• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Give Number One a Name Already

Majel's take on it (...) was that Number One came from an Earth colony where the populace toyed with genetic engineering, cloning, etc, and "Number One" was her only designation/name.

That's what I've heard too and I quite like that. Leaves room for explanation how she could be so old (or was there one in NF?) and why she doesn't appear to age. :-)
 
Morgan Primus can't be Number One, at least not if you accept the Barret/Fontana backstory for Number One. Morgan is several centuries old (so not from any Earth colony) and her immortality is magic (not the product of anything understandable).
 
Or perhaps the pseudonym she used for the role, "Grace Hudec".

She didn't use a pseudonym as Number One. She was billed as "M. Leigh Hudec," which was her real name, the M. standing for Majel. If anything, "Barrett" is the pseudonym.

Arrg. Somewhere along the line I knew that (once upon a time, I'd used her as "Commodore Hudec" in a ST role-playing game (from whence the "emperorkalan" name also comes)).

Apparently somewhere in the back of my head her name collided with Grace Lee Whitney's.
 
Guinan's people, the "species of listeners," wound up with the formal name El Aurians. Perhaps Number One's actual name is Numero Uno. :lol:

Reminds me of some of the early Legion of Super Heroes origins. For example, the real name of Ultra Boy, who gained his powers when he was swallowed by a space whale, is "Jo Nah." Oh, and Matter Eater Lad, who can digest anything, comes from a planet called Bismoll.

Long Live the Legion! :) {ProfJonathan}
 
Morgan Primus can't be Number One, at least not if you accept the Barret/Fontana backstory for Number One.

Why not? Illyria could have been one of Earth's earliest colonies, which would make it centuries old by the TNG timeframe. Scientists might have been quick to take up residence there and freely experiment with genetic engineering since such practices were outlawed on Earth. And Primus does mean "Number One" after all.
 
Morgan Primus can't be Number One, at least not if you accept the Barret/Fontana backstory for Number One.

Why not? Illyria could have been one of Earth's earliest colonies, which would make it centuries old by the TNG timeframe. Scientists might have been quick to take up residence there and freely experiment with genetic engineering since such practices were outlawed on Earth. And Primus does mean "Number One" after all.
Because, if nothing else, Morgan's immortality is a mystery. And, as I recall, she's from Earth.
 
I'm happy with DC Fontana's backstory for Number One, which built upon Majel's own ideas. You can't get much closer to the source than that. Works just fine for me.

I personally never cared for the Fontana/Barrett backstory. It tries to explain something that needs no explanation. She was called "Number One" because that is a common naval nickname for the ships First Officer.
 
Earlier this week I flipped through John Byrne's latest Trek comic, which featured "Number One" from TOS' "The Cage" from a time before the events of that episode.

The comic seemed decent enough, but it also seemed like they danced around the issue of Number One having no established name. That's cute, but tiring.


If it's true Byrne work, you'll get that every issue - He's got this rule (Byrne has many "rules"), that toys have to go back in the box in the form you found them - you don't change anything, so I wouldn't expect her to get a name...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top