• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Walking Dead The Ones Who Live

I am wondering if that is the case. ANd if so... how would it work? So he might be the one that Carol said has returned... and it might make sense if he and Carol drove together up the coast

Except Carol took off on her own to find Daryl, and while the showrunners wanted to lay bread crumbs about the mystery person she was referring to during her radio conversation with Daryl (on the Daryl Dixon series), i'm not certain it was Morgan. For all anyone knows its Dwight or Sherry, since they've resettled nearby at the former Saviors' compound.

Also he has his daughter with him... is he gonna follow the TWD pattern of behavior that in the "real" world would call out Child Protective Services, or will she join him?

I hope not. The Morgan arc of FTWD ended with the character coming to grips with all of the people he's lost since the ZA's start, so he would not take Mo into a conflict with a real military force. That, and child endangerment plots have been done to death in the WD franchise, so it would be sensible for Mo to stay at Alexandria.



So for this latest episode... i have felt like @TREK_GOD_1 has given "too many" A+ to shows like TWD and Black Lightning...
The shows are graded based on what I believed they've honestly earned.

but if that is his grade for episode 4, I would actually agree.

Review coming this evening, so we will see...

I still don't understand how Michonne can't see the real threat by the CRM.... they have gas bombs and missiles. She knows darn well Alexandria can not compete with that. ANd them escaping (at least at the beginning) --- how would they be able to make it to literally across the country (they were in the Washington state region, right?)

Michonne may be changing her tune about the threat the CRM poses in E5.
 
Except Carol took off on her own to find Daryl, and while the showrunners wanted to lay bread crumbs about the mystery person she was referring to during her radio conversation with Daryl (on the Daryl Dixon series), i'm not certain it was Morgan. For all anyone knows its Dwight or Sherry, since they've resettled nearby at the former Saviors' compound.
They could have split anywhere between Alexandria and Maine (isn't that where she found Darryl's bike?)

We'll see... i still don't feel like the other series connect very well, but maybe they will surprise me. I guess we'll find out this summer. But another lingering thing then is that Carol will be ditching her very important duties for the COmmonwealth. (ANd also sad that she didn't stay with Ezekiel)
I hope not. The Morgan arc of FTWD ended with the character coming to grips with all of the people he's lost since the ZA's start, so he would not take Mo into a conflict with a real military force. That, and child endangerment plots have been done to death in the WD franchise, so it would be sensible for Mo to stay at Alexandria.
The thing is... they have also done the "leaving kids out to make it convenient for our characters to operate" plot a little too much too. Maggie makes the most sense , since her son was kidnapped. But Negan had a plot excuse to not show his wife or child... and RJ & Judith have been without now both parents for quite a while (to allow for the actors to return -- IF they wanted to).

For Morgan to ditch Mo so soon after reuniting seems lame and out of character. Dwight at least trained FInch over the years, so at least he was able to be with his son and raise him to a degree, even if his son didn't know it. Which added to the tragedy, because they could have had a pretty healthy relationship moving forward.

Morgan spent years away from his child. Seems like the least they could do is stay together.
The shows are graded based on what I believed they've honestly earned.
Yeah... i think we have an honest disagreement on A+... where i see those as just absolute perfection. A
s aren't bad, and i just see those as pieces that make the series overall a good one....just not the best of the show. Sometimes, we won't see it until later
Review coming this evening, so we will see...
looking forward to it
Michonne may be changing her tune about the threat the CRM poses in E5.
They have been pretty good about quickly addressing "issues" i see in one episode, so I am trusting them to make it make sense (such as Michonne taking off Rick's helmet)
 
This would have been posted days ago, but its been a very busy week.

The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live
- Season one, episode 4 - "What We"

Rick and Michonne I: On the helicopter back to base, Michonne and Rick sit facing each other, without exchanging a word. Suddenly, an scowling Michonne detaches their seat belts, grabs Rick and leaps out of the helicopter into the stormy darkness, her VO apologizing to Judith, because she does not know if they will ever make it back. Well, they did survive by falling into a river. Locating an A.I.-controlled high rise outfitted with nearly every amenity for someone still living there (curiously, no food in the refrigerator). Michonne finds a closet full of civilian clothes, which she exchanges for her CRM uniform, all the while observed by Rick--first appreciating her body (which he has not touched in six years), until his expression changes at the sight of the "X" brand on her back.

