I forgot DS9 even had a disappearing planet episode. Shows how much of an impression "Meridian" made on me.
What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?
- Thread starter Amasov
- Start date
I'm just now looking at this thread, but I'm with you on this one, Amasov. And yes, The Wrath of Kahn was a good movie, but I also don't think that it was as great as everyone else does. And as a matter of fact, I always thought that the sequel The Search for Spock, was much better than The Wrath of Khan.
Also, I probably shouldn't mention this, but I realize that Ricard Montalban had a receding hair line and therefore, he had to wear those bangs, but there was just something about his bangs that took something away from the character to me, compare to how his hair looked on TOS.
Additionally, even though, I thought that the story of Star Trek: The Motion Picture wasn't great, I did think that this movie was aesthetically and visually impressive. I even like the pastel-colored uniforms more so than the monotonous red uniforms that the entire crew wore in all the following TOS movies.
TMP vs. TWOK --> TMP has better visuals, but TWOK overall.
TSFS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
TVH vs. TWOK --> TVH is fun, but TWOK.
TFF vs. TWOK --> TWOK
TUC vs. TWOK --> TWOK. TUC has 1991 written all over it.
GEN vs. TWOK --> TWOK
FC vs. TWOK --> This is the only serious competition.
INS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
NEM vs. TWOK --> TWOK
2009 vs. TWOK --> TWOK. The 2009 Film is a Comic Book Movie.
ID vs. TWOK --> TWOK, all the way. It's not even close.
BEY vs. TWOK --> TWOK. I don't even remember BEY.
TSFS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
TVH vs. TWOK --> TVH is fun, but TWOK.
TFF vs. TWOK --> TWOK
TUC vs. TWOK --> TWOK. TUC has 1991 written all over it.
GEN vs. TWOK --> TWOK
FC vs. TWOK --> This is the only serious competition.
INS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
NEM vs. TWOK --> TWOK
2009 vs. TWOK --> TWOK. The 2009 Film is a Comic Book Movie.
ID vs. TWOK --> TWOK, all the way. It's not even close.
BEY vs. TWOK --> TWOK. I don't even remember BEY.
TMP vs. TWOK --> TMP is better than its rep suggests... but TWOK takes it.
TSFS vs. TWOK --> Toss-up, they're both great.
TVH vs. TWOK --> TVH. The benchmark.
TFF vs. TWOK --> TWOK. Best part of TFF was the "Row Row Row Your Boat" scene.
I need to see TUC again.
GEN vs. TWOK --> TWOK by a mile.
FC vs. TWOK --> Another toss-up, they're great in different ways.
INS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
NEM vs. TWOK --> TWOK. Like comparing a steak with a sawdust casserole.
2009 vs. TWOK --> TWOK, but 2009 was fun.
Haven't seen the other Kelvin films, it's on my to-do list.
TSFS vs. TWOK --> Toss-up, they're both great.
TVH vs. TWOK --> TVH. The benchmark.
TFF vs. TWOK --> TWOK. Best part of TFF was the "Row Row Row Your Boat" scene.
I need to see TUC again.
GEN vs. TWOK --> TWOK by a mile.
FC vs. TWOK --> Another toss-up, they're great in different ways.
INS vs. TWOK --> TWOK
NEM vs. TWOK --> TWOK. Like comparing a steak with a sawdust casserole.
2009 vs. TWOK --> TWOK, but 2009 was fun.
Haven't seen the other Kelvin films, it's on my to-do list.
I appreciate that it gives solid evidence of timeline corruption, since I use it to explain the 23rd century's visual reboot(tm).
V
Vale
Guest
I don't care about the age difference so much as the fact that Harry is basically Linnis's uncle. That's all kinds of wrong.
Just watching The Communicator (Enterprise).
Don't know if this is a controversial opinion, but I think they are risking far more contamination by going back to find that communicator than by just leaving it be. (And as we see in the rest of the episode, they take huge risks.) I don't think a world on par with 1940's level of technology would learn too much from a 2150's communicator. Their research equipment would probably be too primitive, and they'd even lack the required theoretical understanding.
But next time perhaps they should build in self destruct on such items that can be activated remotely. Just for cases like these.
Don't know if this is a controversial opinion, but I think they are risking far more contamination by going back to find that communicator than by just leaving it be. (And as we see in the rest of the episode, they take huge risks.) I don't think a world on par with 1940's level of technology would learn too much from a 2150's communicator. Their research equipment would probably be too primitive, and they'd even lack the required theoretical understanding.
But next time perhaps they should build in self destruct on such items that can be activated remotely. Just for cases like these.
It doesn't get any better in the rest of the episode.
Archer and Malcolm: "Oops, can't tell these people that we're aliens, that would be cultural contamination. Better make this nation, that's already on the brink of a devastating war, believe that we're genetically engineered super soldiers with prototype weapons from the other side. That'll probably have less severe impact."
Archer and Malcolm: "Oops, can't tell these people that we're aliens, that would be cultural contamination. Better make this nation, that's already on the brink of a devastating war, believe that we're genetically engineered super soldiers with prototype weapons from the other side. That'll probably have less severe impact."
TOS and how it handled leaving behind advanced technology also did it awkwardly but at least Kirk just accepted that the contamination had already taken place 100 years before and McCoy's communicator wasn't going to be a life or death situation. If anything Kirk, Spock and McCoy all mused on how the inhabitants of Sigma Iotia II would back-engineer his communicator and one day be as advanced as Starfleet.
On to the next planet! After all, Kirk was already going to have to explain to Starfleet Command why Starfleet was going to have to visit Sigma Iotia II every year to collect a monetary cut of a deal that Starfleet Command had nothing to do with.
On to the next planet! After all, Kirk was already going to have to explain to Starfleet Command why Starfleet was going to have to visit Sigma Iotia II every year to collect a monetary cut of a deal that Starfleet Command had nothing to do with.
On to the next planet! After all, Kirk was already going to have to explain to Starfleet Command why Starfleet was going to have to visit Sigma Iotia II every year to collect a monetary cut of a deal that Starfleet Command had nothing to do with.
Why hasn't LOWER DECKS done an episode that returns to Sigma Iotia II to collect the Federation's piece of the action?! Whelp, I have another spec script to write.
With a stop at Ceti Alpha V(I) to check in on the deposed superman and his red-shirt deserter.TOS and how it handled leaving behind advanced technology also did it awkwardly but at least Kirk just accepted that the contamination had already taken place 100 years before and McCoy's communicator wasn't going to be a life or death situation. If anything Kirk, Spock and McCoy all mused on how the inhabitants of Sigma Iotia II would back-engineer his communicator and one day be as advanced as Starfleet.
On to the next planet! After all, Kirk was already going to have to explain to Starfleet Command why Starfleet was going to have to visit Sigma Iotia II every year to collect a monetary cut of a deal that Starfleet Command had nothing to do with.
Still, “A Piece of the Action” had the best freeze-frame ever.
"I'm gonna make Starfleet an offer they can't refuse!"
Wasn’t that going to be the original plot of the DS9 anniversary episode the became Trials and Tribbleations? I could swear I read that before.
Yep. It was one of many ideas pitched.
You know, that could still be a 60th anniversary episode. And with so many shows on now, any of them can do it... including any future shows.
And it's the best suited show to do it, given it's a little over a century since Kirk visited the planet.
Something tells me if Lower Decks does do anything with Sigma Iotia it'll likely just be a brief scene in one episode. Similar to the bit with Landru in the season 1 finale.
Similar threads
- Locked
