that, if they do cast a new Khan whoever the pick should be a powerful, preferably Hispanic actor (the character isn't Hispanic, of course, but Montalban made such a mark that having, say, a Brit play the role just wouldn't feel right). Edward James Olmos actually comes immediately to mind, especially if this ends up being an older Khan. Banderas is too much a light-character actor - I like him a lot but I'd have trouble accepting the guy from Spy Kids and Puss n Boots as Khan. Bardem is still a possibility if the Bond film is wrapped in time.

Of course if everything I just said about the character being Hispanic is thrown out and the doors are open wide, then one name comes to mind: Ian McShane! ;) But ONLY if he plays Khan in full Al Swearingen mode, of course!

Alex
 
I'd be open to another Khan movie if they could come up with a REALLY cool, alternative take on the idea.... but that would be such a huge challenge I'm not sure even Nicholas Meyer could do it.
 
While I wouldn't go that far, I will say I will be very disappointed in the writers if it ends up being Khan, whether Space Seed or Wrath of, doesn't matter. Next we'll hear Trek 13 will feature Trelane, 14 will feature the Tribbles, and the rest of the films will feature Harry Mudd.

New villains, people - not rehashes.

Having said all that, if they do cast a new Khan whoever the pick should be a powerful, preferably Hispanic actor (the character isn't Hispanic, of course, but Montalban made such a mark that having, say, a Brit play the role just wouldn't feel right). Edward James Olmos actually comes immediately to mind, especially if this ends up being an older Khan. Banderas is too much a light-character actor - I like him a lot but I'd have trouble accepting the guy from Spy Kids and Puss n Boots as Khan. Bardem is still a possibility if the Bond film is wrapped in time.

Of course if everything I just said about the character being Hispanic is thrown out and the doors are open wide, then one name comes to mind: Ian McShane! ;) But ONLY if he plays Khan in full Al Swearingen mode, of course!

Alex

I don't get this whole Hispanic actor thing people have going on just because Montalban was Hispanic. . . Why not a really hot, award-winning Indian actor from bollywood? Especially given that Paramount wants overseas box office numbers. . . A billion plus Indians and South Asians. . . who happen to spend more money on movies than Americans. . . yeah, Paramount would be smart to tap that. . . and considering that Khan is Sikh, it would make much more sense than casting a Hispanic in the role. . . this is not the 1960s. . .we can do better than painting Puerto Ricans actors brown for Klingons and casting Hispanics as Indians. . .


~FS
 
While I wouldn't go that far, I will say I will be very disappointed in the writers if it ends up being Khan, whether Space Seed or Wrath of, doesn't matter. Next we'll hear Trek 13 will feature Trelane, 14 will feature the Tribbles, and the rest of the films will feature Harry Mudd.

New villains, people - not rehashes.

Having said all that, if they do cast a new Khan whoever the pick should be a powerful, preferably Hispanic actor (the character isn't Hispanic, of course, but Montalban made such a mark that having, say, a Brit play the role just wouldn't feel right). Edward James Olmos actually comes immediately to mind, especially if this ends up being an older Khan. Banderas is too much a light-character actor - I like him a lot but I'd have trouble accepting the guy from Spy Kids and Puss n Boots as Khan. Bardem is still a possibility if the Bond film is wrapped in time.

Of course if everything I just said about the character being Hispanic is thrown out and the doors are open wide, then one name comes to mind: Ian McShane! ;) But ONLY if he plays Khan in full Al Swearingen mode, of course!

Alex

I don't get this whole Hispanic actor thing people have going on just because Montalban was Hispanic. . . Why not a really hot, award-winning Indian actor from bollywood? Especially given that Paramount wants overseas box office numbers. . . A billion plus Indians and South Asians. . . who happen to spend more money on movies than Americans. . . yeah, Paramount would be smart to tap that. . . and considering that Khan is Sikh, it would make much more sense than casting a Hispanic in the role. . . this is not the 1960s. . .we can do better than painting Puerto Ricans actors brown for Klingons and casting Hispanics as Indians. . .


~FS
So...are you suggesting Shah Rukh Khan for Khan?
 
My guess is that Khan will be the mentor of Kirk's Klingon rival, puppeting the Klingon Empire from the shadows, having been found and thawed by the Klingons a while after the Kelvin was destroyed.

Not a bad idea really. It could reference the ENT Klingon augment arc somehow....<hides from the ENT haters>
 
I don't get this whole Hispanic actor thing people have going on just because Montalban was Hispanic. . . Why not a really hot, award-winning Indian actor from bollywood? Especially given that Paramount wants overseas box office numbers. . . A billion plus Indians and South Asians. . . who happen to spend more money on movies than Americans. . . yeah, Paramount would be smart to tap that. . . and considering that Khan is Sikh, it would make much more sense than casting a Hispanic in the role. . . this is not the 1960s. . .we can do better than painting Puerto Ricans actors brown for Klingons and casting Hispanics as Indians. . .


~FS
So...are you suggesting Shah Rukh Khan for Khan?

Shah Rukh Khan would definitely bring in the box office. . . but for someone who looks genetically engineered Hrithik Roshan would work. . . Arjun Rampal isn't bad at all. . . an older Khan: Kabir Bedi. . . there are so many ways to go, that casting a Hispanic in the role just seems dated and wrong. . . especially in a global market. . .

~FS
 
I don't get this whole Hispanic actor thing people have going on just because Montalban was Hispanic. . . Why not a really hot, award-winning Indian actor from bollywood? Especially given that Paramount wants overseas box office numbers. . . A billion plus Indians and South Asians. . . who happen to spend more money on movies than Americans. . . yeah, Paramount would be smart to tap that. . . and considering that Khan is Sikh, it would make much more sense than casting a Hispanic in the role. . . this is not the 1960s. . .we can do better than painting Puerto Ricans actors brown for Klingons and casting Hispanics as Indians. . .

If Khan is the only idea they have for a sequel, Boneheaded Thinking is already in full effect; casting a Hispanic is just par for the course at that point. Sure, Khan is Sikh, but the all-important ignorant popcorn-smacking Joe Average Moviegoer doesn't know that. And everything has to be all about that person.
 
A second remake of Khan is all they can come up with? That's it? If this movie is a Khan remake, it could come out in 2016 for all I care. I won't be seeing it.:barf:
I've always thought the Wrath of Khan was more a remake of "Balance of Terror" than "Space Seed".
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top