Michonne browses a bookshelf, recalling stories she read in childhood, using that to ask Rick to create a story of his own, explaining his refusal to return home...to his children. Catching the reference, Michonne informs the stunned Rick about RJ. Michonne is enraged when Rick's first response is to ask for the PRB:

Michonne: "I JUST TOLD YOU YOU HAVE A SON! I DON'T KNOW WHO YOU ARE ANYMORE!"
Rick: "--I'm trying to keep you and them alive--you need to give it to me."
Michonne: "What did you say? 'Everything we had is broken'--
Rick:"You have no idea who we're dealing with here--you need to give it to me!"
Michonne:"...raising our kids, believing you were alive and you were!
Rick: "Y-you think I didn't want to be with you?? I tri--I tried everything!! We need to go back! "

Rick: "I told you not to show them who you are, and you break the kill record. You grabbed the R-DIM from Thorne, and nearly get yourself killed! I'm tryin' to get you out of here alive, a-and you pull us out of a goddamned helicopter!"
Michonne: "That's because I don't like who you are with them--what they make you! It isn't you!"
Rick: "You thin-you think I want this? Are you gonna give it to me?"
Michonne: "So what? We just...let them win?"
Rick: "Heh...look at me. They won a long time ago. They won the day Jadis brought me here."
Michonne: "She brought you? (realizing how obvious this revelation is) She was working for them, wasn't she?"
Rick: "With them. She was runnin' away from Alexandria, she saw me half dead in the riverbank...she will destroy our home....if I try to leave. I was...makin' her let you go. I got that much out of her."
Michonne: "Y-you want me to go?"
Rick:"I want you to live. She's threatened by us because...together--you and me--she thinks we can do anything."
Michonne: "We can. We can stop her--"
Rick:"You saw what happened to your friends--it will happen to everyone we know! To our children. Our son."
Michonne: "If we get to Alexandria first--"
Rick: "..find everyone we know? If we get there in time? You want to risk that?"
Michonne: "We'll kill her then--we should have done that in the beginning."

Rick continues, informing Michonne about Jadis' threat to use her dossier on Rick and his people, countered by Michonne wanting to finds said dossier, then kill Jadis so they can escape. Rick's silence engenders partial disgust and shock in realizing how effective the CRM had been in breaking Rick. Rick asks her go go back; Michonne--tearing up--asks if Rick still loves her, which he confirms, stating he's never stopped loving her.

Michonne hands him the PRB at the exact moment the couple spots their helicopter crashed into a side of the building. Michonne is elated, believing Jadis will will think everyone died in the crash, so there's nothing to stop them from returning home--together, but Rick--once again--refuses.

Sometime later, Michonne stares out of the window, telling Rick how RJ refers to himself as "the little brave man"..how RJ and Judith tell each other stories about their father, but turns to judging him, recalling how Nat was right, as she did find Rick...but did not. Rick argues that by staying, he can protect his loved ones by trying to carry out Okafor's mission the change the CRM from within, which Michonne cannot believe, since the CRM is the organization that held him against his will for six years, and, noting how he stands at attention as a soldier--sees him as an obedient prisoner.


Michonne: "You don't choose to stay in prison--when the door's open, you leave!"
Rick: "We've been crawling around in the dirt for so long, Michonne, losing people we love--this felt like...a way or a chance to stop that, not surrender to it. To fight--for everyone!"
Michonne: "That...place..is not your responsibility! You have A FAMILY!"
Rick: "Okafor's gone. Thorne's one of them now, I'm the only one left."
Michonne: "So uh...you're trying to..keep us safe by maybe changing the CRM...one day. Who might come after our home, and put it in danger? That's it? You won't come home with me--to your life? ...kids?"
Rick: "I don't want to do this--I have to."

Michonne has had enough, running down all she's sacrificed to find Rick, while gathering her CRM belt and a makeshift staff, accusing Rick of being a liar who will only realize the truth when its too late.

She leaves, marching down a hallway, until she stops to turn--hoping Rick might follow--her eyes watering. Inside the apartment, Rick--though breathing heavily in his heartbreak--reaches for the doorknob, his fingers inch, yet hesitate to open the door to go after his wife. Michonne makes her way down the stairs, right at the moment Rick comes to his senses and runs after her.

Rick and Michonne II: As Rick races to find Michonne, a CRM helicopter arrives--to fire its missiles into the wreckage of Rick's helicopter, the resultant explosion rocking the entire building, just as Rick leaps to protect Michonne from the blast. Luck being nonexistent in the WD world, the blast shattered glass entrances to the building, allowing an endless stream of Walkers to enter.

As the duo race to find an exit, slowly, their care for each other comes to the surface--Rick's decision to catch Michonne saying more than mere words are capable of expressing, although Rick's use of CRM terminology ("Defensible position") triggers a mocking "Commando" barb from Michonne. They find a lab with the corpse of a woman (suicide) who had been part of a project (in the wake of the ZA outbreak) to change the world through living off of the grid. Michonne observes that when some try to save the world in their own way, it tends to "go to shit"--a pointed reference to the CRM, leading to the unresolved issue...

