Finished : A Feast for Crows (finally.....took forever....... review below)
Reading : Well into 11/22/63 already..
A Feast for Crows - 3/5 stars
So, having read the reviews before reading the book, I had a somewhat tempered expectation of how good the book was and as such, I wasn't as put out by some who thought it was 1 or 2 star material or was upset that it didn't contain certain popular perspectives in the story. Still, I agree that A Feast for Crows is probably the weakest entry in the series up to this point, mostly due to the lack of any chapters dedicated to the series three most popular characters for most people. While we do get chapters about characters that most enjoy and are central to the main narrative like Jamie, Brienne, Samwell, Arya, Sansa and even Ceresei, there are what feel like to me, lots of filler chapters where half the time I didn't know who the characters even were or in some cases, knew and just didn't care. Finally, the first half of the book really struggles to find it's voice and all these things combined end up making this a more challenging read than the first three and not as enjoyable overall. In the end, the only "filler" chapters I ended up being interested in at all was the Greyjoy/Iron Island story line though I certainly don't think it is integral to tell the main story.
Still, it needs to be pointed out that it's a bound to be a bit more difficult to judge the book on it's own because until books 5, 6 & 7 come out to complete the tale, it's unclear how well this chapter fits within the whole narrative. The story picks up directly after the events of Storm of Swords and really does little to change the game except towards the very end for two pivotal players and depending on how the story continues, possibly a couple other minor players. While this review probably does appear pretty negative to this point, I will say that the book really starts to pull things together around the halfway point and by the time you're 3/4 of the way through the book, it really begins to hit all it's marks quite nicely and finishes strongly. It's a shame it took so long to get the ball rolling because once it did, it felt like he was really starting to hit is grove and then the story had to end.
So, all in all, I'd say the book was well written fantasy/drama (still pretty light on the fantasy for the most part), but suffers from too many "filler" chapters of characters that most of us don't care about and that don't appear to be all that important to the main story except that he's taken the time to make them part of it. Still, since this is the middle of a much longer story it's a little difficult to judge it on it's own since it requires both the books that precede and that will follow it in order to appreciate in context.