• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Dave Filoni Named Chief Creative Officer at Lucasfilm

Is this the part where I start complaining about a woke agenda, despite the fact Filoni is a white guy?

;)
Well, his spotlight character is a woman, so he obviously must hate other men.
:lol:
It's worth keeping in mind for everyone freaking out because they didn't like some of his recent stuff, that this more of a consulting or oversight role, so he's not going to be writing or creating everything himself.
 
He has helped make some of the most popular stories in Star Wars.
All subjective I realise, but of his stuff I only really like Mando seasons one and two, and Ahsoka. I dislike Clone Wars, Bad Batch, Rebels and whatever the other animated show was.

So hardly promising from my point of view.
 
It's worth keeping in mind for everyone freaking out because they didn't like some of his recent stuff, that this more of a consulting or oversight role, so he's not going to be writing or creating everything himself.
It's not just his recent stuff I don't like.
 
He sometimes has good instincts.

Other times, not so much.

Isn't this the guy who said Han can't understand Chewbacca?
 
I think people are missing the real interesting part of the story, which is Carrie Beck's promotion; if anyone is being groomed to take Kennedy's place when she retires it's Beck. As head of development, she's going to be the one really deciding what pitches do and donnot get made.
So... someone with no apparent real-world experience outside of the antiseptic, emotionally stunted hallways of Lucasfilm animation, who, unlike Kennedy, never had firsthand experience of working with the likes of Spielberg and Zemeckis? That doesn't inspire much confidence, but, time will tell.
 
Just out of curiosity, what makes you call Lucasfilm antiseptic, and emotionally stunted? I've never really heard much about the working environment there, is it really that bad?
 
Plus, way to try and make it sound like Beck is some weird little kid who grew up in Skywalker Ranch and has never ventured beyond the gates. ;)
 
There could be a bit more connection between different shows and films as they go along. Remember that the Pergill were from a seemingly filler-like episode. Now they are massively important to two series and referenced in two other series. Just because it seems unimportant doesn't mean Filloni won't go back and make it important later on.
 
Remember that the Pergill were from a seemingly filler-like episode.
I never had that impression. Ezra's taming of the purrgil in "The Call" was quite significant, as was the encounter of living creatures capable of jumping into hyperspace. The whole episode began and ended with the purrgil defining the action.

Plus those Mining Guild TIEs were cool AF.

:shrug:
 
"filler 13. (television, music) material of lower cost or quality that is used to fill a certain television time slot or physical medium, such as a music album" [https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/filler#Noun]

This aligns with how the term has been used for decades, for example under the idea that the filler on a record album is inferior to the hits.

:shrug:
 
So...never change?

'Cause Lucas made the OT. Then the PT.

Sometimes people get things wrong.

I believe the mistakes that Lucas had made were sanctioning the return of Maul in "The Clone Wars" and selling Lucasfilm to Disney.
 
This aligns with how the term has been used for decades, for example under the idea that the filler on a record album is inferior to the hits.
Depends on who you're talking to. Certain people like to declare "filler!" anytime a given episode doesn't (in their view) contain some major revelation, advance the metanarrative plot, upset the status quo somehow, or most often then not: they just didn't like it very much. Whether these assessments have any objective merit is besides the point; they get thrown around all the same.
For proof, look no further than literally every show/season's spoiler thread on this forum for the last two decades.
 
I believe the mistakes that Lucas had made were sanctioning the return of Maul in "The Clone Wars" and selling Lucasfilm to Disney.

Me too, on both counts.

There was a one-shot anthology comic years ago called Visionaries in which Maul made his return with a mechanical lower half, to fight Obi-wan in the desert where, ironically, Owen Lars killed him with a blaster shot to the side of the head after a ferocious lightsaber duel. I think this was the inspiration for Maul's return, and I wish they'd just let him stay dead. Everything he did in TCW could have been done by Asaaj Ventress.

And the fight presented in Visionaries was re-imagined in the Rebels episode Twin Suns, where Kenobi and Maul have that final duel on Tatooine, resulting in Maul's demise.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top