Michonne: "..they thought they knew it all...oh, except without the killing of innocent people--except that part."
Rick: "The city stands.And i'll stop the killing. I'll find a way."
Michonne: "Just like her?"
Rick: "You still don't understand!"
Michonne: "Signing up for lifelong duty to the enemy?"
Rick: "This is about ending the enemy."
Michonne: "This--is not you, Rick!"
Rick: "This isn't me how? That I would give everything, my hand..my life for you. That's not me? This is what I need to do TO KEEP YOU SAFE!"
Michonne: "The only time I feel safe is when i'm with you. We don't have to be afraid, Rick."
Rick: "Yes...we do."
Michonne: "Is that what I tell your son? That his father didn't want to know anything about him because he was...so...afraid."
Rick: "I'm not 'The Brave Man'. You shouldn't have come. I was taken away--I didn't have a choice. You did."

Michonne angrily pushes Rick back, incensed at Rick's implication that she would have ever considered not trying to find him, and the unavoidable personal cost to her family.

Michonne: "You don't know a goddamned thing anymore, do you?? NOT A GODDAMED THING! So, this is who YOU are now? Big guy, huh? Soldier of the CRM. You moving up, Rick? That's the plan? Maybe I should be afraid of you! In the red uniforms--I don't know what you're capable of! You've lied to me. YOU KEEP LYING TO ME! YOU THINK I'M NOT BEATING MYSELF UP FOR NOT BEING WITH MY KIDS, RIGHT NOW?!? THAT I'M NOT WONDERING HOW I'LL EVER--LIVE WITH MYSELF IF--GOD FORBID---"
Rick: "That's why you should go."
Michonne: (Taking a deep breath in apparent defeat) "Okay. I don't know who you are. 'Cause the main I knew would never talk to me like that. Ever."

Rick has no response to that, because he knows she's right.

The duo break out out of the lab fighting through walkers, when a light fixture--and the ceiling which supported it--plummets in a stairwell, pinning Michonne's legs (not enough to break them). Although Michonne begs Rick to save himself, that sort of self-serving impulse is not a part of Rick Grimes' character, so he works to free his wife, while both kill Walkers shuffling toward them.

Michonne: "Thank you."
Rick: "You never have to thank me--ever."

With nowhere else to turn, the pair return to the apartment, with the strains of the relationship leaving them standing in silence, before they face each other, and despite all of their arguments and tension, both readily give in to their passion for each other. Rick suddenly hesitates, as if he's unsure about even relating to his wife (in a sexual sense), but Michonne reassures him with her eyes that there's not a thing wrong between them (SEE NOTES).

Sometime later, the couple are still in bed, discussing RJ, with Michonne noting the boy shares Rick's good and kind heart. Rick & Michonne are exactly where they should be (emotionally), until Rick begins talking about changing the CRM again, which Michonne sees as Rick deceiving her--and himself. Changing the subject, Michonne explains how her ex-college friend branded her hip with the "X", and how she had to stop searching for him, as he was not gone forever, which, she adds, she has not stopped searching.

Michonne adds that Rick can still come home, evidenced by his not signaling the CRM when he had the chance. Soon, debris from the crumbling building rains down in their room, but Michonne will not move until they comes to a decision about his future--to go home, or back to the CRM. Getting to the very heart of the matter, Michonne puts Rick on the spot:

Michonne: "After I left here, why did you come after me?"

Rick: "You know why."

Michonne: "Say it. I need you to."

Rick: "You're the love of my life. I couldn't just let you go...it felt like my heart...ripped itself out of my chest when you walked out the door!"

Michonne: "Then come home with me--its that easy."

Rick: "It's not that easy."

Michonne: "Listen to me. When this army attacked my friends--I got hit too, and nearly died.I was holed up in a mall, trying to recover with Nat for a year (SEE NOTES). They took a year from me. From my time with my kids. I lied to you--I don't know how Judith is. I-I don't know if she's okay! She stopped answering the walkie. They've taken so much from us! Why give them any more?!?"

Michonne (grabbing Rick): The hope that you have in the CRM--sacrificing yourself? Its not real! We--your family--are real! I'M real! Our love--this? It doesn't get denied! No matter what you keep trying to tell me--or yourself! And this...this back and forth...is hurting me, Rick. It's making me become someone I don't recognize. You're hurting me! And I know you. That is not how you love. What did they do to you?? I need you to try to tell me what's really going on here! What did they take from you?"

Rick (gasping & sobbing): "Carl. They took Carl. I lost him again. When I was taken, I fought and I fought and tried to get away, about how I would dream. I would meet up with Carl in my dream. ...and that's how I survived in here. Kept me alive. Then one day, he was just gone. Just left. But then I started dreamin' about you. And there you were--you and I fell in love in different ways, and it kept me going. ..and then you were gone, too. I couldn't see your face anymore, just like I couldn't see Carl's."

