• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If Michelle Forbes had taken the job

The more I think about it, the more I wonder why the producers didn't bring her in for some of the Maquis episodes?

Well, she turned down the job of Kira so it was either because they didn't want to give her any more money, or because she turned down any offer they did make... at a guess :confused:
No, she supposedly didn't want to commit to a series as a regular. That's what I've always heard named as the reason why she refused the job. (Although she did a couple of years later sign up as a regular on Homicide:LOTS... but that didn't last long.)
 
AHA! I have my sources wrong! And not for the first time either! (Wait, I don't think I should be proud of that...)

Well, she's clearly a lunatic then.

Did she get offered a spot on Voyager by the way? I think I heard that somewhere.
 
Did she get offered a spot on Voyager by the way? I think I heard that somewhere.

I recall reading somewhere that the producers, briefly, toyed with Ro being among Chakotay's Maquis Cell but decided against it because they didn't think that Michelle Forbes would be interested.
 
Did she get offered a spot on Voyager by the way? I think I heard that somewhere.

I recall reading somewhere that the producers, briefly, toyed with Ro being among Chakotay's Maquis Cell but decided against it because they didn't think that Michelle Forbes would be interested.

Was this around the time they were writing "Preemptive Strike" because wasn't her tactical training alleged under Chakotay?
 
I'm also Wondering if Ro was Onboard would the Powers that be still bring Worf in the later Seasons. Worf was brought in to Bolster the show, would it had needed bolstering?
That's a good question. I think yes. Ensign, or Lt. Ro, wasn't really part of the "classic TNG" cast, and she was a polarizing character.
Whereas Worf was one of the main, and most popular, characters for all 7 years.
 
Did she get offered a spot on Voyager by the way? I think I heard that somewhere.

I recall reading somewhere that the producers, briefly, toyed with Ro being among Chakotay's Maquis Cell but decided against it because they didn't think that Michelle Forbes would be interested.

Was this around the time they were writing "Preemptive Strike" because wasn't her tactical training alleged under Chakotay?

Yes on the case of her tactical training. Chakotay was supposed to be the Lieutenant Commander that showed sympathy for the Maquis at Advanced Tactical according to a scene that was planned but cut.

Preemptive Strike came before Voyager so I'm not certain what the answer is.
 
That was the original intention, but afterwards they changed their mind and had it stated in VOY that Chakotay left Starfleet before Ro would have had her training.
 
Maybe the more important question is what if Famke Janssen had taken the role of Dax?

That would just be confusing, cause she was a Kriosian, not a Trill. :lol:

Well, originally the Trills had ridges and the reason they changed to spots was that they felt it made Terry look weird/not attractive enough. So if she did take the role she the Trills we know might have looked different.
 
Maybe the more important question is what if Famke Janssen had taken the role of Dax?

That would just be confusing, cause she was a Kriosian, not a Trill. :lol:

Well, originally the Trills had ridges and the reason they changed to spots was that they felt it made Terry look weird/not attractive enough. So if she did take the role she the Trills we know might have looked different.

A classic case of "let's just change the make-up. No-one will notice"
 
As much as Ro Laren was one of my favorite characters on TNG, I'm glad this didn't happen, as Nana Visitor's Kira Nerys was such a joy to watch.
 
AHA! I have my sources wrong! And not for the first time either! (Wait, I don't think I should be proud of that...)

Well, she's clearly a lunatic then.
IMDB has this quite:
On turning down "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" (1993): There were all sorts of rumors about why I didn't take [the DS9 role] and that I was quite arrogant about the whole thing. It wasn't that at all. It was, again, about wanting variety in my career. If I'd gone on to do DS9, I might not have had the variety I've been lucky to have in my career. That's not to say I wasn't grateful for the opportunity; I genuinely was. However, I had to make a choice that felt right for me, which was a difficult one, especially as a young actor being offered a steady job. (TV Zone Magazine, January 2005)
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000405/bio

It's hard to imagine. It definitely would have been a different dynamic. Instead of Sisko and Kira learning to trust each other, it would have been Ro and the Bajoran provisional government trying to come to terms. Ro and Odo would have been uneasy with each other at best while Ro and Quark would probably have become fast friends - perhaps even more.
Did I forget something from TNG - was Ro's affinity for Ferengis ever established in any way in canon, or does that come just from the books?

I don't know which and kind of relationships would Ro have had as opposed to Kira, and which dynamics would have been played up the most, but that would depend in part on the kind of chemistry Forbes would have had with other cast members - so I find it difficult to guess.
 
