Eyes, you might be the perfect person to ask this. I listened to this song last night and liked it alot, but am I the only one who finds it a bit odd that this is a Canadian band that named itself after a Scottish dish, that plays Irish-inspired music?
With a name like that, I thought sure this band must be from Scotland...but the music sounded Irish and so I had to look them up, figuring no Scottish band would be so much about Irish music. I mean, I don't know THAT much about the politics of your country...but I have always been under the impression that the Irish are very proud of their history/traditions (including music) and the Scottish feel the same about theirs. So it just seemed a bit 'off' to me.
However, when I looked them up on Wikipedia, I was surprised to learn that they are from frakkin' CANADA!![]()
Well, I didn't look them up, but I was surprised to find that they were singing Irish stuff, with a Scottish name.
However, despite the name, I didn't get a Scottish vibe off of them. You are somewhat correct, it would be very unusual to find a Scot singing Irish folk music. I thought that they were American (or Canadian, as it seems), as they didn't sound like they were from the British Isles.
You can tell, I think, most of the time. Most British artists have a distinct sound that gives away their nationality. It's the ones that have a more generic sound that make it big in America, most of the time. Lowest common denominator and all, most Americans don't realise that they aren't American, and they're successful. Talking pop and RnB mainly here,the likes of Taio Cruz and Jay Sean, as that's the dominant genre in the charts today, but it still applies to rock artists.
One of my favourite rock bands, Biffy Clyro, are Scottish, and you can tell so much that they are Scottish when they sing. I didn't get this vibe from Enter the Haggis.
I assumed they were from New York or around that area (there are a lot of Irish people there, I think, or is that just Fairytale of New York playing at me again?), and some of the band might have Scottish ancestry. That's without looking them up.
Taylor Swift - White Horse
Yeah, I'm not sure that I can really talk about any particular song of Taylor Swift's without talking about her in general. I go back and forth on how I feel about her stuff. On the one hand, she's pretty and seems really nice and her music's pleasant enough. And I gotta give her credit for (by all accounts) writing her own stuff. On the other hand, her twangy-pop sound is decried by some people as part of the "death of country" - and I can kinda see where they're coming from, although Nashville's been trending that way for years anyway. Her songs are fairly interchangable and the fact that she's authentic doesn't do much when she's clearly a girl from suburbia who's not been through very much. Let her go through some bad relationships, or struggle with the negative side of fame, or go through a substance addiction, etc. and then we'll see. But maybe I'm being overly harsh. I've never heard her live (she's supposedly not a very good singer) but her stuff's nice to listen to for the most part. "White Horse" doesn't really stand out as particularly noteworthy in either a good or bad way - it's sad, but not raw, more of a melancholy-starting-to-grow-up-disillusioned song. Call it a 6/10 - I'll defend her music for those who enjoy it and I'll even enjoy it most of the time, but won't often seek it out.
Katy Perry - Hot and Cold
Haha, oh Katy Perry. Is anybody here familiar with the reviewer Todd in the Shadows who currently does pop song reviews for That Guy With the Glasses? My thoughts on Katy Perry are very similar to his - her music is the epitome of vapidness and it's really not very good. On the other hand and at the same time - much of her music is just infectious fun and I don't want to turn it off. "Hot and Cold" is probably one of her better songs (although I like her newest, "ET," minus the rap guest lyric, though in a "that's really creepy and fucked up but brilliantly so" way) - it's a big stupid pop song that revels in itself. And you know what? I like it. Katy can't sing and she's autotuned to hell, but this song is rather infectious. 7/10 for a "what the hell, why not," and I'm quite familiar with her work since I listen to pop music.
Kelly Clarkson - Sober
The video's from Smallville; I'm not familiar with that part of the series, is this actually played over the show and specifically recorded? Anyway, Kelly Clarkson tends to kinda fade into the background for me. She's got a pleasant enough voice, and the instruments are fine for this song, but it doesn't leave much of an impression on me. It's enjoyable enough for a 6/10 anyway.
My three:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ht5RZpzPqw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDZCWUUu28g&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJvPjelxxj0&feature=related (shamelessly stolen from another thread!)
My picks:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtaozH9PsNo&feature=fvst
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SNtUuu2AtQ
(this is one of the bands I have made CD purchases of)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hy17DWrjNT0
It's DREADLOCKS NIGHT!!!!!
^ That first one has gotta be a side project for the guy from CAKE. It's like 'CAKE: The Reggae Years' or something. Not that that's a bad thing, mind you.![]()
My three:
Sadly, no... seems to be the only good quality version on YouTube. Here's another song by the same artist... different tone, but equally good song: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20aPuDPmVKE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMNfB7MWRIY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izwa9HL7nWc
^
Excellent choices!
Yeah, Candlebox is one of those post-grunge bands...much like Bush who is one of my favs.
Shinedown is one of those bands that slip into the alt-metal/nu-metal category depending on the song.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.