• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

humour

Lots of hilarious lines in the film. Scotty was terrible though, his humor was too broad and ruined the tone.

No, one or two lines didn't work, but he had several lines that got a really good laugh from the audience. The transwarping transportation analogy got me both times.
 
I think my favorite line was when Cupcake said to Kirk at the bar that there was four of them. Kirk's response, "Well, go get a few more and then we'll have a fair fight," so sumpin or other. Awesome.

I also thoroughly enjoyed Scotty's lines. All of them.
 
I think the humor is a large part of what made it such an enjoyable film and accessible for so many people.

I enjoyed most of the jokes (especially "Out of the chair" and "I have no comment on the matter"), but "Numb tongue?" made my eye twitch a bit. My mind jumped to Scooby Doo when Kirk said that and tried to give Uhura the message.

To make it clear I am not trying to be cynical, I find myself laughing often at TOS. I love how a previous poster described it as "happy humor"... I completely agree. It's silly, light-hearted, and wholesome. I just want to wrap it all in a big hug and squeeze the stuffin' out of it.
 
i liked how they intertwined the humor so it relieved tension in otherwhise a pretty serious film.
much in the way tos did.
even the ultra serious city had touches of humor thorugh it.

as for scotty well try the end of by any other name or tribbles as to how he wasnt played totally seriously all the time.

hmm so many of mine have been mentioned but..

bones entry.. the whole take a seat thing.
people were applauding and laughing at the same time.

the koybashi maru..notice how some of the other cadets are happily reacting.
(and some of them later on also on enterprise.)

kirk's look when sulu says his experience is in fencing.

when kirk spock and pike are transported back to the ship a reall scene of joy that is expressed by scotty and his tech (who is doohan's son)
 
I liked the scene between prime spock and kirk , when he is told to take command of the enterprise ,kirk says something like" what overyour dead body", and prime spock say"preferably not"
 
Did anyone raise a smile, when chekov had trouble speaking to the computer thought it was cute to play up on his accent
 
Did anyone raise a smile, when chekov had trouble speaking to the computer thought it was cute to play up on his accent

Yes I did...I thought it was a cute scene. I was afraid of not liking Chekov's accent at all because I heard some negative things about it beforehand.....but I actually loved it! Loved it so much that I've tried desperately (alright not desperately) to get the Chekov toy from BK because he says his name which would of been a hoot. But it's not meant to be....:wah:
 
I think the moment that cracks me up the most is the Red Shirt's excitement about "kicking some Romulan arse" or whatever, followed by a blank stare on the part of Sulu and Kirk.

It's the kind of thing that's satisfying as a long time fan because really the longer you've been following Trek the funnier that moment is.

There were a few clunky lines in the movie, and a few gratuitous bits that felt awkward, but whatever, mostly the humor worked.

Taking a step back for a moment I will say this: it is hard to give the destruction of a planet and the death of a few billion souls the weight it deserves when you are concerned with getting back to the funny action romp a few frames later.

Imagine the opening sequence of the film with a few wisecracks thrown in.
 
also liked the bit when scotty , was talking about food and his sidekick said something and scotty said shut the ,then stopped before he swore.
 
I think the moment that cracks me up the most is the Red Shirt's excitement about "kicking some Romulan arse" or whatever, followed by a blank stare on the part of Sulu and Kirk.

It's the kind of thing that's satisfying as a long time fan because really the longer you've been following Trek the funnier that moment is.

There were a few clunky lines in the movie, and a few gratuitous bits that felt awkward, but whatever, mostly the humor worked.

Taking a step back for a moment I will say this: it is hard to give the destruction of a planet and the death of a few billion souls the weight it deserves when you are concerned with getting back to the funny action romp a few frames later.

Imagine the opening sequence of the film with a few wisecracks thrown in.

I have always appreciated the humor of TOS.

I was watching The City on the Edge of Forever last night, and even though it dealt with the death of a storyline character, there were plenty of instances of laughable interaction with a lot of characters. However, the usual last scene between the characters and having a light hearted moment was not warranted and stay in 'character' to the episode.

I will take humour in any episode as long as it is done right and with purpose. Just like there aren't all serious days at a job, there are serious days in TOS (Balance of Terror) to non-serious days (I, Mudd).
 
I liked when Chekov was running to the transporter room mumbling "I can do that, I can do that!" No offense to Wil Wheaton, but that's what a precocious wunkerkind should act like.
 
He shouts, "Ja, major!" (ya-my-yor) when he gets Kirk and Sulu on the pad. That's a German spelling of the Russian I heard.

Does anybody know what that means?
 
^^Simply "Yes, Sir!", I think. With perhaps the wrong rank. Or was that really Russian?
I think my favorite line was when Cupcake said to Kirk at the bar that there was four of them. Kirk's response, "Well, go get a few more and then we'll have a fair fight," so sumpin or other. Awesome.
:lol: Thank you. I'd forgotten that.
Did anyone raise a smile, when chekov had trouble speaking to the computer thought it was cute to play up on his accent
Yes. I am foreign and sometimes I find English to be a mouthful and I found it funny that the computer wouldn't recognize the words. I also found Chekov's mix of youthful enthusiasm and brilliance made him a very enjoyable, funny character with too few scenes.
 
When I went to the first viewing on opening night, people laughed at every joke. The second time around... not a one. Maybe it was just because everybody had already seen it?
 
There are different dynamics with different audiences. People have to start laughing for others to follow. The French audience I was a part of laughed very little. At this kind of movie, it's always the same: I feel as if I am almost the only one. I knew it would be like that, but... it was a 3/4 full, huge theatre!
 
I guffawed a little louder than most :alienblush: but I liked the humour. I enjoyed Simon Pegg's lines and look forward to what he has to do in the next flick. My favorite moments were when Kirk was having the allergic reactions. McCoy keeps injecting him: "THHHstop that!" :lol:
 
He shouts, "Ja, major!" (ya-my-yor) when he gets Kirk and Sulu on the pad. That's a German spelling of the Russian I heard.

Does anybody know what that means?
PKTrekGirl might; I'm pretty sure she speaks Russian. There's someone else I've seen posting recently from Moscow, if I can only remember who.

(Edit: Desleane)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top