They’re not art pieces. Technologies follow form after function. They look like they do after the tech anspects are satisfied. It’s not until the Technology Unchained era with the Galaxy Class that you begin to mold technology into whatever form you want, and even there it isn’t absolute.They would be "new" ships if newly constructed. Why not? Your saying that a ship cant be the shape of a Miranda, yet far more capable than the 2280s Reliant. Since we know that an F-16V outclasses an F-16A, Occams Razor doesnt tell us much of anything here. No reason the SHAPE just magically means you cant cram in 24th century tech into it. We know that's wrong from the real world.
Aircraft carriers are glorified barges. They’ve got some advanced techs onboard but it’s the planes that are the main event. Starships are closer to aircraft than sea ships.The some of the Arleigh Burke-class destroyers have been in service for over 30 years, yet the last of the Block IIA destroyers are being finished as the first of the Block III destroyers enter service now. The Nimitz-class carriers range from 16 to 50 years old.
The B-52 is the exception that proves the rule. Also bombers are glorified sky barges. Starfleet might still use fifty year old Excelsiors like the Hood as cargo ships but it shouldn’t on the front lines. Hell, would the B-52’s still be around if we were engaged in hot wars with comparable adversaries lo these 50 years? I doubt it. We’re just ahead and can afford to reuse stagnant technology.And the B-52 is on track to be a Century old Bomber design that is still in use.
Just because something is old, doesn't mean you can't update it and make it useful.
-
Someone mentioned the Klingons. They too are ahead of the game having been an empire for a thousand years and possibly using or got the jumpstart of advanced Hur’Q technologies. They’re brutal and extractive to a huge swath of space because of it. Also they also devote a lot more of their blood and treasure to war, so even with stagnating tech they can be overwhelm their enemies.
But they’re barely keeping apace. They’re R&D and scientific traditions just aren’t as robust. They destroyed their key energy producer Praxis just to keep up with the upstart and overwhelming UFP, in peacetime, and I think if not for the disaster relief and tech exchange leading to advanced ships like the Vor’cha, they’d already be “the alien trash of the galaxy,” and a shrinking empire chipped and carved away from without and within.
Last edited: