You can have one more season of your favorite Trek series, BUT...

[Qonundrum]

Obtain: TOS Season 4
Discard: DS9 Season 7

Obtain: TNG Season 8
Discard: PIC Season 1


Honorable mentions that stray from the original premise:

Obtain: Prodigy
Discard: ENT

Obtain: TNG with Dr Pulaski in seasons 3-7
Discard: ENT seasons 1-3

Obtain: TNG with Dr Crusher in seasons 3-7 but still having the comparative depth of season 1
Discard: Any character in 21st century Trek that says the F-word and isn't a drawn cartoon

 

[ED-209]

Can I do it multiple times?

S1 DSC for Ent S5
S3 DSC For Ent S6
S4 DSC For Ent S7

Pic S1 for DS9 S8
Pic S2 for Voy S8 (post alpha quadrant return at least half the series).

 

[Oddish]

Can I do it multiple times?

S1 DSC for Ent S5
S3 DSC For Ent S6
S4 DSC For Ent S7

Pic S1 for DS9 S8
Pic S2 for Voy S8 (post alpha quadrant return at least half the series).

I'll go along with that, as long as on ENT, they carry out their plan to have Shran as a regular cast member.

 

[JonnyQuest037]

Can I do it multiple times?

You're not supposed to, but practically everyone has been ignoring that. I wanted people to make tough choices.

 

[Oddish]

As an ultimate silly example...
Delete all of TOS, TAS, DS9, VOY, ENT, DIS, LD, PRO, PIC, ST, and SNW... and get a total of 45 seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation!

 

[ED-209]

You're not supposed to, but practically everyone has been ignoring that. I wanted people to make tough choices.

If I could only do one, S4 of DSC for Ent S5 - but it wasn’t a “tough choice” at all.

 

[fireproof78]

You're not supposed to, but practically everyone has been ignoring that. I wanted people to make tough choices.

I mean, I would give up most of the Berman era for more TOS, and Phase II.

Unfortunately, I do not have the attitude that this is a "tough choice."

 

[ED-209]

21 more seasons of TOS and 21 seasons of Phase 2? Damn they’d be “so very tired” by the end of that.

 

[fireproof78]

21 more seasons of TOS and 21 seasons of Phase 2? Damn they’d be “so very tired” by the end of that.

Whose "they?"

If you're including me in the "they" then that's not accurate.

TOS always has an appeal to me, the wacky and wooly.

 

[ED-209]

The cast, sorry thought that was obvious.

 

[hbquikcomjamesl]

I'd also preemptively trade the entire run of a (thankfully still hypothetical, so far as I'm aware) Section 31 series for another season of almost anything else (that includes non-ST series: like maybe Crusade continuing until the Drakh plague is dealt with, or even another season of My Mother, the Car. But not another season of The Bachelor, or Survivor, or anything else of that ilk.)

 

[fireproof78]

The cast, sorry thought that was obvious.

If NCIS can do it, Trek can do it.

 

[Lord Garth]

I'd also preemptively trade the entire run of a (thankfully still hypothetical, so far as I'm aware) Section 31 series for another season of almost anything else (that includes non-ST series: like maybe Crusade continuing until the Drakh plague is dealt with, or even another season of My Mother, the Car. But not another season of The Bachelor, or Survivor, or anything else of that ilk.)

S31 is going to be a TV Movie. Not much of "an entire run". More like "an entire two hours, including ads!"

 

[Lord Garth]

I have a new answer for this question. I wouldn't have bumped the thread after nine months if I wasn't serious about it.

Chop out ENT Season 2.
Add DSC Season 6.

That's my definitive answer, going forward. I don't see my opinion changing on this for a long, long time. If ever. There'd have to be another Star Trek series which doesn't exist yet that I'll really like where I'll also think it ended too soon.

 

[JonnyQuest037]

I have a new answer for this question. I wouldn't have bumped the thread after nine months if I wasn't serious about it.

Chop out ENT Season 2.
Add DSC Season 6.

That's my definitive answer, going forward. I don't see my opinion changing on this for a long, long time. If ever. There'd have to be another Star Trek series which doesn't exist yet that I'll really like where I'll also think it ended too soon.

Thank you for playing the game in the spirit in which it was intended.

 

[Anduinel]

PIC S2 axed for DS9 S8.
PIC S3 axed for PRO S3.

 

[BillJ]

S31 is going to be a TV Movie. Not much of "an entire run". More like "an entire two hours, including ads!"

So, 45 minutes for those of us that have the commercial free version?

 

[Lord Garth]

So, 45 minutes for those of us that have the commercial free version?

Guess I'll find out! I cancelled my Paramount+ subscription but will pick up the commercial-free plan for a month, to watch Section 31, before I dip out again.

 

[evilchumlee]

Easy.

DS9 Season 8 and 9. Buh bye DSC 1 and 2
ENT Season 5, 6, and 7. Bug bye DSC 3, 4, 5.

I'm satisfied now. That's good.

Give me a Season 4 and 5 of PIC rebranded Legacy and you can take SNW too.

 

[kkt]

21 more seasons of TOS and 21 seasons of Phase 2? Damn they’d be “so very tired” by the end of that.

If they stuck with the same actors, they'd be pretty sick of it by then.