• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

5x012 The Pandorica Opens (Grading/Discussion) SPOILERS!!

Grade "The Lodger"

  • Who da Man?!

    Votes: 93 73.2%
  • Good

    Votes: 26 20.5%
  • Average

    Votes: 6 4.7%
  • Poor

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • What episode? The crack erased it

    Votes: 2 1.6%

  • Total voters
    127
  • Poll closed .
Much like James Bond isn't the only 00 Agent, JAck Harkness isn't/wasn't the only Time Agent, there were likely quite a few of them.
dont quote me on exact numbers, but according to Captain Joh, there was a down fall of the Time Agency and only a dozen or so survived, himself & Jack being two of them.
 
I'm a little bit worried. River is totally awesome but they've mentioned several times that time can be re-written. I'm hoping that we don't see her sacrifice herself for the Doctor and be erased from time, because that would make the previous episodes featuring her very confusing... and rob us of any chance of seeing their first meeting.

The thing is, as a character she is a gold mine. I was even wondering if their first meeting was also going to be their last (i.e. she learns how to fly the TARDIS, steals his sonic screwdriver and kills him (probably not murder since she really seems to care for him) but he dies somehow, setting us up for the next reincarnation.

Although it looks as though Rory may not be totally gone that reference could have been to set us up for this episode, so who knows...? It's quite nice that it's so hard to predict where this is going.
 
Much like James Bond isn't the only 00 Agent, JAck Harkness isn't/wasn't the only Time Agent, there were likely quite a few of them.
dont quote me on exact numbers, but according to Captain Joh, there was a down fall of the Time Agency and only a dozen or so survived, himself & Jack being two of them.

So my point stands, there are at least a dozen Time Agents out there (always assuming the agency didn't fall after Blue Guy chopped one's arm off!)
 
I am guessing the voice was done by Phillip Madoc, which is what brought the War Lord to mind for me from War Games, Troughton's last series. The War Lord and his people were removed from time. With the Timelords gone, and their limited time travel technology that they got from the Timelord, Magnus, may have let them influence the Tardis. I also thought that brief black and white Tardis image that River saw looked a bit like the symbol that Magnus wore in the episode.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Chief

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Lord
Interesting thought but how do we know Philip Madoc is appearing in "The Big Band?" The only place I've seen him listed is IMDB (which TARDIS Wikia uses as its source) and IMDB isn't the most reliable when it comes to future casts (television and movies alike).
 
I am guessing the voice was done by Phillip Madoc, which is what brought the War Lord to mind for me from War Games, Troughton's last series. The War Lord and his people were removed from time. With the Timelords gone, and their limited time travel technology that they got from the Timelord, Magnus, may have let them influence the Tardis. I also thought that brief black and white Tardis image that River saw looked a bit like the symbol that Magnus wore in the episode.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Chief

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Lord
Interesting thought but how do we know Philip Madoc is appearing in "The Big Band?" The only place I've seen him listed is IMDB (which TARDIS Wikia uses as its source) and IMDB isn't the most reliable when it comes to future casts (television and movies alike).

An valid point, I havent seen anything BBC official about Madoc, but with the amount of callbacks to the 1st and 2nd Doctors in the series, I am hoping its something like this rather than Daleks and Davros again. Also, I thought the Tardis like ship in the Lodger might come into play as we don't know where it came from. It would be amusing if we have already seen the end of the big baddie already in the Lodger. Timey Wimey madness:)
 
I am guessing the voice was done by Phillip Madoc, which is what brought the War Lord to mind for me from War Games, Troughton's last series. The War Lord and his people were removed from time. With the Timelords gone, and their limited time travel technology that they got from the Timelord, Magnus, may have let them influence the Tardis. I also thought that brief black and white Tardis image that River saw looked a bit like the symbol that Magnus wore in the episode.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Chief

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Lord
Interesting thought but how do we know Philip Madoc is appearing in "The Big Band?" The only place I've seen him listed is IMDB (which TARDIS Wikia uses as its source) and IMDB isn't the most reliable when it comes to future casts (television and movies alike).

The Big Band?

So the Doctor's enemy is Glenn Miller? :p
 
I am guessing the voice was done by Phillip Madoc, which is what brought the War Lord to mind for me from War Games, Troughton's last series. The War Lord and his people were removed from time. With the Timelords gone, and their limited time travel technology that they got from the Timelord, Magnus, may have let them influence the Tardis. I also thought that brief black and white Tardis image that River saw looked a bit like the symbol that Magnus wore in the episode.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Chief

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_War_Lord
Interesting thought but how do we know Philip Madoc is appearing in "The Big Band?" The only place I've seen him listed is IMDB (which TARDIS Wikia uses as its source) and IMDB isn't the most reliable when it comes to future casts (television and movies alike).

The Big Band?

So the Doctor's enemy is Glenn Miller? :p

And Amy's mom will be one of the Andrew's sisters who turn out were former companions of Patrick Troughton's Doctor.
 
As I said in another threar it's doubtful it's Jack.

1. Jack's no longer in the 51st Century, so if it is him then he had his hand cut off before the events of The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances and I think we'd have noticed. People will shout timey wimey here but the big blue guy did say it came off the arm of a Time Agent, again Jack hasn't been a Time Agent since before he met the Doctor.