Did I forget something from TNG - was Ro's affinity for Ferengis ever established in any way in canon, or does that come just from the books?

I think the assumption derives from Ro's edgier past with Starfleet. She always came off as more of a rebel, less polished than the regular crew (which may be the reason many people were turned off by her)

Basically the difference between Ro as First Officer vs Kira is that you would have one character who was not a spiritual Bajoran patriot and Kira who was very much so. Personally I feel taking a Bajoran atheist and parking her right outside her people's "heaven" would make for very interesting character development indeed.
 
Did I forget something from TNG - was Ro's affinity for Ferengis ever established in any way in canon, or does that come just from the books?
I think the assumption derives from Ro's edgier past with Starfleet. She always came off as more of a rebel, less polished than the regular crew (which may be the reason many people were turned off by her)

Basically the difference between Ro as First Officer vs Kira is that you would have one character who was not a spiritual Bajoran patriot and Kira who was very much so. Personally I feel taking a Bajoran atheist and parking her right outside her people's "heaven" would make for very interesting character development indeed.
But how is being a rebel connected to liking the Ferengis, or Quark in particular? Quark is not a rebel, he is very much a "proper" Ferengi that obeys all the Rules of Acquisition. And their culture's views about women don't seem like something that would be sure to appeal to a strong, independent woman.
 
I think Ro came off as far more open minded about people. Because she traveled off-world in the diversity of starships and Starfleet academy, she was likely more accepting of interspecies relationships as Kira was, who only had four relationships in the entire series, only one of them being a non-Bajoran (aside from the initial attraction to Tom Riker and Chief O'Brien, which was just plain weird if you ask me.) Kira seemed always turned off by Dax's openness in her relationships and showed outright revulsion toward more diverse species like Ferengi and Captain Boday. Just my opinion, but that characterization of openness seems to have carried over in the continuing books concerning Ro.
 
It's hard to imagine. It definitely would have been a different dynamic. Instead of Sisko and Kira learning to trust each other, it would have been Ro and the Bajoran provisional government trying to come to terms. Ro and Odo would have been uneasy with each other at best while Ro and Quark would probably have become fast friends - perhaps even more.
Did I forget something from TNG - was Ro's affinity for Ferengis ever established in any way in canon, or does that come just from the books?

As others have said, it has nothing to do with an affinity for Ferengi, simply a contrary personality that would probably find some kinship with the likes of Quark.
 
I think Ro came off as far more open minded about people. Because she traveled off-world in the diversity of starships and Starfleet academy, she was likely more accepting of interspecies relationships as Kira was, who only had four relationships in the entire series, only one of them being a non-Bajoran (aside from the initial attraction to Tom Riker and Chief O'Brien, which was just plain weird if you ask me.) Kira seemed always turned off by Dax's openness in her relationships and showed outright revulsion toward more diverse species like Ferengi and Captain Boday. Just my opinion, but that characterization of openness seems to have carried over in the continuing books concerning Ro.
And still, that's pure conjecture, and we never actually saw any evidence on screen of Ro's open-mindedness about people , or of her open-mindedness about inter-species relationships, except for her fling with Riker... which doesn't make her different from Kira. We're not aware of any other relationships she might have had... She did not have any relationships with Bajorans on Enterprise, but there were hardly any Bajorans on Enterprise, and I don't remember that we ever got to see any male ones. Kira, on the other hand, eventually had the weirdest of all interspecies relationships - is there really anything more unusual than a romantic relationship between a humanoid and a Changeling?

Because she traveled off-world in the diversity of starships and Starfleet academy, she was likely more accepting of interspecies relationships as Kira was
You really think that people who have travelled a lot or been in the company of more diverse people are by default more open minded? Not from my observation.

Also, I almost forgot to comment on this:
Basically the difference between Ro as First Officer vs Kira is that you would have one character who was not a spiritual Bajoran patriot and Kira who was very much so.
A spiritual Bajoran patriot? That she wasn't. But a Bajoran patriot? Very much so. She was all about talking about the Occupation, about her history on Bajor, getting angry at Picard for not using her surname first - the Bajoran way, insisting on wearing her earring... (That Trek costume people later didn't pay attention and had other Bajorans wear it on another ear, was just an insignificant error, and that Trek Lit authors later tried to give it a meaning, was pure retcon.)

I mean, come on - Ro is not Dax, she never came across as a particularly open-minded person, she is far more similar to Kira, and when she was introduced in TNG she was supposed to represent Bajorans. That she wasn't religious wasn't that important since Bajoran religion was very much a side issue on TNG.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top