Rick: "I c-can't live without you. Without you, I die. And I figured out how to do that. I know how to be dead and live now. You can't just come back her and make me come alive again, if I don't know if I won't lose you again. What if I lose you, and I can't figure out how to die all over again? I can't--I can't. When I--when I saw you, I got so scared, I needed to get ahead of it. I had to. At least if I think you will live on longer than me without knowing if you do, I can just believe that its true. Knowing--seeing that loss? I can't. I won't survive that, Michonne. I won't. I just won't."

Michonne presents the phone bearing the illustration of Carl, and it instantly restores Carl's image (at various ages) in his mind.

Michonne: "If Carl were here right now, what would he say? What would he want you to do with this new chance to be with those you love? Hm? Despite all the odds, all the years, I found you, Rick. I cam here through the Hell that we have both been through to take you home."

Rick looks into Michonne's eyes, then back at the illustration of Carl.

Michonne: "You think that's all for nothing? For us to just go our separate ways? No. We go home, Rick. ..and we figure out how to protect it together. That's how we make it all make sense. We love on each other, as hard as we can...while we can."

Rick takes Michonne's words to heart, knowing he cannot push her away for fear that the next time he loses her might be a real loss, not one caused by separation and circumstance. Their love, she implies, is worth the risks of life (which everyone as to deal with), but they do have each other.

Rick and Michonne III: The couple work in perfect harmony to take down Walkers as they flee the building. Finding a truck powered by Ethanol, the loving duo drive off as the building collapses.

NOTES:
Where to begin... The Ones Who Live's 4th episode is as so many viewers have claimed--its one of the best hours--if not the very best episode--in The Walking Dead TV franchise's history, which was no small feat when one recalls numerous stellar episodes in the parent series.

The biggest draw of the episode was the fact that Danai Gurira--already a well-renowned playwright--delivered the rich character study that was this 4th episode. The depth of her understanding of not only her own character, but Lincoln's Rick Grimes so well, that the characters' troubled interaction played as real for any viewer in a long-lasting relationship, which would have easily fit into any genre, yet it still fit on a series about survival horror.The hurt over seeing a significant other psychologically and spiritually broken played with so much realistic weight.
We all have expectations of a partner to be there, to stand up with and for us, so anything less--especially if the partner repeatedly argues in favor of that which broke him (essentially erased that which brought the couple together) is more than anger-inducing, but fills a heart with a sense of loss (of both) that cannot be overcome. Michonne had reached that point, but Rick finally opening up the floodgates of his fears, his deep, still raw sadness over Carl being dead and how he tried to "live" as a "dead man" (death with his old life fading from memory), answered all of her concerns since they reunited.

In one of the many spot-on, tragic character moments of the episode, Rick laments not being able to "see" Carl anymore; he was attributing this to both being broken--that his knowing he would never return home meant even his memories of his son were not to be "accepted" within the CRM's enforced psychological conditioning. I feel there has to be some sort of retribution for that level of abuse--although I hope it is not in the form of two people believing they can bring down a massive military community...

Michonne's "We love on each other, as hard as we can...while we can." sort of carried an ominous ring to it....

Next: "Become" - Rick and Michonne are truly on the run..until confronted by someone who is determined to make sure they never return to Alexandria...or so its been suggested in some circles. That, and Michonne states they cannot return...

GRADE: A++. Wonderfully effective, meaningful episode in every imaginable category.
 
Warning!

Well, it didn't take long for spoilers about tonight's surprise return to hit the internet. It would have been nice to have been surprised, but it will be nice to see him once I actually get to see the show. Thank you for the spoiler, Entertainment Weekly.
 
Last edited:
For what it's worth, that particular character is in the episode's opening scene, so it's not spoiling anything too significant. Granted, as someone who went in unspoiled it was a fun moment to see the character back, but the episode certainly isn't ruined if you know in advance.
 
Dang, I just realized there's only ONE episode left in this...I hope they got the okay for a continuation.
 
I hope they got the okay for a continuation.
Although not officially announced, the general consensus is they'd be stupid if they didn't do another season, given the huge publicity TOWL has generated. Besides, even looking where E5 has ended, I see plenty of story possibilities that can fuel another season, so I think it's a safe bet.
 
Although not officially announced, the general consensus is they'd be stupid if they didn't do another season, given the huge publicity TOWL has generated. Besides, even looking where E5 has ended, I see plenty of story possibilities that can fuel another season, so I think it's a safe bet.

I mean, Dead City and Daryl's show both got renewed. I don't see why they didn't do so for this when it's the one that's doing a real continuation of TWD's storylines from TWD, Fear and World Beyond.
 
Although not officially announced, the general consensus is they'd be stupid if they didn't do another season, given the huge publicity TOWL has generated. Besides, even looking where E5 has ended, I see plenty of story possibilities that can fuel another season, so I think it's a safe bet.

I mean, Dead City and Daryl's show both got renewed. I don't see why they didn't do so for this when it's the one that's doing a real continuation of TWD's storylines from TWD, Fear and World Beyond.

I am pretty sure they are, considering it has broken recent records (i.e. most successful since pretty much TWD's hey day).

The thng is -- this was originally planned/marketed as 3 movies, so they might have focused on that... and was waiting to see what the follow up would be: theatrical or TV movie, or more season(s) or for some reason, an open cliffhanger.

I think we will see at the ending a DEFINITE continuation. But my continued personal concern is that everyone involved with WD are stuck in the franchise, and can't go on.... production crew doesn;t have any new shows they can do.... when know Lauren Cohan had a failed TV show, and just about everyone else doesn't seem to have any projects they are doing (other than Danai... but this role might be to help fund future stage stuff, which wouldn't be a money maker, though obviously awesome creative endeavors for her)

I definitely do NOT doubt there will be a second season of TOWL.... there real question is ...will season 2 be it, or will they find a way to drag it out?

Sort of interesting theories about who might show up in The Ones Who Live:

The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live Just Teased Morgan’s Return Explained
Looks like that was off... was the established character they suspected was actually
Faither Gabriel.
i
I BARELY recall Jadis and Father Gabriel being together.

i think they did a great job making it a "real" relationship.

i still kinda question how Jadis was able to sneak out every year, or why the CRM is ignoring Alexandria (or even more so, the COmmonwealth

Oh, and are we just waiting for @TREK_GOD_1 's review before dropping spoiler tags.... or is this still like Voldemoort's name?
 
^ Well, I was only being vague because the episode had literally just dropped. It was indeed nice to see Gabriel again and I felt they gave Jadis a satisfactory conclusion to a very fascinating overall story arc (although the walkers that got her seem to come out of absolutely nowhere). Even as I shed no tears for her demise, her comment that "I wish I'd died an artist" still hit hard.
 
In terms of a movie trilogy the story for this season could probably be about two movies or even 1.5 movies depending on runtime and how tight it was edited.
 
The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live - Season one, episode 5 - "Become"

Father Gabriel walks through the forest, and after killing a Walker, then seeing a helicopter fly over, he says a prayer (SEE NOTES).

Rick and Michonne I:
On the road, the couple happily head home, along the way, they discover a van spilling over with boxes of ramen noodles, which they happily consume, thinking nothing of tossing the packaging (a mistake). Finding a campsite convenience store, Michonne notes that she was never fond of the mini vanity plates because--as Rick adds--her name was not one to be found on the souvenir. While Michonne looks around, Rick spots a necklace bearing the name "Michelle". Rick decides it will make a nice gift for Michonne...after he breaks off every letter except "M".

Finding the key to a cabin they'll use for the evening, the couple head to the location on foot, coming across

Michonne: "Thorne was so...uptight..just trying so hard for this army. Too hard."
Rick: "She was trying' to get home to South Africa to someone she loves, but Okafor found her, and she stopped trying. You know, I never let go. I denied it. I pushed you away, but I never let go."
Michonne: "I didn't know. "

Michonne notices a curious statement made on a National Park sign:

"PROTECT THE PARK FROM THE PEOPLE.
THE PEOPLE FROM THE PARK
AND THE PEOPLE FROM THE PEOPLE"


Before she can interpret its meaning, they run in the direction of screaming people, rescuing a trio from Walkers. Michonne offers the obviusly hungry people packs of noodles, only to have their kindness rewarded with the leader pulling a gun on the couple, demanding all of their provisions. Michonne and Rick quickly disarm the would-be robbers, trying to get them to promise not to pull that sort of ungrateful crap on anyone else. Michonne takes the noodles back, while tossing one of their emptied guns away.

That evening at the cabin, after Rick and Michonne contemplate why they did not hesitate in helping the trio, Rick gives Michonne the "M" necklace--the thoughtful modification leading to their rekindled passion. That evening, as the two sleep, a shadowy figure dismantles Rick's Walker trip wire, and carefully approaches the cabin...

THREE YEARS AGO

Father Gabriel prays for his canteen of water to be blessed as Holy Water, when he's approached by Jadis. Gabriel is cautious, unsure of her motivations, but he hugs her in any case. Jadis longed to see him again, but insists he keep her presence to himself. Gabriel observes she left Alexandria feeling she was still being judged for her past actions, but adds Rick brought her in, thinking people can change, and died holding to that belief. Jadis does not flinch, pretending she does not know the obvious, but is a bit too cool about this ordinarily tragic revelation.

Father Gabriel: "My mistake wasn't trusting you. It was losing my faith in you. Can you forgive me for that?"
Jadis: "What about...the people who can't forgive you? What about the one that you make 'gone'? How do you live with that?"
Father Gabriel: "Prayer. Amends? ...talk."
Jadis (her reaction clearly indicating she's not going to go the prayer route): "I can't talk about the things i've been a part of, things I will be a part of."
Father Gabriel: "Not even to your people?"
Jadis: "No. Not without telling them about all of you."
Father Gabriel: "You can talk to me. clergy confidentiality. You weren't even here, Anne."
Jadis (amused): "I forgive you."

In the present, an armed Jadis breaks in on Rick and Michonne, ordering the pair to tie each other up. She explains that after hearing about the helicopter crash, she joined the reclamation team to search the wreckage, spotting the yellow truck, yet on a second inspection of the rubble, the truck had been stolen. That, and a trail of discarded noodle packages led her right to the pair.

Operating as an analyst tag-team, Rick and Michonne speak at and around Jadis, irritating the woman, as expected, but Jadis has her own choice words for the pair--

Jadis: "You see, I've been thinking about someone else I killed. A confidant. Someone monumental in my development as...me. As a person who will help turn the world. I left things unsaid between us. I don't want to do that before I kill both of you."
Rick: "You just play games Anne, you don't give a shit about that army or that city!"
Jadis: "I--do! You think i'm still her. I'm not. I'm not that woman from the heaps, either. 'We take. We don't bother'. Didn't work. I am decorated Warrant Officer Jadis Stokes of the Civic Republic Military. Defender of the Republic--"
Rick: "You're doing this for you...Anne."
Jadis: "NO--for the Republic! If I were to let you go home, and somehow, so other enterprising warrant officer were to find you, my connection with Alexandria would be discovered, and that important work would end. I saved your life."
Michonne: "You took it! You took it from him! You took it from me! You took it from our children! All those years they grew up without their father?!? All those years I didn't know whether he was alive or dead!?"
Rick: "You stole our family, Anne!"

Jadis: "I didn't kill you in your sleep because I wanted--I needed to thank you. By dying here today, Alexandria will remain safe and your children will have a better world! You could have made other choices. But you didn't lose here. You went a different way, so its the end of your story. Let that be your peace."

Jadis fires at the pair, but they--anticipating the attempt--roll off of the bed in unison, Rick sliding under the bed, Michonne behind a door. Rick flips the bed over on Jadis, giving Michonne enough time to retrieve her hatchet, which she uses to hack into Jadis's rib cage.Michonne almost shoots Jadis, but rick slaps her arms down, wanting to catch her.

TWO YEARS AGO

Jadis travels to the forest for her annual meeting with Father Gabriel; they discuss Rick and Michonne, with Jadis learning they were never officially married. Father Gabriel recalls Rick once asking him to perform the marriage ceremony, but Father Gabriel had doubts about the meaning of it all, until he--sitting alone--spotted a ring that he believed would perfect for the occasion, but the bridge happened.

Jadis has come to look forward to her meetings with Father Gabriel, as it gives her a feeling of the woman she used to be, as opposed to the life she currently lives, which is centered on responsibility instead of personal connections...doing things that are--as she describes it--cruel.

Father Gabriel challenges her--asking if she's confessing--expressing doubts, he wonders if that cruel person is not who she is. Jadis rejects this, stating that the negative part of her who commits cruel acts--is the one that kept her alive, and can help keep the rest of the world alive. Father Gabriel reveals some of the struggles his people have had to face (referring to the Whisperers), and the dire consequences of those struggles, including but not limited to food insecurity for the children. He asks Jadis for help, but she flatly refuses, yet claims to feel remorse for her refusal. Father Gabriel gives her the ring (as a symbol of faith and love), with the hope that it will give her something she needs.

Jadis asks to meet Gabriel again next year, which he agrees to....if he's alive.

In the present, Rick and Michonne (arguing about why Jadis should not be killed) speed after Jadis, eventually running her off of the road. The pair find her car abandoned. Jadis has stumbled across the trio of vagabonds, promising shelter in exchange for protection.

Elsewhere, Rick explains that Jadis' dossier could be at any number of bases scattered across America, but they need to try talking to her to get that information, as Rick believes she could be reached by appealing to her discomfort in being addressed as "Anne" (reminded of the life she lived in that role).