2. Jack's vortex manipulator was pretty much deactivated by the Doctor at the end of Last of the Timelords.

Much like James Bond isn't the only 00 Agent, JAck Harkness isn't/wasn't the only Time Agent, there were likely quite a few of them.

I was about to post pretty much the same thing. Jack left the Time Agency before he met the Doctor and before he became immortal. They could have said "ex-Time Agent" but didn't. I'm sure there are other handsome Time Agents out there.

As for having had the vortex manipulator deactivated, well, he has managed to get it going before but I still doubt it was his.
 
I quite enjoyed the episode, the final scene with all the Doctor's enemies from over the years imprisoning him was done well IMO. There's just one thing I'm not too sure about: What are the Cybus Cybermen from Pete's World doing with the Alliance? I thought they'd all been destroyed, and besides, it's not possible for them to travel into and out of the Doctor's universe due to the Time War. Unless they're actually the original Cybermen, who have somehow evolved into a form virtually identical to that of their other-dimensional counterparts...?
 
I quite enjoyed the episode, the final scene with all the Doctor's enemies from over the years imprisoning him was done well IMO. There's just one thing I'm not too sure about: What are the Cybus Cybermen from Pete's World doing with the Alliance? I thought they'd all been destroyed, and besides, it's not possible for them to travel into and out of the Doctor's universe due to the Time War. Unless they're actually the original Cybermen, who have somehow evolved into a form virtually identical to that of their other-dimensional counterparts...?

They could have been spat out of the void at some point in history (like the ones in The Next Doctor) and proceeded to build themselves in our universe.
 
With the Pete's World Cybermen, it could be anything. A few managed to stay on this side somehow undetected, the cracks allowed them to leave their universe, etc, etc.
 
It was really only now because he had the sudden whim to read the oldest words in the universe. He'd probably heard about them since he was a youth, could've visited at any time in his life and ended up in the Pandorica. For that matter, he's probably heard of the Pandorica as a bedtime story, too. Wonder how much Little Doctor's mind would've been blown when he found out he was going to grow up to be the monster locked inside.
Yeah, for such a tightly constructed season plot, this was a bit sloppy. The Doctor decides to look at the Oldest Words in the Universe (isn't that a bit Hitchhiker's Guide) in the exact same season everyone's been talking to him about the Pandorica and silence falling and he's picked up the companion who's relevant to that plot?

Of course, I suppose you could argue that the reason everyone's been talking to him about the Pandorica and silence falling is because he's about to see the message and get embroiled in the adventure!

I haven't yet heard the throngs comment on how good wizard sound an awful lot like Merlin.
It's because "good wizard" is an incredible vague descriptor. It also sounds an awful lot like Gandalf and Ron Weasley!
 
As I said in another threar it's doubtful it's Jack.

1. Jack's no longer in the 51st Century, so if it is him then he had his hand cut off before the events of The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances and I think we'd have noticed. People will shout timey wimey here but the big blue guy did say it came off the arm of a Time Agent, again Jack hasn't been a Time Agent since before he met the Doctor.

2. Jack's vortex manipulator was pretty much deactivated by the Doctor at the end of Last of the Timelords.

Much like James Bond isn't the only 00 Agent, JAck Harkness isn't/wasn't the only Time Agent, there were likely quite a few of them.
Of course it could have been Jack during his 2 missing years...
 
^ Aha good shout!

I think Jack's TVM was active at the end of COE. Gwen gave to him and he used to hitch-hike, didn't he?
 
I wonder what happened to the original Cybermen then? All we've seen of them since NuWho started is a head in a museum in Dalek. Their absense is a little conspicuous. That's why I suggested that the ones in the Alliance ARE the originals, but a future development of the race, upgraded with tech from those of Pete's World.
 
I wonder what happened to the original Cybermen then? All we've seen of them since NuWho started is a head in a museum in Dalek. Their absense is a little conspicuous. That's why I suggested that the ones in the Alliance ARE the originals, but a future development of the race, upgraded with tech from those of Pete's World.
It's alright, I'm writing a story that will explain everything.
 
^ Aha good shout!

I think Jack's TVM was active at the end of COE. Gwen gave to him and he used to hitch-hike, didn't he?

yea but was probably able to use the device for other things than the TVM, which has done on a number of occasions.
I am sure there were still some more Time agents out there, Captain John said in Torchwood season 2 that there only a few left.
 
I wonder what happened to the original Cybermen then? All we've seen of them since NuWho started is a head in a museum in Dalek. Their absense is a little conspicuous. That's why I suggested that the ones in the Alliance ARE the originals, but a future development of the race, upgraded with tech from those of Pete's World.

Didn't the Doctor say they had gone extinct in Dalek?

I am glad they went back to the Cybermen being a person in a mechanical body instead of just a brain. That's a whole lot creepier.
 
Unfortunately I have one nitpick. How was there a photo of Rory in Amy's bedroom when Rory had been erased from history? I'm hoping there's a reason for this and it isn't just poor plotting from Moffat.


The Doctor said earlier in the episode that being erased occasionally left traces because the universe is so complex, and specifically mentioned faces in photographs as an example

Sounds kind of like wiping a hard drive but file fragments being left over that you can reconstruct if you try hard enough!

Mr Awe
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top