The Walking Dead
Season 11 - Episode 12 - "The Lucky Ones"
Eugene and Max: In a voiceover, Max recalls how her contact with Eugene began--from her stumbling across discarded radio parts & making it functional again, to getting to know Eugene. She also recalls how her signal was intercepted, leading Mercer to question what would make her risk her life agreeing to meet a stranger at the railyards (hence the reason fake Stephanie was sent there as a plant) and expose the Commonwealth, particularly because it would be dangerous for the siblings (SEE NOTES).
Seeing Eugene with someone pretending to be her hurt, but she would not reveal herself. Still angered by his conversation with Hornsby, Eugene questions Max about his plans for his communities, but Max claims to have no idea what Hornsby's goal is regarding Alexandria. Eugene--still smarting from the deception of it all--leaves.
Sitting alongside the lake, Eugene's still depressed, Rosita joins him, listening to his self-edited story about fake Stephanie. Rosita comforts her old friend, promising him that he will find the right woman for him.
That evening, Eugene visits Max, offering ice cream as an olive branch; Max is still upset, demanding to know how Eugene could believe fake Stephanie was the real deal. Eugene admits that he just fell into believing she was the real woman, despite fake Stephanie not sharing any of the things he discussed with Max over the radio. Eugene apologizes and prepares to leave when Max asks about his manuscript; this opens the door to the pair exchanging ideas about character and plot, which seems to thaw the ice between them....
Pamela, Hornsby and Maggie: A caravan of Commonwealth troopers (including Mercer and Daryl back in his street clothes) escort Pamela and Hornsby into Alexandria. Pamela sees Hornsby's ambitions as a potential threat to the Commonwealth by expanding to two small communities--stretching their resources.
At Alexandria, Aaron goes back into "official greeter" mode, welcoming the caravan. Mercer asks Daryl about the history of the community, if he was one of the leaders, and what Daryl was doing pre-apocalypse. Later, inside of what used to be Deanna's home, Pamela sees a photo of Reg and Deanna, telling Daryl they use to meet on occasion in philanthropic circles. She's fairly impressed by what Alexandria started out to be, but sees how so much fell apart and as Daryl points out, had to be rebuilt time and again.
Making their way to the Hilltop, the caravan runs into Maggie (and others) killing off a walker roadblock, Daryl introduces her to Pamela and Hornsby. Attempting to feel out the situation, Pamela asks everyone to go hunting, pairing off with Maggie, where the two debate the merits of each other's leadership styles, with Maggie pointing out that she does not need to take on material trappings to convince others to aspire to be like her--Pamela's way of running the Commonwealth.
After Oceanside refuses to join (out of loyalty to Maggie), Hornsby sees his grand plan falling apart. Still, he brings much-needed supplies to Hilltop (with Mercer letting Hershel wear his helmet). He attempts to convince Maggie that they share the same goals, going as far as to ask her to imagine a day when she could take Hershel to college, or sail up the coast to other thriving communities, but she turns him down, rankling Hornsby, though he tries to hide it.
Pamela is no fool; she approves Hornsby trying to bring in other communities, but if his work at the commonwealth suffers, there will be consequences. Later, a clearly pissed off and scheming Hornsby intentionally draws walkers to him, just to pick the off. Aaron cautiously approaches him but is assured that things are moving forward...that they will remake the world (SEE NOTES).
Carol and Ezekiel: Sigh. Presumably, Ezekiel was aware that access and/or services were earned through work or favors, so his being so outraged that Carol worked to move him up the surgery schedule (when other suffering patients need surgery as much as he does) was...kind of ridiculous. If favors move mountains, that's how the Commonwealth works, and he should accept that--and reap the benefits of Carol's heartfelt reasons for working with Hornsby. As Carol pointed out, he should not suffer because the Commonwealth's medical system is broken. Ultimately, Ezekiel stops protesting and admits himself into the hospital for surgery.
Ezekiel's reaction is absolutely
not ridiculous, especially not for him. Despite being a self-proclaimed King, he is NOT a harsh ruler like the xurrent and previous Governor. The royalty part is more like uplifting cosplay; Ezekiel actually cares for people , all people.
Again, unlike Milton, Ezekiel never took advantage of his status as leader (His son was training to be a blue colar worker). He was also never asked his thoughts about "cheating" in the line. A price has already been paid, that he never asked for. He also realizes that by him getting ahead, others could die as a result of the delay. His character reminds me of Chicago Bears great Walter Payton, who did NOT use his clout get the transplant he depserately needed.
He also told Carol "you can't b.s. the b.s.'er",so when she said she did some favors, he knew it was no small task, and the weight of what she was willing to do. He knows what she is capable of more than most.
I will expect feelings of guilt later, especially if he hears of a patient who died due to a delayed surgery. E
His cure was telegraphed way back when we heard Miko's brothr is thorasic surgeon. So ezekiel will survive (maybe join Ride with Darryl & Carol). But i expect Miko's brother to also feel some guilt, maybe even break down during the show.
NOTES:
Much implied in this episode, such as the potential for a conflict between Hornsby and Pamela. She's no fool and is fully aware of Hornsby's quest to run things his way, so I can see one or both characters not surviving to the series finale.
