I know this sounds common but I would like to know who would win if the two universes got into a fight. I am completely new here so don't say that there is already a thead like this I would like to know who would win in the fight. Especaily Borg vs Replicators that should be interesting.
Who would win in a fight? Stargate vs Star trek?
- Thread starter TheThreadkiller
- Start date
Batman would kick both their asses, provided he had time to prepare.
Yeah, nothing stops a P-90, and a red shirt doesn't protect a person from anything.
I am talking like ship vs ship battles. Not those on the ground. I also don't want people to say chuck norris would win.
It would come down to who is more powerful, the Ascended Ancients or beings like Q.
As for ship to ship battles it is impossible to tell as we have no idea how either side's weapons would go against the shields of the other.
Stargate does have FTL drives that allow for intergalactic travel in a couple of days (though the Asgard seemed to do it in seconds), which I don't think we've seen in Trek. The only intergalactic ships I can remember hearing about were Kelvan and I think they were generational vessels.
As for ship to ship battles it is impossible to tell as we have no idea how either side's weapons would go against the shields of the other.
Stargate does have FTL drives that allow for intergalactic travel in a couple of days (though the Asgard seemed to do it in seconds), which I don't think we've seen in Trek. The only intergalactic ships I can remember hearing about were Kelvan and I think they were generational vessels.
In a ground fight, the battle would be decided when one side or the other figured out that their personal weapons fired at line-of-sight mode were not the best way to proceed. Both SG1 and Trek suffer from misuse of the existing equipment... The former could throw a few hand grenades, set up mines or heavy machine guns in advance, or bring heavy indirect-fire weaponry through the Gate; they have done all of this at least once, but for some reason forget to do it again when needed. The latter could in turn use phasers on a geography-altering mode, removing all the protection from around our SG1 heroes at the push of a trigger button while digging impenetrable fortresses for their own use.
A space fight would be decided on technobabble. The weapons of SG1 Earth are probably much weaker than their Trek equivalents, and SG1 has fewer ships, but SG1 ships can reach the battlefields faster than their Trek equivalents, and they can carry powerful alien weaponry while Trek ships basically never do.
A fistfight would of course go to the Trek team, as all the SG side has to offer is Teal'c who is helpless without a staff weapon. Most Trek teams feature experienced pugilists who make up for lack of finesse with sheer stubbornness and punching power. OTOH, none of them carry knives, so any fight that starts out as a fistfight would end with the bleeding corpses of the Trek side being dragged out the back door...
At chess, O'Neill would defeat McCoy in 87 moves, with actual chess experts on both sides gasping in awe at the inspired and unconventional game. Although in the meantime, Kirk would use the diversion to secure triumph for his side in the greater fight.
Timo Saloniemi
A space fight would be decided on technobabble. The weapons of SG1 Earth are probably much weaker than their Trek equivalents, and SG1 has fewer ships, but SG1 ships can reach the battlefields faster than their Trek equivalents, and they can carry powerful alien weaponry while Trek ships basically never do.
A fistfight would of course go to the Trek team, as all the SG side has to offer is Teal'c who is helpless without a staff weapon. Most Trek teams feature experienced pugilists who make up for lack of finesse with sheer stubbornness and punching power. OTOH, none of them carry knives, so any fight that starts out as a fistfight would end with the bleeding corpses of the Trek side being dragged out the back door...
At chess, O'Neill would defeat McCoy in 87 moves, with actual chess experts on both sides gasping in awe at the inspired and unconventional game. Although in the meantime, Kirk would use the diversion to secure triumph for his side in the greater fight.
Timo Saloniemi
Worf?
Given that they're the good guys, why would they be fighting?
I know, I know, excitement and all that...but I'd find a team-up more exciting. Or Wraith fighting Klingons. Or the Borg fighting the Replicators.
Or the Ancients, Prophets, and Q teaming up to battle the Ori, the Pah-Wraiths, and the M Continuum.
I know, I know, excitement and all that...but I'd find a team-up more exciting. Or Wraith fighting Klingons. Or the Borg fighting the Replicators.
Or the Ancients, Prophets, and Q teaming up to battle the Ori, the Pah-Wraiths, and the M Continuum.
I was thinking who would win in a fight Goauld vs starfleet in the 22nd century? I picked this era becasue that is the closessed time to the stargate time frame.
Hmm, good one. A Ha'tak is remarkably easy to destroy, a puddle jumper took one out in two shots. But then, 22nd century Starfleet can only go warp 5, and I'm pretty sure hyperdrive is much faster than that.
...Ah, yes. But only beginning with DS9; in TNG, he didn't carry any swords or knives on away missions.
Although at least Peter David in his novels believed Klingons always carried comical amounts of concealed weapons (Strike Zone IIRC suggested 15 separate weapons was standard for any self-respecting warrior, and of course Worf had way more).
Timo Saloniemi
In which time period? I saw the first few episodes of Stargate SG-1 and they had naff all equipment besides standard 1990s weaponary. Then I saw some episodes from a later season and they had spaceships, megabombs and all sorts of stuff that let them kick the arses of apparently far more advanced civilisations. I'd imagine that, at this rate of advance, by the 22nd or 23rd century the Stargate people would be able to wipe out Star Trek with a thought. Not that this is necessarily a good thing!
I assumed he usually had at least his mek'leth on him since he also had it on his person in STFC.
It's not like he started out the movie on board the E-E, and I find unlikely that they happened to have a random mek'leth on board.
Heh, well yeah, that's what happens when your 1990s team spends the last few years of the 90s and the bulk of the 2000s bumping heads and shaking hands with a technologically-advanced galaxy. In ten years a lot can change. The show actually does this better than almost anything else; tune into the earliest hours and the latest hours without seeing all the in-between and it will seem damn silly, but watch the whole journey unfold and you'll probably be impressed with how layered the growth is.
Anyway, SG-1 fan moment aside, I echo the sentiments that it would come down to the Q and the Ancients. And I think the Q would win because the Ancients might be extraordinarily mighty but the Q can snap their fingers and do things even the Ori would be hallowed by.
