• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

No vehicle, be it car, boat, or starship, is capable of maintaining maximum velocity at all times. Warp 7.5 is pretty respectable, in my opinion, for Voyager with a top speed of 9.975. I'm surprised it was that high an average with all the backtracking and side missions Voyager undertook in addition to scrounging for food and supplies.
9.975 Might have been the "Top Speed" listed on the Ship Specs.

But they also stated that 9.75 was sustainable for 12 hours, so they probably couldn't sustain 9.975 for that long of a period.
 
It's just simple that the Writers goofed up, or there was another hidden "Under Space" passage that leads from Earth to Kronos in 4 days that we don't know about.

Alternative theory: After Cochrane's invention of warp drive technology developed extremely quickly, so that only 4 years later, they already could build a probe capable of reaching speeds around warp 5 on the TOS scale (that's what would be needed) to travel about 30.000 light years in 200 years non-stop, without refueling or requiring maintenance (VOY: Friendship 1).

By the 2150's technology had progressed to the point that Q'onos could be reached in 4 days (at warp 4.5).

Then, all this fantastic warp technology regressed somehow, leading to the much slower TOS and TNG speeds, though the generations in these eras were too proud to admit it. So, they probably inflated the warp scales to hide that, making Vulcan -much closer to Earth than Q'onos- 4 days travel away at TOS high cruise speeds (probably around warp 6 or 7?).
 
No vehicle, be it car, boat, or starship, is capable of maintaining maximum velocity at all times. Warp 7.5 is pretty respectable, in my opinion, for Voyager with a top speed of 9.975. I'm surprised it was that high an average with all the backtracking and side missions Voyager undertook in addition to scrounging for food and supplies.

In "Caretaker" Voyager is stated to have a "sustainable cruise velocity of warp factor 9.975", not a maximum cruise velocity.
 
Didn't they show that being used during the Klingon war in SNW?
Yup, but they didn't think about doing that in the 24th century when ever Voyager was over loaded with patients.
That should be the SOP (Standard Operating Practice) in any modern UFP Medical Facility.

Most likely the Writers didn't think of it IRL, but in-Universe, it sucks that patients died because they weren't frozen in the Transporter Buffer.

That can literally freeze all patients "Golden Hour" and allow Medical Resources enough time to properly treat all patients coming in.

You won't run into a case of "The Doctor" having to make a hard decision of who to triage.

He can take his time and either run multiple instances of his program to treat as many people as Server Capacity allows multiple copies of himself to run, or up to whatever medical resource limit is currently available.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top