Star Trek: Starships Model/Magazine Subscription

[137th Gebirg]

I still often ponder if they foolishly assigned the task of R&D for the XL E-A model to some summer intern who happened to be someone's relative high-up the food chain and didn't know the first thing about the ships. When you look at that thing, and compare it to one of the other XL's like Voyager or Reliant, which were damn nice, you really wonder what the hell happened there. :WTF:

I know that Ben attended many conventions over the years (and still does) talking about their products. Has anyone ever asked, "Dude, WTF was up with that XL E-A??" Inquiring minds, and all that...

 

[dantini]

I still often ponder if they foolishly assigned the task of R&D for the XL E-A model to some summer intern who happened to be someone's relative high-up the food chain and didn't know the first thing about the ships.

Must have been the same guy who did the Stargate Puddle Jumper.

 

[Firebird]

I still often ponder if they foolishly assigned the task of R&D for the XL E-A model to some summer intern who happened to be someone's relative high-up the food chain and didn't know the first thing about the ships. When you look at that thing, and compare it to one of the other XL's like Voyager or Reliant, which were damn nice, you really wonder what the hell happened there. :WTF:

I know that Ben attended many conventions over the years (and still does) talking about their products. Has anyone ever asked, "Dude, WTF was up with that XL E-A??" Inquiring minds, and all that...

The bizarre thing is the sculpt for the pre-Trumbull Bridge superstructure is actually accurate to the reference photos! Whomever was doing the modeling work for Eaglemoss did a fantastic job... for the wrong damn ship.

 

[137th Gebirg]

And really all they needed to do was proof-read the primary hull. The secondary hull, nacelles and pylons all seemed to be pretty much correct.

Didn't much care for the decals, either. They were a little oversized for the scale they were shooting for.

 

[Tomalak]

The decals were really poor - and the paint job wasn't great either. Basically the Corgi model improved in every respect at a slightly smaller scale, although at a somewhat higher price point.

 

[Cradok]

There's not a lot of models you'd want redone, especially given how many ships they did by the end, but the ones you would are mostly Big ones. Most of them are Enterprises, even, and most that aren't are Starfleet.

I know Ben Robinson answered why they never did a separated Galaxy Class/E-D but I wonder if he’s ever said why they didn’t do at least the “at warp” Voyager.

Same basic reason, I believe, that they wanted to do it as moving parts but couldn't. Which doesn't really wash, three versions of the Bird of Prey and all.

Honestly, 90% or so of what they did was great, but the remaining 10% was full of completely baffling choices.

 

[pst]

Oh, speaking of Fanhome retreading EM... how about an SNW version of the Enterprise? Updated engine detailing, windows on the saucer and maybe a metallic paint scheme (I know that last part is asking too much, they always go with flat gray even when these things look metallic on screen these days).

Anyone compared the LDS Titan to the Picard Titan? Did Fanhome reuse EM's old LDS sculpt?

 

[Paul755]

I don’t mind them redoing some of the Eaglemoss stuff. A SNW version of the Discoprise makes a ton of sense. And I’m sure eventually they will want to do the classic hero ships. The Enterprise, the E-D, Defiant, Voyager, etc…

But there is no way we’ll get redos of Kes’ Shuttle or the TOS Orion Ship, etc…

 

[NCC-73515]

Oh, speaking of Fanhome retreading EM... how about an SNW version of the Enterprise? Updated engine detailing, windows on the saucer and maybe a metallic paint scheme (I know that last part is asking too much, they always go with flat gray even when these things look metallic on screen these days).

Anyone compared the LDS Titan to the Picard Titan? Did Fanhome reuse EM's old LDS sculpt?

The LDS Titan is more purple than the novel Titan, IIRC. The PIC Titan is a completely new ship (Conny III)

 

[Tomalak]

Fanhome also did Riker's Titan, which Eaglemoss did in two flavours: LD and a "realistic" version which appeared in the PUC S2 and S3 fleet scenes.

 

[dantini]

Anyone compared the LDS Titan to the Picard Titan? Did Fanhome reuse EM's old LDS sculpt?

They're different, here's a comparison:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies