• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Marvel's Echo on Disney+

Roles can be rewritten to fit their performers. Echo in the comics doesn't have a prosthetic leg; the character was given that trait because the actress they chose as the best candidate for the role happened to have a prosthetic leg. It's no different from changing, say, Heimdall's ethnicity to fit Idris Elba, or changing the New York-born Charles Xavier into an Englishman to fit Patrick Stewart. So there's no reason in the world why Alaqua Cox couldn't play a character who wasn't originally conceived as Native American, deaf, or having a prosthetic. They'd simply adjust the character to fit the person they cast, as films and TV shows have been doing for generations.

Of course it's by no means impossible, but Skipper isn't exactly wrong to say that Hollywood doesn't tend to cast Native Americans, deaf people or people with prosthetics in lead roles that often, especially in projects that aren't explicitly intended to be about that specific group.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Of course it's by no means impossible, but Skipper isn't exactly wrong to say that Hollywood doesn't tend to cast Native Americans, deaf people or people with prosthetics in lead roles that often, especially in projects that aren't explicitly intended to be about that specific group.

Exactly. The default or imposed standard is generic White man #305 (though they're less generic these days) and any attempt to address that is hit with whining from anti-woke types
 
Why can't I just feel sorry for Cox? Perhaps she doesn't need my sympathy, but this is my reaction to a series I had hoped I would enjoy. I had enjoyed her performance in "Hawkeye" and hoped I would enjoy "Echo". But I didn't. And many seemed more concerned about Daredevil and Fisk than they are about Echo. At least to me.

Why do you react as if I'm not allowed to have different opinions about "Echo"? That was me expressing my honest feelings about the series. I'm not simply trying to be contrary or anything like that.
I'm not being sarcastic here, I'm honestly confused by why you feel sorry for her. What's there to feel sorry for?
She's newcomer actress who's second ever job, is that the lead character on a Marvel show which seems to be getting a fairly decent reception. There a lot of people who spend decades acting never find that kind of success. She's incredibly lucky, and I don't see any reason to feel sorry for her.
I don't really see anything to feel sorry for.
 
Photos of Alaqua Cox in New York have appeared online leading to speculation that Maya may appear in DBA since that series is now filming again. Again, that is speculation.
 
I finished Echo. It was a lot better than I expected with all the schedule shifts I got the impression Disney was trying to bury it.
Although I had the same problem with it that I had with Monarch. I missed big chunks of the story because of the Captions/ Subtitles. Being dyslexic makes it impossible to keep up so I ignore them.
 
I know I say this every time with an Assembled episode (and I'll keep saying it for as long as it's true!), but I absolutely love watching seeing so many people clearly having the time of their lives in producing this series.

Far more importantly, I'm blown by the incredible work that went behind the scenes to make everything as authentic as possible in direct, deep coordination with the Choctaw people at every level of the production from day one. From the extensive bead work on Maya's hero costume that carefully reflected her people, their culture, and their history, to how the production flew in professional stickball players and Choctaw powwow dancers in their full personal regalia to portray those particular characters instead of just regular background actors. The production team went above and beyond to represent the Choctaw culture in such a positive, truthful manner. I wasn't surprised to learn that their representatives were naturally hesitant about Marvel's intentions in making this show, but I'm glad they were convinced the producers wanted to create the best story possible with their direct guidance and approval.

Along with properly representing the Choctaw people, I was thrilled by how far the production went into making the deaf community feel seen. I had already known that the cast and crew spent several weeks learning ASL, but it was still such a joy seeing Alaqua Cox glowing with pride that Marvel honored her request when they asked her if there was anything they could do to make her feel more comfortable on set. Something I hadn't realized until this special is that Katarina Ziervogel, who played Taloa, Maya's mother, is also a deaf actress. I can only hope that future productions of shows and films that star deaf actors will also go to such great lengths in accommodating actors such as Cox and Ziervogel.

Considering the previously released deep dive about the Daredevil/Echo fight, I wasn't expecting anything here, so I was pleasantly surprised to see Charlie Cox briefly speak about his experience (and reminding us he's British). He pointed out something I didn't even think about because I was just too engrossed with the fight: Both of them were fighting with significant disabilities and an important part of their fight was them realizing that about each other and then trying use that knowledge against each other.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top