• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

dax death question....

If Terry didn’t leave the show, Pah Wraith/Dukat would have simply zapped Jadzia unconscious or a Bajoran security redshirt would have been in her place. Worf wouldn't have trashed Vic's lounge, and Jadzia would have taken leave to visit Captain Sisko just before he, his father and Jake leave to fird the missing Orb.
 
In the last episode of DS9 season 6, doctor basier said that there was nothing that he could do to help dax.. With all that medical advancement how could there be nothing he can do abd she is still alive for that brief of time? Also in "the wreckoning" kira and jake were possessed by wormhole aliens and were hurt and dr bashier fixed them up just fine, so what was wrong with dax?

Trill, like Kryptonians, are vulnerable to magic.
 
yes... i tend to agree with plynch... it just suddenly appears in that season... and dax's death was done rather horribly.... but yet i find it odd that dukat apologized to dax after he did that....
 
Maybe Marritza didn't die after all...

As for Dax, could it be that sehe had been given some of these fancy future stimulants, so she was conscious while still at the brink of death?

Marritza should not have died (or it should have been possible to bring him back to life).
 
Last edited:
yes... i tend to agree with plynch... it just suddenly appears in that season... and dax's death was done rather horribly.... but yet i find it odd that dukat apologized to dax after he did that....

With Dukat...I think once the Pah-Wraith went out of him, he may have been a bit stunned at what he'd done. He did look kind of somber on the way out--I don't think he regretted what he'd done in the sense of striking against the Prophets, but I do think he may have wished he'd been able to attack Sisko or Kira, or someone else he had more direct enmity with.

Maybe Marritza didn't die after all...

As for Dax, could it be that sehe had been given some of these fancy future stimulants, so she was conscious while still at the brink of death?

Marritza should not have died (or it should have been possible to bring him back to life).

Like I said, I'm not sure that's so easy when the victim does not WANT to live. Even in the 24th century, I would expect the patient's will to continue to be a factor as it is today. I think Marritza's spirit would've been long gone even if he could be physically revived--all you'd have would be a brain-dead shell, is my guess.

And with Dax, I suspect that was the case, in order to give Bashir time to preserve the symbiont.
 
well i would think that dax would want to live because she and worf were going to have a child...
 
well i would think that dax would want to live because she and worf were going to have a child...

I think Dax did, but Dukat did such severe neurological damage it wasn't possible.

Marritza's a different case, though...his wound should've been much simpler to fix, but I think on some level, he didn't allow that to happen.
 
Like I said, I'm not sure that's so easy when the victim does not WANT to live. Even in the 24th century, I would expect the patient's will to continue to be a factor as it is today. I think Marritza's spirit would've been long gone even if he could be physically revived--all you'd have would be a brain-dead shell, is my guess.

Perhaps Marritza merely refused care. At the time, he was not a prisoner, and if conscious fully free to make such a choice--assuming medical ethics work the same in the 24th century, which is, I admit, a logical leap.

Likewise, declaring the man mentally incompetent would not have been the hardest task.

Still, I stick by this theory as the best explanation.
 
Like I said, I'm not sure that's so easy when the victim does not WANT to live. Even in the 24th century, I would expect the patient's will to continue to be a factor as it is today. I think Marritza's spirit would've been long gone even if he could be physically revived--all you'd have would be a brain-dead shell, is my guess.

Perhaps Marritza merely refused care. At the time, he was not a prisoner, and if conscious fully free to make such a choice--assuming medical ethics work the same in the 24th century, which is, I admit, a logical leap.

Likewise, declaring the man mentally incompetent would not have been the hardest task.

Still, I stick by this theory as the best explanation.

I'm not sure he was conscious long enough to refuse care in any verbal manner--it didn't look like they cut away from the death scene for any time. It was more like--in goes the knife, BOOM, he's dead.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top