The couple track Jadis to a converted shelter, searching every makeshift room, until they spot someone race by wearing Jadis' coat. It turns out to be the female member of the vagabonds, who is shaken to learn Rick and Michonne were the "bad people" Jadis enlisted them to lure into her trap. Michonne and Rick disarm the vagabonds (again) leaving it up to Jadis to fire wildly, only alerting Walkers to their location, and within seconds, the woman is taken down by Walkers. Her less-than-formidable companions race to help--and join her to become an easy meal.

ONE YEAR AGO

Father Gabriel and Jadis meet again; Jadis is thoughtful, regretting how each time she sees him, she has more blood on her hands. Father Gabriel asks why she comes back every year, where he could have her--to himself. He feels her coming back proves--contrary to her oft-stated claim--she is still here, as Anne. She kisses Father Gabriel, prompting him to ask her to return to Alexandria to be with him, which she brusquely rejects, while defending the purpose of her group, which Father Gabriel sees as cruel. Feeling vulnerable, Jadis now sees Gabriel as a loose end she needs to kill, which she prepares to do...

The present: Jadis, now alone, faces Rick & Michonne, but warns them if anything happens to her, their children will die. Michonne is quite hot-headed at this point (understandable), and is Hell-bent on killing Jadis, no matter what Rick says. Playing her biggest card--her life--Jadis stands with her arms out, testing Michonne as Walkers shuffle toward their next meal. Michonne draws her gun--considers allowing the Walkers to consume Jadis--until she accepts the bitter pill that the woman cannot be killed, and picks off the creatures...emptying her gun. Treachery abounds, with Jadis--taking advantage of the situation--fires at Michonne. Jadis attempts to play with Rick's mind, telling him he was on the ascent with the CRM, with Beale set to give him the Echelon Briefing.

Jadis: "Your eyes would have been opened to the true size and scope of what the CRM's gonna do to bring this world back. You could have insured Alexandria's security. But you didn't. You let Michonne pull you away from that. (to Michonne) All you had to do is leave! Rick arranged for your escape.But you didn't, and now, here we are. The fate of you friends--your children are sealed, because you are just like her--you look out for you."
Rick: "You don't really want to kill everyone back home, Anne. I know you don't!"
Jadis: "It's not about want. It's about keeping your humanity...or saving humanity! And it is a choice! I've chosen MY community--I've chosen MY life! So whose gonna die today?? The two of you? Or me? And everyone back home!"

Through the conversation, Michonne studies Rick, believing he is--once again--leaning in the direction of the CRM's propaganda. However, as the couple look into each other's eyes, it is clear they have concocted a scheme against Jadis:

Michonne: "She's right. Rick...I didn't want to see it, I wanted her dead, so I didn't have to see it. But Rick, there has to be a sacrifice.Since i found you, all that i've done has been for us. But now I see this can't end with us going home."

Rick promises to return to the CRM with Jadis, as long as she agrees to allow Michonne to go home, and not inform the CRM about Alexandria. On the condition everyone drop their weapons (and Michonne leave to find a med-kit), Rick emerges from hiding empty-handed, but Jadis--ever the liar--pulls one the vagabond's guns on Rick...

ONE YEAR AGO II

Jadis aims her gun at Father Gabriel, but he presses the notion that she--Anne--never left, and if he's wrong, she can shoot him...

The present: Michonne comes out of hiding, aiming a CRM rifle at Jadis; before she can issue yet another ultimatum, Walkers grab Jadis, biting into her throat. Rick dispatches the creatures, but it is obviously too late to save Jadis. Between her loss of blood from the hatchet wound and the bite, Jadis shakes and gasps incoherently--her energy rapidly fading.

Jadis (flashback to her interactions with the Heap people, Father Gabriel, et al.): "Everything I ever had...lost. My people...my friends. Everyone--was tired of losing. I-I was finally part of something that could've lasted...I couldn't lose another community. My old one...my new one...and I knew...if I didn't kill you all, somehow, some way you'd come to CRM, so I drew up the dossier, to protect myself and make sure you couldn't....I thought my death was worth it. I'd chosen a side, right? I thought I had..back and forth. Jadis...Anne..Alexandrians...CRM...

ONE YEAR AGO III


Father Gabriel stiffly waits for Jadis to shoot him. Instead, she shoots an approaching Walker, which Gabriel sees as the answer Jadis was seeking about who she is.

The present:

Jadis (thinking of Father Gabriel): "He already showed me. I found my answer. The dossier...its in my room..at the Cascadia base. J-just destroy it and go home. The CRM will bring the world back...tell me you won't come after them?"

Michonne: "No. Because we are coming after them. We're gonna get the dossier...and then, the CRM...we're gonna stop them. He's gonna get the Echelon Briefing, and find out everything they do that the city doesn't know about. the city I saw won't stand for what they are, and we're gonna help the city stop them, because....Anne...the CRM is not the answer. And they must...end. (to Rick) "we're gonna do that."