You are absolutely right on that... but with the CRM... will they play a role in the series finale...or just be this looming threat that leads to the Rick movies? How many more episodes left in part 2? WOnder if something will happen, maybe at the cliffhanger?
Speaking of surviving, we already know Maggie lives on to appear in her spin-off, so she's in no real danger. Knowing that did not prevent the writers from building real tension / territorial behavior between Maggie and Pamela, but of course, suspicion falls squarely on Hornsby, who is so incensed that Maggie refused his offer, that one should expect him to plot against her.
Definitely the question is if Hilltop will completely fall. Losing Diane is huge -- anyone we know who is left?
In the flashback, Mercer said Max's rule breaking would be dangerous for them...as if they are on some sort of shaky ground in the Commonwealth. This could play into the reason Mercer--as a "general" had his orders ignored at the hospital...
I dunno if THATis the reson why the prisoner was taken at the hospital... or more that he knows the system -- and ONLY Milton has full clout... he might have been fooled by his receent popularity. But he has been around long enough to know how things are
really run.
That is why he was so fearful of Max.... he knows what could happen. Max is smart enough to know too, but may have been so fed up, she didn't care any more.
Eugene was hurt, but I'm glad he finally came around to not being so shitty toward Max; she might be his only insider protection / early warning system should things go south (and usually, they do).
Hopefully, this will
not end in tragedy. They work well together
Small but sweet moment: Judith sent a jar of candy to Hershel--a treat he's never experienced before.
Didn't catch that. Thanks fo rthe insight
Mercer seems to be warming up to Daryl, but he is warning him that everyone has a role to play if they're to live in the Commonwealth.
GRADE: A.
Again, Mercer knows how the system is
really run, and Darryl has earned enough respect that Mercer wants him to succeed.
For some reason the final scene between Eugene and Max was heartwarming to me. Nice to see two people just being real amid so much pretending.
Definitely, but also nice that Eugene also owns up to how his previous deception had hurt people before, so he kind sees the justice in it.
I assume we're leading up to some confrontation between Hornsby and Maggie, and while we know Maggie is in no real danger, I wonder who will be caught in the fallout. If Maggie is going to end up in New York with Negan, what does that mean for Hilltop and her people?
And are Hilltop, Alexandria and Oceanside really just pawns in Hornsby's play for power, or is there more? Pamela isn't forthcoming about what the Commonealth wants with the three communities, and that is a logical question for Maggie to ask. What's in it for the Commonwealth? Pamela's vision for the future seems too simple.
Pamela never really wanted the communites to join -- she said it herself. She was more indulging Hornsby. I have to go back and review old episodes now, to see who knew what and when. But if Hornsby knows all about our characters (through the interview process), then he know how strong they are, and he could use them against Milton.
One question on Oceanside.... are they just kinda window dressing now? Cyndie used to be the leader, but she has disappeared. Is Sydney Park busy wth other gigs? And since Luke (who we last saw immigrating to Oceanside) is a guy, he's nowhere near Oceanside leadership, right?
That was good. I am wondering what Honrsby's angle is so will be looking forward to seeing what that is. I'm not sure Alexandria et al provide much in the way of armed forces he could use, or is his plan to use them as convenient places to dump malcontents? There is a real Saul Goodman quality to him which makes me struggle to see him as a threat, though he's clearly not as weak as I initially took him to be.
I think Maggie's wrong, I think Daryl's right, better to be on the inside surely, especially when you're struggling to survive and given Hilltop has lost people in the wake of this surely that survival becomes even harder. I'm kinda surprised Lydia didn't walk as well.
being on the outside allows for freedom, and not subject to another's rule. Times are really tough now, but if they can ride it out, it will be worth it.
That said there's clearly something unsettling about the Commonwealth stormtroopers and Maggie sees that.
i wonder what Maggie saw when she was out wandering the country. (And that seems like a viable 6th series, if needed...though i guess we will get flashbacks in Isle of the Dead
I loved that when Eugene was trying to reconcile Max's lies he harked back to his own likes to Rosita and Abraham. That was a really nice call-back.
Daryl and Mercer have a very interesting dynamic.
I feared Ezekiel would turn down the surgery when he discovered what Carol had done. Glad he didn't, unless there's some rub pull coming!
I appreciate all of those too. Definitely can't wait to see what comes of all 3 things you mentioned.
THANK YOU! Ever since first seeing him I've thought the guy who plays Hornsby looks like a Bargain Basement Bob Odenkirk. Nice to see I'm not the only one who sees a similarity.
Ditto, just seemed really obvious and nice to know I'm not the person who sees the resemblance!
I also noticed the resemblance, and a bit of personality.
It's content creation for the AMC+ streaming service. Without WD that whole service dies. The new shows will surely be VERY low budget, and if they even air on mainstream cable will have very low ratings. Wouldn't have survived in the world TWD thrived in.
Yeah, i am not sure why they stil have AMC+, or not incorporate it into another service. Definitely low on the poll for our family. We pay for Netlix and Disney Plus, get HBOMax and Apple+ free due to our phone subscriptions... and i am waiting for a good time to binger Paramount+. No budget for more.
The new Dead shows will be as "cheap" as World Beyond...and they might start them as "limited series", so as not to shoot down expectations when it fails in the ratings (World Beyond wasn't advertised as a limite dseries until i think the very end of season 1, if not preparing for season 2).