\Which Chief of s\ecurity would win in a fight?

to death or incapacitation. Hand combat only, no phasers, no batleths etc (exception:FSNPs alowwed)

 

Wouldn't Odo have an unfair advantage, being a changeling? Or does 'hand combat only' imply that Odo also is not allowed to morph into a (supposedly much stronger) lifeform?

 

Maybe the others can beat him enough he must regenerate but has no bucket available

 

Martok insisted that a Klingon should rightly fear the deadlines of changelings in CHIMERA.

Odo wins.

 

Whichever one has time to prepare.

 

Odo, no contest.

Of those remaining, Worf, then Tuvok.

 

Do we judge Worf only on when he was actually chief of security? Because he only got proper good after he lost that job.

 

Odo does his "long arm of the law" trick and trips, entangles, or strangles them all. It's not even a contest.

Only person who might have a chance is Tasha... she's a lot like Kira, so maybe Odo might fall in love with her.

 

La'an. She's related to Khan.

 

Depends on the plot

 

If Anakin could have turned into a hawk like Odo can, the high ground might not have mattered much.

 

If you disallow beam weapons, it’s Odo and not even close,

 

And if you allow them...

 

This poll has a distinct lack of Nhan.

 

Odo, no question, he’s way above the others.

 

If must:

All of them including Giotto and Nham and whoever else I missed plus a rabid Lematya, all naked in the Thunderdome, and Odo can't morph

 

Always Giotto.

 

My dad could beat your dad.