Rick's mind processes all Jadis has said, and reaches a startling conclusion:

Rick: "You kept us alive for a reason."
Jadis (now honest with herself--nothing to lose): "I wish I died an artist. It was never about survival. That life was just about truth. This is mine...the end of my story. My peace."

Jadis removes a necklace running through the ring Father Gabriel gave her, handing it to Rick while recalling how he wanted to marry Michonne. With her life coming to an end, Jadis asks Rick to marry Michonne. Rick takes it all in--then magnanimously shoots Jadis in the head, putting her out of her misery.

Rick and Michonne II: Backtracking through the woods, Rick acknowledges the full meaning of her "surrender" speech to Jadis--that it was meant for him. Michonne believes that together, they can change the world. Rick pauses...to propose to the love of his life:

Rick: "Michonne--wait. I've been wanting to say something. This broken world...Michonne...you're the only thing that puts it back together. 'till my last breath, I am yours."

Rick lowers himself to his knees, presenting the ring.

Michonne: "I could never have imagined this. But it could only have been you. I am yours."

Michonne also bends to her knees, the pair kissing, with their love for one another never stronger.

NOW

Father Gabriel returns to the forest, as its now another year, and time for a reunion with Jadis. Eventually, as time passes, the forlorn Father almost senses he will never see her again, his facial expression indicating he's guessed her likely fate.

NOTES:

As much as some viewers are praising the arc of Jadis, this episode's standout was the return of Father Gabriel, and his patient dealings with Jadis. For Gabriel to be satisfied with a single visit every year shows not only how connected he was to Jadis, but it raises the question of the timeline of the meetings--whether they all occurred after the events of TWD's series finale.

Jadis initially began as a recurring antagonist, then a semi-trustworthy ally. Her eventual turn to full-on villain in the spin-offs did not always work, as her story did not seem to have much behind it. This one episode changed all of that, with Father Gabriel patiently working on what he viewed as her true self. While she was certainly conflicted--right up to her end--its clear the level of love and dedication Rick and Michonne have for each other did serve as the inspiration for her final, genuine confession about changing the world, and wanting Rick to marry Michonne.

Jadis' death was sort of reminiscent of Andrea's from The Walking Dead's season 3 finale, "Welcome to the Tombs" (E16), where Andrea--like Jadis--was bitten in the neck, and gives a few parting words about her intent with partial regret, before a bullet (self-inflicted in Andrea's case) ended their lives.

Once again, a series in the survival horror genre soars above most current and recent fantasy series, and its accomplishing that with some amazingly frank, mature exchanges between the leads.

Next: "The Last Time" - the season one finale; Rick and Michonne risk it all to destroy Jadis' dossier, and begin to strike a blow at the CRM...but being a season finale (instead of a series wrap-up), will it end with a cliffhanger? Will that "last breath" declaration come back to haunt Rick or Michonne?

GRADE: A++.
 
For Gabriel to be satisfied with a single visit every year shows not only how connected he was to Jadis, but it raises the question of the timeline of the meetings--whether they all occurred after the events of TWD's series finale.

If the season premiere "Years" is set five years after the TWD episode "What Comes After" - then the subsequent meetings between Jadis and Father Gabriel started two years after "What Comes After" and ran for three years, up until the present day. That means more than likely means that Father Gabriel was meeting with Jadis sometime between events of the final seasons of "The Walking Dead".
 
In the "Three Years Ago" flashback, Gabriel mentions trying to reach Jadis on Eugene's ham radio, and talks about Rosita in the present tense, implying she's still around, so that's obviously before TWD ended. Possibly during S9, when Eugene first got the radio running. The "Two Years Ago" flashback makes a direct reference to the Whisperers attacking, so that's during S10. The "One Year Ago" flashback might be during the interim year between the end of the main story in the finale and the epilogue scene.
 
In the "Three Years Ago" flashback, Gabriel mentions trying to reach Jadis on Eugene's ham radio, and talks about Rosita in the present tense, implying she's still around, so that's obviously before TWD ended.

Yes--good catch--I was focused on Jadis being closer to the present day, and assumed all of the Father Gabriel meetings were post-TWD finale.
 
This was certainly an enjoyable show. My one main complaint is that the ending is a bit too convenient, what with
all the CRM's corrupt and evil people being present for that event and therefore killed and with them gone, the Civic Republic's civilian leadership has asserted control of what's left of the military and turned it into a force for good.
It all seems way too sudden and way too convenient and makes the happy ending feel somewhat rushed.

But otherwise this has been one hell of a great show which I have enjoyed the hell out of. Solid entertainment.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top