The better screamer: Harry or Tom?
- Thread starter Ragitsu
- Start date
I'd say Kim.
Though no one can top Kes in that deparment.
Though no one can top Kes in that deparment.
Robert Duncan McNeill in "Alice". You aren't considering Harry Kim's scream in "Caretaker"?
I was prepared to dislike "Alice," which is one of those I never saw in the original run, on first viewing.
I liked it. Robbie did an excellent job. I did, however, think the guest actress made some odd choices. That could have also been directorial; perhaps the desired approach to the entity was to make "Alice" seem more alien, hence the somewhat odd line deliveries. Still, that held the ep back for me.
But yes - outstanding scream in the turbolift. No question. Garrett was no slouch himself in the screaming department, but I'll give this one to Robbie.
I liked it. Robbie did an excellent job. I did, however, think the guest actress made some odd choices. That could have also been directorial; perhaps the desired approach to the entity was to make "Alice" seem more alien, hence the somewhat odd line deliveries. Still, that held the ep back for me.
But yes - outstanding scream in the turbolift. No question. Garrett was no slouch himself in the screaming department, but I'll give this one to Robbie.
Last edited:
That wide-eyed stare of hers resulted in her performance vacillating between "conventional drug addict" and "supernatural entity" (supernatural because she seemed possessed of a boundless mania).
Can you recall any examples besides the Ceti eel invasion?
Which episode in particular?
0:35 - best scream from anyone, ever. Vocal cadence modulation yet mouth and throat remain motionless. Now that's sum good actin'!
Similar threads
